Doe v. Bowles ( 2001 )

5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21 3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH  (/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU )LOH 1DPH DS 81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6 )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB s$1( '2( ;  3ODLQWLII$SSHOOHH   1R Y  !  *$ FHOOLVRODWLRQ@ZLOOQRWEHXVHGLQ LQVWDQFHVZKHUHWKHLQPDWHKDVDFWHGLQDYLROHQWRUDVVDXOWLYH 3ODLQWLIIEURXJKWD†FODLPDJDLQVW$QWKRQ\%ULJDQR PDQQHUls$ WKHZDUGHQRIWKHSULVRQ5LFKDUG.HPSWKHPDQDJHURIWKH 3&XQLW5RQDOG6WUDWWRQWKHVKLIWVXSHUYLVRURQGXW\ZKHQ 'XULQJKLVGHSRVLWLRQWKHQ'HSXW\:DUGHQ0DFNWHVWLILHG WKHDVVDXOWRFFXUUHGDQG*D\OH%RZOHVWKHFRUUHFWLRQRIILFHU WKDWDYLROHQWRUDVVDXOWLYHLQPDWHVKRXOGQRWEHSODFHGLQFHOO RQ GXW\ LQ SODLQWLIIjV XQLW ZKHQ WKH DVVDXOW RFFXUUHG LVRODWLRQ EXW UDWKHU VHJUHJDWLRQ s$   3ODLQWLIIjV 'HIHQGDQWVPRYHGIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWDUJXLQJWKDWWKH\ FRXQVHOWKHQVSHFLILFDOO\DVNHG0DFNDERXWWKHLPSDFWLIDQ\ ZHUH HQWLWOHG WR TXDOLILHG LPPXQLW\  7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW RQVDIHW\ XOWLPDWHO\HQWHUHGMXGJPHQWLQIDYRURIGHIHQGDQW%ULJDQR DQGGLGQRWUHDFKWKHTXHVWLRQRITXDOLILHGLPPXQLW\DVWR 4 $QGLWjVQRWVDIHIRUWKHRWKHULQPDWHVDQGRWKHUVWDII KLP  7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW GHQLHG TXDOLILHG LPPXQLW\ WR WR KDYH DQ >DVVDXOWLYH@ LQPDWH SODFHG MXVW LQ FHOO GHIHQGDQWV.HPS6WUDWWRQDQG%RZOHVVWDWLQJWKDWLWFRXOG LVRODWLRQ" QRW FRQFOXGH DV D PDWWHU RI ODZ WKDW WKH GHIHQGDQWV ZHUH HQWLWOHGWRTXDOLILHGLPPXQLW\'HIHQGDQWVDSSHOODQWV.HPS $ 7KDWZRXOGEHP\DVVXPSWLRQ\HV 6WUDWWRQ DQG %RZOHV QRZ DSSHDO DOOHJLQJ WKDW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWHUUHGLQQRWJUDQWLQJWKHPTXDOLILHGLPPXQLW\)RUWKH s$   :KLOH ERWK .HPS DQG WKHQ:DUGHQ %ULJDQR UHDVRQV VWDWHG