- s,11 # " s$,/4,)) 6 ()02( (//,)(2+0(206(35'*( 05240 ()(/'$/4 $/' ()(/'$/4/4(26(/02 .%5=1>49>7D85(&5@1BD=5>D?6?==5B35QC69>1 7D81D% & 5>79>5C1B59>3 D851>D94E=@9>71>43?E>D5BF19 74EDI?B45BC?>35BD19> F5BD931 79>5C25DG55>331>4E@D? 331>4@1BDCD85B5?66B?=D85 $5?@ 1/ 1D5452BE1BI B9DD>5I%$?G5 4 9J25D8% 5F9>C?>?H%?D8C389 7D?> 6?B$ D966s85:91>7=5B9CE>'538>? 4 I 5I ?==5B391 B1>389F9 (&5@1BD=5>D?6 ECD935?6 *1C89>7D?>6?B565>41>D(>9D54&D1D5C*9D8D85=?>D852B956G5B5 B91>!?I>D?>$B9>39@1 DDD?B>5I5>5B1 4$1DB9391! !31BD8I9B53D?B#63?E>C5 D852B956G1C ?>s1381BI?B25CDD?B>5I ?EBD"? $175 #66935?6D858956?E>C5 6?B35=5>D?=@ 35(& 5@1BD=5>D?6?==5B35?6*1C89>7D?> 1>95 5945B=1>1>4&D5@85>#B1F1 9>7&@1 7 $?6 *1C89>7D?>6?B565>41>D >D5BF5>?BB977C&DB1DD?> 8?5B?F5C E475$ D966s85:91>7=5B9CE>'538>? D966O?BNs85:91>7=5B9CE>O9C16?B597>5H@?BD5B?6 =?G5BC6B?= D85$5?@ 1N89>1O$ D966381 75CD85(& 5@1BD=5>D?6?==5B35QCN?==5B35O69>1 7D81DD85% & 5>79>5=1>E613DEB542I8?>7A9>7%1D?'538>? 7A9>7 %1D?O9C9>3 D851>D94E=@9>71>43?E>D5BF19 74EDI?B45BC?>35BD19> F5BD931 79>5C25DG55>331>4E@D? 331>4@1BDCD85B5?66B?=89>1 5BD19>)5BD931 79>5C5DG55>331>4(@'? 331>4$1BDC'85B5?6 6B?=D85$5?@ 1&3?@5%E 7?>!?496954)5BD931 79>5C53 N9>1 7O$% C555BD19>)5BD931 79>5C5DG55>331>4(@D? 331>4$1BDC'85B5?6B?=D85$5?@ 154%57 !1I 1>D94E=@9>71>4 3?E>D5BF19 74EDI?B45BCN#B45BCO '853BEH?6D89C31C59CG85D85B8?>7A9>7%1D?QC% &8?B9J?>D1 79>5C61 D85C3?@5?6D85#B45BCD81D3?F5BF5BD931 79>5C$ D966 9D1D9?>CD?D8514=9>9CDB1D9F5B53?B4B56 D >E=25BC69 D89C31C5"? ?EBD"? $175 1B7E5CD81DD85% &5>79>5C3?>D19>1>5G 548?B9J?>D1 79>5 D81DC8?E =5>D3?>D5>4C D81D?==5B35QCC3?@5BE 7G893845D5B=9>54D81DD858?B9J?>D1 79>5 G1C5AE9F1 DD?1N=?496954F5BD931 79>51>4D8EC65 D85C3?@5 ?6D85#B45BCC8?E 54D?B1 D49C3ECC9?>CG9D8D85$1BD95C B5F51 D1 79>545C97>9C>5GD?D85=1B;5D1>4D8EC1 8?B9J?>D1 79>5G1C>?D3?>D5=@ D85#B45BCG5B54B16D54D?3?F5B F5BD931 79>5C&55#B1 D966QC!?D9?>6?B E47=5>D?>D8575>3I%53?B4 N$ D966QC!?D9?>O$ 3I%N$ DCED8?B9D95C&E@@$ 3I%N$ 41>D(>9D54&D1D5CND85?F5B>=5>DO?BN565>41>DO1>4 565>41>D >D5BF5>?BB977C&DB1DD?> N565>41>D >D5BF5>?BONB977C &DB1DD?>O?BN$5D9D9?>5BO?