Park v. Super. Ct. CA2/1 ( 2014 )

Filed 9/24/14 Park v. Super. Ct. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
JUHAN PARK et al., B254769
Petitioners, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. BC503036)
v.
THE SUPERIOR COURT OF LOS
ANGELES COUNTY,
Respondent;
TEMPLE COMMUNITY HOSPITAL et al.,
Real Parties in Interest.
ORIGINAL PROCEEDING; petition for writ of mandate. William F. Fahey,
Judge. Petition granted.
Law Offices of William H. Newkirk, William H. Newkirk and Ashley S. Feder for
Petitioners.
No appearance for Respondent.
Fonda, Hester & Associates, Peter M. Fonda and Cecille L. Hester for Real Party
in Interest Temple Community Hospital.
Gonzalez & Hulbert, Michael D. Gonzalez and Rebecca L. Smith for Real Party in
Interest Jamshid Nazarian.
La Follette, Johnson, De Haas, Fesler & Ames, Don Fesler and David J. Ozeran
for Real Party in Interest Hossein Babaali.
Reback, McAndrews, Kjar, Warford, Stockalper & Moore, Patrick E. Stockalper
and Harlan N. Petoyan for Real Party in Interest Bun Raymond Lim.
——————————
Temple Community Hospital (Hospital) and Jamshid Nazarian, M.D., are
defendants in a civil action filed by Juhan Park, Joung Hee Lim, Dae Sook Kim, and
Joung Hun Park (collectively, Park). The complaint alleges professional negligence and
failure to obtain informed consent, among other claims, related to the death of plaintiffs’
mother two days after surgery performed by Dr. Nazarian at the Hospital. The trial court
sustained without leave to amend the demurrers of the Hospital, Dr. Nazarian, and other
defendants. Park sought a writ of mandate directing the superior court to vacate its order
sustaining the demurrers. We issued an alternative writ of mandate, directing the trial
court either to vacate its order sustaining the demurrer without leave to amend as to
Park’s fourth cause of action against Dr. Nazarian and the Hospital for failure to obtain
informed consent, or to show cause why it should not be ordered to do so. The superior
court did not vacate its order, and for the reasons stated below, we grant Park’s petition
for writ of mandate and reverse the trial court’s order sustaining the demurrer to the
informed consent cause of action.
BACKGROUND
Park’s first amended complaint, filed June 11, 2013, alleges that Park’s 74-year-
old mother, Byung Soon Park, died at the Hospital on December 26, 2011 while under
the care of Dr. Nazarian and other defendants, two days after Dr. Nazarian performed an
open cholecystectomy. As against the Hospital and Dr. Nazarian, the complaint alleged
causes of action for professional negligence causing wrongful death, fraud
(misrepresentation), fraud (concealment), failure to obtain informed consent, elder abuse,
unfair business practices, and survivor’s claim. The informed consent cause of action
alleged that neither Byung Soon Park nor Park gave their informed consent to the
2
surgery, and they would not have agreed to it if they had been fully informed of the
results, risks of, and alternatives to the procedure.
The Hospital and Dr. Nazarian filed demurrers to all the counts except the
professional negligence and survivor’s claim. Dr. Nazarian argued that the informed
consent cause of action was “duplicative of, and therefore subsumed by” the professional
negligence cause of action. The Hospital argued that it had no duty to obtain a patient’s
informed consent, and Dr. Nazarian was not its employee or agent. The trial court
granted the demurrers without leave to amend at a hearing and by minute order on
January 6, 2014.
A lack of informed consent is a separate theory of liability from professional
negligence or malpractice, and can generally be established by the patient-plaintiff’s
testimony. (See Cobbs v. Grant (1972) 8 Cal. 3d 229, 240–244; Arato v. Avedon (1993) 5
Cal. 4th 1172, 1190–1191.) As an “alternative negligence theor[y],” lack of informed
consent can establish liability even when expert testimony has eliminated allegations of
negligent performance. (Willard v. Hagemeister (1981) 121 Cal. App. 3d 406, 417–418.)
The relevant question of fact is whether the treating professional gave the plaintiff
sufficient information as to the nature of the procedure “so that she could intelligently
decide whether to undergo the . . . procedure. If [the treating professionals] did not make
this minimal disclosure of material facts, they are liable for all injuries sustained by [the
plaintiff] during the course of this . . . treatment, whether the treatment was negligent or
not.” (Id. at p. 418; Jambazian v. Borden (1994) 25 Cal. App. 4th 836, 845.)
Further, the complaint alleged that both Dr. Nazarian and the Hospital had a duty
to explain the attendant risks before the surgery was performed. The complaint also
alleged that Dr. Nazarian was an agent, employee and joint venturer of the Hospital.
Whether the Hospital had a duty to obtain informed consent and whether Dr. Nazarian
had an employee or agent relationship with the Hospital were questions of fact
appropriately addressed in a motion for summary judgment or adjudication. (See
Ermoian v. Desert Hospital (2007) 152 Cal. App. 4th 475, 506–509.)
3
The trial court erred in sustaining Dr. Nazarian’s and the Hospital’s demurrers to
the informed consent cause of action.
DISPOSITION
The petition for writ of mandate is granted. This court’s alternative writ of
mandate is discharged. Let a peremptory writ of mandate issue, directing the respondent
superior court to vacate its January 6, 2014 order sustaining the demurrer of real parties
in interest to the petitioners’ cause of action for failure to obtain informed consent.
Petitioners are to recover their costs in this writ proceeding.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
JOHNSON, J.
We concur:
ROTHSCHILD, P. J.
CHANEY, J.
4