EHORZ ZH JUDQW TXDOLILHG LPPXQLW\ WR WHVWLILHGLQWKHLUGHSRVLWLRQVWKDWFHOOLVRODWLRQPD\KDYHEHHQ GHIHQGDQW6WUDWWRQEXWZHFRQFOXGHWKDWWKLVFRXUWGRHVQRW WKHDSSURSULDWHUHVSRQVHs$DJHQXLQHLVVXH KDYH MXULVGLFWLRQ WR UHYLHZ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV GHQLDO RI RI PDWHULDO IDFW H[LVWV ZKLFK SUHFOXGHV UHYLHZ RI .HPSjV TXDOLILHGLPPXQLW\WRGHIHQGDQWV.HPSDQG%RZOHV TXDOLILHGLPPXQLW\FODLP ,, 7KH SULVRQ SROLF\ DOVR UHTXLUHV WKDW DQ LQPDWH RQ FHOO LVRODWLRQmZLOOEHHVFRUWHGWRKLVSRGDQGORFNHGLQKLVFHOO 'HIHQGDQWV DUJXH WKDW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW HUUHG LQ GHQ\LQJ XQWLOKHDUGE\WKHXQLWKHDULQJRIILFHU(DFKLQPDWHSODFHG WKHPTXDOLILHGLPPXQLW\IURPSODLQWLIIjVFODLPV4XDOLILHG RQFHOOUHVWULFWLRQZLOOQRWOHDYHWKHFHOOIRUDQ\UHDVRQRWKHU LPPXQLW\LVDQDIILUPDWLYHGHIHQVHWRD†FODLPDJDLQVW WKDQl YDULRXV OLVWHG DFWLYLWLHV s$  HPSKDVLV LQ DSXEOLFRIILFLDO7KH6L[WK&LUFXLWKDVH[SODLQHGWKDWLQRUGHU RULJLQDO  ,QWHUSUHWLQJ WKLV SURYLVLRQ 0DFN H[SODLQHG WKDW IRUDFRXUWWRGHQ\TXDOLILHGLPPXQLW\WRD†GHIHQGDQW WKH SODLQWLII mPXVW HVWDEOLVK WKDW >GHIHQGDQWjV@ FRQGXFW YLRODWHGDIHGHUDOULJKWVRFOHDUO\HVWDEOLVKHGWKDWDQ\RIILFLDO  LQKLVSRVLWLRQZRXOGKDYHXQGHUVWRRGWKDWKHZDVXQGHUDQ 7KHQ'HSXW\ :DUGHQ 0DFN FRXOG QRW UHFDOO GXULQJ KLV GHSRVLWLRQ ZKHWKHU WKH SROLF\ VWDWHPHQW LQFOXGHG LQ WKH sRLQW $SSHQGL[ ZDV LQ HIIHFW DIILUPDWLYHGXW\WRUHIUDLQIURPVXFKFRQGXFWl0F&ORXGY DW WKH WLPH RI WKH DWWDFN s$  +RZHYHU WKHQ:DUGHQ %ULJDQR 7HVWD)GWK&LUFLWLQJ:DVKLQJWRQ ZKRVH VLJQDWXUH LV DIIL[HG DW WKH HQG RI WKH SROLF\ VWDWHPHQW WHVWLILHG WKDW WKH SROLF\ VWDWHPHQW DSSHDUHG WR EH WKH RQH LQ HIIHFW DW WKDW WLPH s$ Y1HZVRP)GWK&LU'HIHQGDQWV  KHUHDUJXHWKDWWKH\DUHHQWLWOHGWRTXDOLILHGLPPXQLW\RQWZR LQGHSHQGHQWJURXQGV)LUVWGHIHQGDQWVDUJXHWKDWSODLQWLII  $W WKH WLPH RI WKH DWWDFN 0DFN ZDV 'HSXW\ :DUGHQ RI 2SHUDWLRQV