@@?C5$ D966QC!?D9?>%5C@B56 >D5BF#@@Q> $ 3I%N56 >D5BFQC%5C@O"? 56QC%5C@$ 3I%N56QC%5C@O"? $ D96669 3I%N$ C49C3ECC5425 4C?==5B35QC9>1 71CE>CE@@?BD542ICE2CD1>D91 351>4>?D9>133?B41>35G9D8 !1I ?==5B359CCE541>D94E=@9>71>43?E>D5BF19 74EDI ?B45BC6?B35BD19>F5BD931 79>5C25DG55>331>4E@D? 331>4@1BDC D85B5?66B?=89>1&555BD19>)5BD931 79>5C5DG55>331>4(@D? 331>4$1BDC'85B5?6B?=D85$5?@ 154%571D #>E7ECD B977C&DB1DD?>69 7B5AE5CDD? 45D5B=9>5G85D85B8?>7A9>7%1D?QC% &N=?496954F5BD931 7 45B 19B3?? ?>B?149>D5B>1 5>79>5CEC54D?@?G5B =?G5BC G9D818?B9J?>D1 ;C816D3?>>53D54D?1B978D1>7 7&@1 7 $D??==5B35B55BD19> )5BD931 79>5C5DG55>331>4 331>4$1BDC'85B5?66B?=89>1./ %5AE5CD6?B&3?@5%E 7%571B49>75BD19>!?496954)5BD931 79>5C E7 N$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CDO$% L #>E7ECD ?==5B359>9D91D54D85C3?@59>AE9BI!5=B5 >9D91D9?>!5=?.6?B/!?496954)5BD931 79>5CE7 $% '85$1BD95C69 DC 5DD5B6B?=?==5B359>1>35 1G#66935CD??==5B35B55BD19>)5BD931 79>5C5DG55>331>4 331>4$1BDC'85B5?66B?=89>1?==5>DC?>&3?@5%E 7@@ %571B49>75BD19>!?496954)5BD931 79>5C&5@D N$ D966QC ?EBD"? $175 4=9>9CDB1D9F5?==5>DCO$% 5DD5B6B?= 9>7&@1 7 $D? ?==5B35B55BD19>)5BD931 79>5C5DG55>331>4 331>4$1BDC '85B5?66B?=89>1./$5D9D9?>5BQC%5C@?>C5?==5>DC#3D N$5D9D9?>5BQC%52EDD1 DCO$% ?==5B359CCE54D859>1 7?>535=25B 45D5B=9>9>7D81D8?>7A9>7%1D?QC% &5>79>5C 1B5=?496954F5BD931 79>5C9>3 D85C3?@5?6D85#B45BC&559>1 7$ D96669 &55&E==?>C"? ?=@ @EBCE1>DD?&53D9?> 1 F9?6D85 '1B9663D?6 1C1=5>454 (&K 11 F91>4 (& K 3'85?EBDG9 I45D5B=9>1D9?>6?E>4D?25 E>CE@@?BD542ICE2CD1>D91 35?>D85B53?B4?B?D85BG9C5>?D9>133?B41>35 G9D8 C?6=5B381>49C53?F5B542ID85C3?@5?61>1>D94E=@9>7?B 3?E>D5BF19 74EDI?B45B=ECD25GB9DD5>9>75>5B1 4AE5CD9?>C=1I1B9C5 1CD?G85D85B1@1BD93E 3 D85C3?@5?61>?B45B&55 %K 1*85>CE38AE5CD9?>C1B9C5?==5B35QCB57E C49B53D9D ?EBD"? $175 D?9CCE5C3?@5BE 7CD81D3 C3?@5?B?ED?6C3?@5 4?==5B359C7E94542I31C5 4175>3IB57E C9>D859BC3?@5BE 7C &55!5B9491>$B?4C F(>9D54&D1D5CN!5B9491>$B?4CO 4 549B %K &01(0)4+(2'(23 ?==5B35QC9>AE9BI=ECD2579>G9D8D85B5 DC3?@5 7E175&5557 #! >3F(>9D54&D1D5C 4 549B 6D85C3?