Esso Standard Oil v. Mujica Cotto ( 2008 )

United States Court of Appeals For the First Circuit No. 07-1218 ESSO STANDARD OIL CO. (PUERTO RICO), Plaintiff, Appellee, v. CARLOS W. LÓPEZ-FREYTES, in his personal and official capacities as President of the Puerto Rico Environmental Quality Board; FLOR DEL VALLE-LÓPEZ, in her official capacity as Associate Member of the Puerto Rico Environmental Quality Board; ANGEL BERRÍOS-SILVESTRE, in his official capacity as Associate Member of the Puerto Rico Environmental Quality Board; NORMAN VELÁZQUEZ-TORRES, in his official capacity as Attorney of the Puerto Rico Environmental Quality Board, Defendants, Appellants. ERRATA SHEET The opinion of this Court issued on April 10, 2008, is amended as follows: On page 25, line 14: "defendants assertions" should be "defendants' assertions"