FDQQRWVXIILFLHQWO\GHPRQVWUDWHWKHDOOHJHG(LJKW$PHQGPHQW DW WKH :DUUHQ SULVRQ +H ZDV SURPRWHG WR :DUGHQ LQ 6HSWHPEHU  YLRODWLRQ EHFDXVH GHIHQGDQWV ZHUH QRW mGHOLEHUDWHO\ s$   'RHY%RZOHVHWDO 1R 1R 'RHY%RZOHVHWDO  LQGLIIHUHQWl XQGHU WKH VWDQGDUG RXWOLQHG LQ )DUPHU Y BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB %UHQQDQ  86    'HIHQGDQWV DUJXH DOWHUQDWLYHO\WKDWWKH\GLGQRWYLRODWHmFOHDUO\HVWDEOLVKHGODZl &21&855(1&( UHJDUGLQJWKHGDQJHURILQPDWHRQLQPDWHSULVRQYLROHQFH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 3ODLQWLIIDSSHOOHH DUJXHV WKDW WKLV FRXUW GRHV QRW KDYH 0F.($*8('LVWULFWsXGJHFRQFXUULQJ,DJUHHZLWKWKH MXULVGLFWLRQWRFRQVLGHUWKLVDSSHDOEHFDXVHWKHSDUWLHVKDYH PDMRULW\ WKDW JHQXLQH LVVXHV RI PDWHULDO IDFW H[LVW ZKLFK QRWVWLSXODWHGWRDOORIWKHIDFWV3ODLQWLIIFLWHVsRKQVRQY SUHFOXGH UHYLHZ RI WKH TXDOLILHG LPPXQLW\ FODLPV RI sRQHV  86   IRU WKH SURSRVLWLRQ WKDW GHIHQGDQWV.HPSDQG%RZOHVsRKQVRQYsRQHV86 GHIHQGDQWVj IDLOXUH WR FRQFHGH WKH IDFWV PRVW IDYRUDEOH WR    , ZULWH VHSDUDWHO\ RQO\ WR KLJKOLJKW FHUWDLQ SODLQWLIIGLYHVWVWKLVFRXUWRIMXULVGLFWLRQ$OWKRXJKSODLQWLII PDWWHUVUHJDUGLQJWKHVXIILFLHQF\RIWKHGHIHQGDQWVjUHVSRQVHV LVFRUUHFWWKDWWKLVFRXUWGRHVQRWKDYHMXULVGLFWLRQWRKHDUDQ SULRUWRWKHVHFRQGsXO\DWWDFNDJDLQVWSODLQWLII LQWHUORFXWRU\DSSHDORIWKHLVVXHRITXDOLILHGLPPXQLW\LIWKH LVVXH LQYROYHV D GLVSXWHG TXHVWLRQ RI IDFW LW LV RQO\ WKH $VH[SODLQHGLQWKHPDMRULW\RSLQLRQGHIHQGDQWVDGPLWIRU PDWHULDOIDFWVZKLFKPXVWEHXQGLVSXWHG,QsRQHVWKH&RXUW SXUSRVHVRIWKLVLQWHUORFXWRU\DSSHDOWKDWWKH\KDGNQRZOHGJH H[SODLQHGWKDW RIWKHULVNVWRSODLQWLIISRVHGE\LQPDWH)UH]]HOO7KH\DUJXH LQVWHDG WKDW WKH XQGLVSXWHG DFWLRQV WKH\ WRRN LQ UHVSRQVH :H QRZ FRQVLGHU WKH DSSHDODELOLW\ RI D SRUWLRQ RI D VKRZDVDPDWWHURIODZWKDWWKH\GLGQRWDFWZLWKGHOLEHUDWH GLVWULFW FRXUW V VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW RUGHU