@5 7E1759CE>1=297E?ECND85@ =51>9>7?6D85 7E1757?F5B>CO 4 6D85 7E1759C1=297E?EC8?G5F5B?==5B359>D5B@B5DCD85C3?@5G9D8D85194?6 D85C?EB35CC5D6?BD89> %K ; !5B9491>$B?4C 41D 6D85; C?EB35C4?>?D49C@?C9D9F5 CG5BD85AE5CD9?>?==5B35 =1I3?>C945BD85; 613D?BCE>45B %K ; 4 ?==5B35=1I3?>C945BD856? 79>D5B@B5D9F5C?EB35CE>45B % K ; D?45D5B=9>5G85D85B=5B381>49C59C3?F5B542ID85C3?@5?61> ?B45B '85 45C3B9@D9?>C ?6 D85 =5B381>49C5 3?>D19>54 9> D85 @5D9D9?> @5BD19>9>7D?D85?B45B1D9CCE5 '85 45C3B9@D9?>C ?6 D85 =5B381>49C5 3?>D19>54 9> D85 9>9D91 F5CD971D9?>@5BD19>9>7D?D85?B45B1D9CCE5 $B5F9?EC?B3?>3EBB5>D45D5B=9>1D9?>C?6D85&53B5D1BI9>3 7 @B9?BC3?@5BE 7C=5=?B1>41?B3 C@5BD19>9>7D?2?D8 ?EBD"? $175 D85 ?B45B 1D 9CCE5 1C G5 7E1751CD81D?6D85?B45B1D9CCE51>4 5D5B=9>1D9?>C?6D85?==9CC9?>@5BD19>9>7D?D85?B45B1D9CCE5 9>3 7 B5@?BDC 9CCE54 @EBCE1>D D? D85 ?==9CC9?>QC 9>9D91 F5CD971D9?> %K ; &53?>41BI9>D5B@B5D9F5C?EB35C9>3 I?D85B 45D5B=9>1D9?>C?6D85&53B5D1BI?BD85?==9CC9?>>?D945>D9695412?F5BE 7C?B 45D5B=9>1D9?>C2I(&ECD?=C1>4?B45B$B?D53D9?>NECD?=CO9>4ECDBI EC175493D9?>1B95C1>41>I?D85BB5 DB53?B45F945>35 4 6D85B59C1 3?>6 D85C5C53?>41BI9>D5B@B5D9F5C?EB35C1>4D85@B9=1BI9>D5B@B5D9F5 C?EB35C?6D89CC53D9?>D85@B9=1BI9>D5B@B5D9F5C?EB35CG9 ?B=1 9> 45D5B=9>9>7G85D85B1@B?4E3D9C3?F5B542ID85C3?@5?6D85?B45B1D9CCE5 4 '85C3?@5 7E175?6D85#B45BC9>D89C31C5CD1D5C9>B5 D@1BD '85 =5B381>49C5 3?F5B54 2I D85C5 ?B45BC 3?>C9CDC ?6 C@1B;97>9D54 >?>B?14 F5BD931 79>5C G85D85B 69>9C854 ?B E>69>9C854 G85D85B1CC5=2 1CC5=2 D54?BE>=?E>D54 @B9=1B9 4 =?G5BC>79>5C=55D9>7D89C@8IC931 =1I 1 ?>81>485 D9>3 72ED>?D 79>5C 1B5 C@1B; 97>9D9?> C9>7 45B 19B 3?? D5B>1 5>79>5CG9D8F5BD931 9=E= 49C@ D ?6 3E293 35>D9=5D5BC 33 1>4 1 =1H9=E= 49C@ D ?6 E@ D? 2ED >?D 9>3 7 33 'I@931 79>5C G9D849C@ DC?6D89CC9J575>5B1D57B?CC@?G5B?625DG55> ;9 79>5C 3?F5B54 2I D89C C3?@5 >?B=1 4 25 35BD96954E>45B>F9B?>=5>D1 75>3I$19B@? 3?>DB? C CD1>41B4C 6?B C=1 ?>B?14 C@1B;97>9D9?> 5>79>5C 1>4 5AE9@=5>D >79>5C D81D ?D85BG9C5 =55D D85 @8IC931 ?6D85C3?@52ED1B5>?D35BD96954E>45B %@1BD 1>41B5>?D35BD96954E>45B?D85B@1BDC?6CE2381@D5B(?6D85$19B @? 3?