Creek v. South Dakota Department of Corrections , 25 F. App'x 479 ( 2001 )


Menu:
  •                      United States Court of Appeals
    FOR THE EIGHTH CIRCUIT
    ___________
    No. 01-2974
    ___________
    Clayton S. Creek,                    *
    *
    Appellant,              *
    * Appeal from the United States
    v.                             * District Court for the
    * District of South Dakota.
    South Dakota Department of,          *
    Corrections; South Dakota State      * [UNPUBLISHED]
    Penitentiary                         *
    *
    Appellees.              *
    ___________
    Submitted: November 30, 2001
    Filed: December 18, 2001
    ___________
    Before BOWMAN, BRIGHT, and LOKEN, Circuit Judges.
    ___________
    PER CURIAM.
    South Dakota inmate Clayton S. Creek appeals the district court's dismissal
    without prejudice of his 
    42 U.S.C. § 1983
     action for failure to make an initial partial
    filing fee.
    In January 2001, Creek filed a motion with the South Dakota Supreme Court
    concerning prison officials who violate prison policies that protect access to religious
    objects, such as ceremonial pow-wow wacipi, medicine pouches, and eagle parts.
    Because the South Dakota Supreme Court returned Creek's motion without taking
    action on the motion, Creek filed a § 1983 claim alleging that his equal protection and
    due process rights were violated. Creek also alleged that prison officials prevented
    Native American inmates from participating in religious ceremonies, which Creek
    asserted pose no threat to security, discipline or good order.
    After receiving Creek's in forma pauperis (IFP) application and Prisoner Trust
    Account Report, the district court granted Creek IFP status, ordered him to pay an
    initial partial filing fee of $.03 on or before April 1, 2001, and ordered the custodial
    institution to forward to the clerk's office 20% of the funds credited to Creek's prison
    account from the previous month, whenever the account balance exceeds $10. On
    July 2, 2001, the court dismissed the case without prejudice for failure to make the
    initial partial filing fee of $.03 by April 1. The court also denied all pending motions
    as moot.
    Creek filed a timely notice of appeal and after remand from this court to
    determine whether Creek should be allowed to proceed IFP on appeal, the district
    court granted him IFP status and assessed appellate filing fees pursuant to 
    28 U.S.C. § 1915
    (b)(2). The court ordered an initial partial fee payment for appellate docketing
    and filing fees in the amount of $.02 to be paid on or before September 15, 2001, and
    the balance to be paid off in the same manner as described above.
    We now determine that the district court improperly dismissed Creek's claim
    for failing to pay the initial partial filing fee of $.03 by the deadline of April 1.
    Creek's Prisoner Trust Account Report indicated that he had a negative balance, and
    there is no indication in the record that he ever had a positive balance. See 
    28 U.S.C. § 1915
    (b)(4) ("In no event shall a prisoner be prohibited from bringing a civil action
    or appealing a civil or criminal judgment for the reason that the prisoner has no assets
    or no means by which to pay the initial partial filing fee.").
    -2-
    We vacate the dismissal and remand to the district court for such action as may
    be appropriate.
    A true copy.
    Attest:
    CLERK, U.S. COURT OF APPEALS, EIGHTH CIRCUIT.
    -3-
    

Document Info

Docket Number: 01-2974

Citation Numbers: 25 F. App'x 479

Judges: Bowman, Bright, Per Curiam, Token

Filed Date: 12/18/2001

Precedential Status: Non-Precedential

Modified Date: 11/5/2024