WKDW WKRXJK LQGLIIHUHQFH WR SODLQWLIIjV VDIHW\ LQ YLRODWLRQ RI WKH (LJKWK HQWHUHGLQDTXDOLILHGLPPXQLW\FDVHGHWHUPLQHVRQO\ $PHQGPHQW)DUPHUY%UHQQDQ86 DTXHVWLRQRIHYLGHQFHVXIILFLHQF\LHZKLFKIDFWVD SDUW\PD\RUPD\QRWEHDEOHWRSURYHDWWULDO7KLVNLQG ,QKLV,QFLGHQW5HSRUWGDWHGsXO\.HPSQRWHGWKDW RIRUGHUZHFRQFOXGHLVQRWDSSHDODEOH EHIRUHKHOHIWWKHSULVRQRQsXO\WKSULRUWRWKHWZRDWWDFNV RQSODLQWLIIWKDWGD\KHPHW ,GDW7KH6L[WK&LUFXLWKDVH[SODLQHGKRZHYHUWKDW LQWHUORFXWRU\DSSHDOLVDSSURSULDWHLImGHVSLWHWKHIDFWWKDWWKH ZLWK&2%UDQKDPDQG&2%ROHV>VLF@DQGUHOD\HGWR GLVWULFWFRXUWWKRXJKWWKHUHZHUHGLVSXWHGLVVXHVRI>IDFW@>WKH WKHPP\FRQFHUQVDERXWWKLVVLWXDWLRQDQGWROGERWKWKDW FRXUWFRQFOXGHVWKDW@UHJDUGOHVVRIWKHIDFWXDOGLVSXWH LI WKH\ VDZ )UL]]HOO >VLF@ DWWHPSWLQJ WR JHW HYHQ QHDU WKHSODLQWLIIV>GR@QRWKDYHDYDOLGFODLPl0F&ORXG)G >SODLQWLII@ WKDW WKH\ VKRXOG FRQWDFW D VKLIW VXSHUYLVRU DW7KLVFRXUWKDVKHOGWKDWmUHJDUGOHVVRIWKHGLVWULFW LPPHGLDQWO\>VLF@DQGKDYH)UL]]HOO>VLF@SODFHGRQ&HOO FRXUWjV UHDVRQV IRU GHQ\LQJ TXDOLILHG LPPXQLW\ ZH PD\ ,VRODWLRQZKLFKZRXOGSUHYHQWDQ\IXUWKHUSUREOHPVXQWLO H[HUFLVHMXULVGLFWLRQRYHU>GHIHQGDQWjV@DSSHDOWRWKHH[WHQW ,UHWXUQHGRQWKHWK WKDWLWUDLVHVTXHVWLRQVRIODZl'LFNHUVRQY0F&OHOODQ )GWK&LU s$   $W ILUVW EOXVK WKLV LQVWUXFWLRQ DSSHDUV WR EH D UHDVRQDEOHLQWHUPHGLDWHUHVSRQVHWRWKHVLWXDWLRQ+RZHYHU 3URYLGHGWKDWWKHUHDUHQRGLVSXWHGLVVXHVRIPDWHULDOIDFW WKHSULVRQSROLF\RXWOLQLQJWKHUHTXLUHPHQWVDQGSURFHGXUHV SUHFOXGLQJMXULVGLFWLRQTXDOLILHGLPPXQLW\PXVWEHJUDQWHG E\WKLVFRXUWLIDVDPDWWHURIODZGHIHQGDQWVjFRQGXFWGLG QRWYLRODWHDFOHDUO\HVWDEOLVKHGFRQVWLWXWLRQDOULJKW7KHULJKW RIDQLQPDWHWREHSURWHFWHGIURPDQDWWDFNE\DIHOORZLQPDWH ZDVZHOOHVWDEOLVKHGDWWKHWLPHWKHHYHQWVLQTXHVWLRQWRRN  'RHY%RZOHVHWDO 1R 1R 'RHY%RZOHVHWDO  UHJDUGLQJ %RZOHVj UHDFWLRQ WR )UH]]HOOjV ILQDO DVVDXOW RQ SODFH:HOOEHIRUHWKHWLPHRIWKHVHHYHQWVWKLVFRXUWVWDWHG SODLQWLII LQ SODLQWLIIjV FHOO  'HIHQGDQWV DUJXH WKDW %RZOHV LQ:DONHUY1RUULV)GWK&LUWKDW LQWHUMHFWHG KHUVHOI EHWZHHQ )UH]]HOO DQG SODLQWLII DQG XVHG IRUFHDJDLQVW)UH]]HOOZKLOHSODLQWLIIDUJXHVWKDWWKHUHFRUG 7KH HLJKWK DPHQGPHQW ZKLFK SURKLELWV LQIOLFWLRQ RI GRHVQRWVXSSRUWWKLVGHVFULSWLRQDQGWKDWLQIDFW%RZOHVZDV mFUXHO DQG XQXVXDO SXQLVKPHQWl HQFRPSDVVHV WKH SK\VLFDOO\LQFDSDEOHRIFRQWUROOLQJ)UH]]HOODQGEDFNHGDZD\ SURVFULSWLRQRImGHOLEHUDWHLQGLIIHUHQFHl WRWKHVHULRXV IURPWKHILJKW7KHVHGLIIHUHQFHVDUHIDFWXDOGLVSXWHV$MXU\ QHHGVRISULVRQHUV2QVHYHUDORFFDVLRQVZHKDYH PD\ ILQG WKDW %RZOHV ZDV VLPSO\ QHJOLJHQW LQ SHUPLWWLQJ KHOG WKDW mGHOLEHUDWH LQGLIIHUHQFHl RI FRQVWLWXWLRQDO )UH]]HOOWRZDONE\SODLQWLIIjVFHOOWRUHWULHYHWKHPRSRUD PDJQLWXGHPD\RFFXUZKHQSULVRQJXDUGVIDLOWRSURWHFW MXU\PD\ILQGWKDWJLYHQDOORIWKHIDFWVDVGHWHUPLQHGDWWULDO RQHLQPDWHIURPDQDWWDFNE\DQRWKHU %RZOHVj FRQGXFW ZDV QRW D UHDVRQDEOH UHVSRQVH WR WKH DGPLWWHGO\NQRZQULVNWRSODLQWLII%HFDXVH%RZOHVjFODLPRI ,GDW7KXVZKHUHWKHUHDUHQRGLVSXWHGPDWHULDOIDFWV TXDOLILHG LPPXQLW\ GHSHQGV RQ WKH UHVROXWLRQ RI IDFWXDO WKHUHOHYDQWTXHVWLRQLVZKHWKHUSODLQWLIIKDVPDGHDVKRZLQJ LVVXHVZHFRQFOXGHWKDWZHGRQRWKDYHMXULVGLFWLRQWRUHYLHZ RI GHOLEHUDWH LQGLIIHUHQFH RQ WKH SDUW RI SULVRQ RIILFHUV WKHFODLPDWWKLVWLPH WKHUHE\ FRQVWLWXWLQJ DQ (LJKWK $PHQGPHQW YLRODWLRQ  ,Q )DUPHUY%UHQQDQWKH&RXUWRXWOLQHGWKHWHVWIRUGHOLEHUDWH ,,, LQGLIIHUHQFHLQDSULVRQYLROHQFHFRQWH[WH[SODLQLQJWKDW )RUWKHUHDVRQVVWDWHGDERYHZHUHYHUVHWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWj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mVXEMHFWLYHUHFNOHVVQHVVDVXVHGLQWKHFULPLQDO ODZlDVWKHWHVWIRUGHOLEHUDWHLQGLIIHUHQFHXQGHUWKH(LJKWK $PHQGPHQW,GDW7RWKHH[WHQWWKDWWKHUHDUHQR GLVSXWHGLVVXHVRIPDWHULDOIDFWZLWKUHJDUGWRDQ\GHIHQGDQWjV FODLPV  ZH FDQ UHYLHZ WKDW GHIHQGDQWj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jV