>DB? ?D5H3 7C >79>5CD81D=1I2535BD96954E>45B2?D8 %@1BD 1CG5 CE2:53D D? D85 C3?@5 ?6 D85C5 @B?35549>7C 5BD19>C=1 79>5CG85D85B?B>?D=?E>D54?>>?> 81>485 D9>3 72ED>?D 4 =?G5BC1>4@B5CCEB5G1C85BC1B59>3 D85C3?@5 ?G5F5B961CE2:53D5>79>59C9=@?BD54=?E>D54?>CE385AE9@=5>D ?> 79>59C3?F5B542ID85C3?@5&E2:53D=5B381>49C59>3 C=1 79>5C @B?4E354 9> D85 CE2:53D 3?E>DBI G85D85B=?E>D54?>?ED4??B@?G5B5AE9@=5>D9>D85CE2:53D3?E>DBI ?B9>1D89B43?E>DBI&E2:53D5>79>5C1B53?F5B54G85D85B?B>?DD85I 1B5133?=@1>9542I?D85B@1BDC ?B@EB@?C5C?6D85C5?B45BC1>E>69>9C8545>79>53?F5BC1D1=9>9=E= 1 CE21CC5=2 ?D 7 3?=@?>5>DC B1>;31C5 3B1>;C816D 31=C816D @9CD?>C 1>4 3?>>53D9>7B?4C =@?BD1D9?>?6D85C53?=@?>5>DCD?75D85BG85D85B 1CC5=2 1CC5=2 4 G85D85B ?B >?D 133?=@1>954 2I 1449D9?>1 5>DC CE38 1C 1 CE=@ 31B2EB5D?B C@135B 3I 45B 8514CF1 ?BF1 CD9DED5C1>E>69>9C8545>79>5 6?B@EB@?C5C?6D85C5?B45BC'859>3 ?6?D85B@B?4E3DCCE381C C@1B; @ D? D85 3I 45B 8514 ?B 5 9D9?> 3?9 38B?>9J9>7 G9D8 D85 5>79>5 D? CE@@ C9?> 3EBB5>D4?5C>?DB5=?F5D85@B?4E3D6B?=D85C3?@5'859>3 ?6 1>I ?D85B 3?=@?>5>DC >?D 945>D96954 1C 3?=@B9C9>7 D85 E>69>9C854 5>79>5CE21CC5=2 1D89B43?E>DBI4?5C>?DB5=?F5D855>79>56B?= D85C3?@5 &@5396931 79>5CE>45B % 1>4 % D81D81F5 149C@ D?6 33?B7B51D5B 131CD 9B?>3I 45B 5B 1>1ED?=1D933?=@B5CC9?>B5 4 1>41 =E66 4F? 33 ?EBD"? $175 &555BD19>)5BD931 79>5C5DG55>331>4(@D? 331>4$1BDC '85B5?6B?=D85$5?@ 154%571D L (3&2,14,0/0)(2&+$/',3( $ D9669C16?B597>5H@?BD5B?6 =?G5BC6B?=89>1D81D5=@ 79>59>9DC$?G5B&=1BD2B1>4 =?G5BC&55$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5 %E 7%5AE5CD1D B?=D85?EDC5D?6D85C3?@5BE 7B5AE5CDD854?=5CD93 @B?4E35BB977C&DB1DD?>45C3B92548?>7A9>7%1D?QC% &5>79>51C1 N=?496954F5BD931 79>5OB1D85BD81>18?B9J?>D1 79>5 41D S ?==5B35538?54D89C 7E175G85>9D@B?F9454D856? 745C3B9@D9?>9>D85 C3?@5BE 7 '85 =5B381>49C5 CE2:53D D? D89C C3?@5 9>AE9BI 9C 1 =?496954 F5BD931 79>5 CE38 1C D85 =?496954 % & 5>79>5 =1>E613DEB54 2I 8?>7A9>7%1D?=?496954F5BD931 79>59C1C9>7 45B 19B3?? 9D54>?>B?149>D5B>1 5>79>5EC54 D? @?G5B =?G5BC G9D8 1 8?B9J?>D1 ;C816D 3?>>53D54 D? 1 B978D1>7 79>5B549B53DC@?G5B6B?= D853B1>;C816DD?1F5BD931 =?G5B 9>1 71D 0..(2&(:3(4(2.,/$4,0/ '?45D5B=9>596D85% &5>79>5CG5B53?F5B542ID85C3?@5?6D85 #B45BC?==5B355H1=9>54D85@ 7E175?6D85C3?@51>4D85; C?EB35C 3?>C9CD9>7?6D85$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CDD85E>45B 7 '%5@?BD ?EBD"? $175 1>4D85$5D9D9?>&55$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CD1DDD &=1 79>5C6B?=89>1(& '$E2 >F"?C ' ' E7 N '%5@?BDO$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CD1DDD $5D9D9?>C6?BD85 =@?C9D9?>?6>D94E=@9>71>4?E>D5BF19 7ED95C5BD19> )5BD931 79>5C5DG55>331>4(@D? 331>4$1BDC'85B5?66B?=D85 $5?@ 1)? 5B1 6?B=1D9?>1>4 >:EBI!1B N$5D9D9?>O ?==5B3569BCD45D5B=9>54D81DD85% &5>79>5CG5B5NC@1B;97>9D54 C9>7 45B19B3?? D5B>1 5>79>5C25DG55>331>4 33 D81D75>5B1D5 ;GD? ;G?67B?CC@?G5BO9>1 71D39D9>7 $5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CD1DDD 35BD96931D9?>6B?=D851 919B %5C?EB35C?1B4N%O1>4DD41D16B?=D85>F9B?>=5>D1 75>3IN$OB571B49>7C=1 ?>B?14C@1B;97>9D9?>5>79>5C?==5B35 D85>45D5B=9>54D81DD855>79>5QC8?B9J?>D1 ;C816DG1C1DD13854D?1B978D 1>7 D1 D1D9?>D?1F5BD931 D1D9?>D8B?E7814?G>G1B4F5BD931 =?G5B B5CE 79>1F5BD931 54 D81DD858?B9J?>D1 ;C816DB978D1>7 4F5BD931 G1B4C816D 3?=@B9C541C9>7 79>5E>9D 4 ?EBD"? $175 '85$?G5B&=1BD=1>E1 3 79>5G8938 9C49F94549>D?9>49F94E1 C1>49C45@93D5425 E1 4931D5CD81DD85@1BD945>D969541C9D5= 9>D85C385=1D939CD855>79>5 1>4D85@1BDC945>D969541C9D5=C D? =1;5E@D85751B2?H$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5 %E 7%5AE5CD1D697EB5 C551 7?B1 DD85?F5B>=5>D3 54 D81D9D5=C D8B?E78 =1;5E@D85=?496954F5BD931 79>5G9D89D5= D855>79>5@ 7?>5C9>7 79>5E>9D #B1 D9663?>D5>454?>D85?D85B81>4D81D9D5= G1C ?EBD"? $175 D85?> 79>5E>9D1>43?>CD9DED5418?B9J?>D1 79>51>49D5=C D? D85751B2?HG5B5>?D@1BD?6D855>79>5 41D L '89C9>D5B@B5D1D9?>9C3B9D931 7B1D85BD81> F95G9>7D85% &1C18?B9J?>D1 79>5?==5B353?>C945B54D858?B9J?>D1 79>5 D85F5BD931 5NC9>7 79>5E>9DO9>?B45BD? 45D5B=9>5D81DD85B5G1C1F5BD931 5>D?6D85@B?4E3DD81D65 D85 C3?@5?6D85F5BD931 79>5#B45BC 6D5BB5 7?>D85@ C3?@5 7E1759>D85#B45BCD85?F5B>=5>D 1B7E54D81D?==5B355H1=9>54D85; C?EB35C?6D85$5D9D9?>E>45B 7 ' %5@?BD1>41BD93 4$5>>CI 91&D1D5(>9F5BC9DID?CE@@?BD 9DC45D5B=9>1D9?