WRRNVWHSVVXIILFLHQWIRUWKHFRXUWWRKROGDVDPDWWHURIODZ GHFLVLRQ  ,Q SDUWLFXODU .HPS DUJXHV WKDW SODLQWLII RIIHUHG WKDWKHZDVQRWmGHOLEHUDWHO\LQGLIIHUHQWlWRWKHULVNRIGDQJHU RQO\YDJXHFRPSODLQWVWKDW)UH]]HOOZDVKDUDVVLQJSODLQWLII WR SODLQWLII  'HIHQGDQW 6WUDWWRQ ZDV DZDUH RI WKH GDQJHU IURP)UH]]HOOjVRZQFHOOGRRUZD\DQGWKDWSODLQWLIIQHYHUVDLG SRVHGE\)UH]]HOODQGWRRNVWHSVWRDGGUHVVWKDWGDQJHU,WLV WKDW )UH]]HOO SK\VLFDOO\ DVVDXOWHG RU WKUHDWHQHG WR NLOO KHU XQGLVSXWHGWKDW6WUDWWRQFRQIHUUHGZLWK.HPSEHIRUH.HPS s$'HIHQGDQW.HPSDUJXHVWKDWKHXQGHUVWRRGWKH OHIW KLV VKLIW  $W WKDW SRLQW 6WUDWWRQjV RQO\ LQIRUPDWLRQ LQFLGHQWWRKDYH LQYROYHGRQO\PLQRUKDUDVVPHQWWKXVQRW UHJDUGLQJ )UH]]HOO DQG SODLQWLII FDPH IURP .HPS ZKR GHVHUYLQJRIDQRUGHULVRODWLQJ)UH]]HOO,QFRQWUDVWSODLQWLII UHSRUWHG WKDW )UH]]HOO KDG mKDUDVVHGl SODLQWLII EXW GLG QRW VWDWHVWKDWVKHWROG6FKZHLW]HUVSHFLILFDOO\DERXWWKHSK\VLFDO LQGLFDWHWKDWDQ\SK\VLFDODWWDFNKDGRFFXUUHG,QDGGLWLRQ DWWDFNDQGWKUHDWVDQGWKDWGHIHQGDQW.HPSWROGSODLQWLIIWKDW ZKHQ6WUDWWRQDVNHGLIVHJUHJDWLRQZDVDSSURSULDWH.HPS 6FKZHLW]HUmDOUHDG\WROGPHlDOORIWKHGHWDLOVs$ DQVZHUHG WKDW LW ZDV QRW  :H FDQQRW ILQG WKDW GHIHQGDQW ,QDGGLWLRQWKHUHDSSHDUVWREHDIDFWXDOGLVSXWHLQWKHUHFRUG 6WUDWWRQZDVUHTXLUHGWRRYHUULGHWKHMXGJPHQWRIWKHRIILFHU DVWRZKHWKHUGHIHQGDQW.HPSLGHQWLILHGSODLQWLIIDQG)UH]]HOO ZKR KDG EHHQ KDQGOLQJ WKH VLWXDWLRQ GLUHFWO\ SDUWLFXODUO\ E\ QDPH WR GHIHQGDQW 6WUDWWRQ RU RQO\ LQGLFDWHG WKDW DQ ZKHQ KH ZDV QRW JLYHQ DQ\ LQIRUPDWLRQ WR LQGLFDWH WKH LQFLGHQWEHWZHHQWZRXQLGHQWLILHGLQPDWHVKDGRFFXUUHGs$ H[LVWHQFHRIDSK\VLFDOWKUHDWWRSODLQWLII$IWHUWKHSP    ,I GHIHQGDQW .HPS GLG QRW QDPH WKH SDUWLHV LQFLGHQW RQ sXO\  LQ ZKLFK )UH]]HOO JUDEEHG SODLQWLII LQ LQYROYHG D UHDVRQDEOH MXU\ FRXOG FRQFOXGH WKDW GHIHQGDQW SODLQWLIIjVFHOO6WUDWWRQGLGWDNHIXUWKHUDFWLRQWRVHJUHJDWHWKH .HPSjV HIIRUWV WR SURWHFW SODLQWLII ZHUH QRW VXIILFLHQW DQG WZRLQPDWHVE\DSSURYLQJFHOOLVRODWLRQIRU)UH]]HOO$VRQH ZHUHDSUR[LPDWHFDXVHRIWKHVHFRQGDVVDXOW7KXVZHPDNH RI WKUHH SRVVLEOH FKRLFHV IRU VHJUHJDWLQJ )UH]]HOO IURP QR VXEVWDQWLYH ILQGLQJ DV WR WKH VXIILFLHQF\ RI GHIHQGDQW SODLQWLII6WUDWWRQjVFKRLFHRIFHOOLVRODWLRQZDVQRWDUHFNOHVV .HPSjVDFWLRQV:HUXOHRQO\WKDWZHDUHSUHFOXGHGIURP DSSURDFKWRNHHSLQJ)UH]]HOODZD\IURPSODLQWLII$OWKRXJK UHYLHZLQJGHIHQGDQW.HPSjVFODLPEHFDXVHJHQXLQHLVVXHVRI XOWLPDWHO\WKDWVROXWLRQZDVQRWVXIILFLHQWWRSURWHFWSODLQWLII PDWHULDOIDFWDUHLQGLVSXWH 6WUDWWRQFRXOGQRWUHDVRQDEO\KDYHIRUHVHHQWKDWRWKHURIILFHUV ZRXOGSHUPLW)UH]]HOOWROHDYHKLVFHOODIWHUWKHFHOOLVRODWLRQ )LQDOO\ZHFRQFOXGHOLNHZLVHWKDWWKHUHDUHJHQXLQHLVVXHV KDGEHHQLPSRVHG%HFDXVHSODLQWLIIGRHVQRWGLVSXWHDQ\RI RIPDWHULDOIDFWZKLFKSUHFOXGHUHYLHZRIGHIHQGDQW%RZOHVj WKH IDFWV UHOLHG XSRQ KHUH ZH FRQFOXGH WKDW WKLV FRXUW KDV FODLP  3ODLQWLII SRLQWV WR VHYHUDO GLVSXWHG IDFWV UHJDUGLQJ MXULVGLFWLRQWRUHYLHZGHIHQGDQW6WUDWWRQjVFODLPDQGWKDWWKH GHIHQGDQW%RZOHVDVHYLGHQFHWKDWWKLVFRXUWODFNVMXULVGLFWLRQ GLVWULFW FRXUW HUUHG LQ QRW JUDQWLQJ TXDOLILHG LPPXQLW\ WR WRKHDUWKLVDSSHDO3OjV%U,QSDUWLFXODUSODLQWLII GHIHQGDQW6WUDWWRQ DUJXHVWKDWWKHSDUWLHVKDYHRIIHUHGFRQIOLFWLQJVWRULHVDVWR ZKHWKHU GHIHQGDQW %RZOHV ZDV GHOLEHUDWHO\ LQGLIIHUHQW WR :HFDQQRWKROGKRZHYHUWKDWDVDPDWWHURIODZGHIHQGDQW SODLQWLIIjVVDIHW\ZKHQVKHOHW)UH]]HOORXWWRJRWRWKHVKRZHU .HPSLVHQWLWOHGWRTXDOLILHGLPPXQLW\5DWKHUZHFRQFOXGH DVWRZKHWKHU%RZOHVWROGSODLQWLIIWKDW)UH]]HOOZDVRXWRIKLV WKDWWKHUHDUHJHQXLQHLVVXHVRIPDWHULDOIDFWZKLFKSUHFOXGH FHOODQGDVWRSODLQWLIIjVUHDFWLRQLIDQGZKHQ%RZOHVWROG UHYLHZRIWKLVFODLP,WLVXQGLVSXWHGWKDW.HPSGLVFXVVHGWKH SODLQWLIIWKDW)UH]]HOOZDVRXWRIKLVFHOO,QDGGLWLRQSODLQWLII sXO\LQFLGHQWZLWKSODLQWLIIRQsXO\VSHFLILFDOO\RUGHUHG SRLQWV WR GLIIHUHQFHV LQ WKH IDFWV RIIHUHG E\ WKH SDUWLHV