>D81DD85=?496954F5BD931 79>58141F5BD931 D1D9?> D8B?E789DCF5BD931 46? 549> D85C3?@5 7E1759>1 71DL '85$1BD95CEC549665B5>DD5B=9>? 5>DCD?45C3B9258?G D85% &5>79>5?@5B1D5CG9D8D852 =?G5B?BD85@EB@?C5C ?6D89C?@9>9?>D85?EBDB565BCD?D85DG?C816DC1D9CCE51CD858?B9J?>D1 ;C816D1>4D85F5BD931 4NF5BD931 G1B4C816DO2I?==5B351CD85 NF5BD931 C=9CC9?>C816DO2I$ D9661>41CD85NF5BD931 41>D >D5BF5>?BD858?B9J?>D1 ;C816D9CB565BB54D?1CD85N8?B9J?>D1 D966&559>1 7$ D5BFQC%5C@$ D96669BCD381 75C?==5B35QC45D5B=9>1D9?>D81DD85B978D1>7 4D85F5BD931 79>51>41B5D85B56?B5 9>3 D85C3?@5?6D85#B45BC$ D9663?>D5>4CD81DD85751B2?H1>4 F5BD931 ?D@1BD?6D855>79>5&55$ D85$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CD9>45D5B=9>9>7 D81DN.=/?496954F5BD931 79>5C3?>D19>18?B9J?>D1 ;C816D1DD13854 D?1B978D1>7 D1 D1D9?>D?1 F5BD931 D1D9?>D8B?E7814?G>G1B4C816DD?D852 =?G5BO 9>1 71D39D9>7$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CD1D L L L '85$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CD3?>D19>54145C3B9@D9?>?6D85 @8IC931 79>5 '85 % & 81C 1 8?B9J?>D1 ;C816D 2ED D85 5>79>5 81C 255> =?496954D?9>3 7 D1 D1D9?> $ED C9=@ D1 ;C816DDEB>C1751B1>4D81D751BD85>DEB>C1F5BD931 6B?=D85C945?6D855>79>5 ?EBD"? $175 $5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CD1D 449D9?>1 931 C G5B59>3 DD138=5>DC L 1>4L&55941DDD @93DEB5?6 =?G5B=1B;5D54?>*1 =?G5B =1B;5D54?>$?G5B&=1BDG52C9D5DD 35BD96931D9?>6B?=%DD 41D16B?=$B571B49>7C=1 ?>B?14C@1B;97>9D9?>5>79>5C1>4DD $?G5B&=1BD=1>E1 35@B?F94542I$5D9D9?>5BD?C8?GD81DD85 B978D1>7 4F5BD931 C945B54@1BDC?6D85% &5>79>5B1D85BD81>@1BDC?6D85 =?G5B9>1 71D 39D9>7D?$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CD1DL CC8?G>12?F5D85 $?G5B&=1BD=1>E1 3 79>5'85 =1>E1 4931D5CD81DD85@1BD945>D969541C9D5= 9CD855>79>51>4D85@1BDC 945>D969541C9D5=C D? =1;5E@D85751B2?H$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7 %5AE5CD1D697EB5 C551 4D?9>D85$5D9D9?>5BQC &3?@5%E 7%5AE5CD97EB5C 1>4 C8?G@8?D?7B1@8C?6D852?H @13;179>7?6D85 =?G5B1>4D85 =?G5B9DC5 C? 35D81DD85B978D1>7 D1>45=G9D8D855>79>59>CE@@?BD?69DC45D5B=9>1D9?>D81DD85 751B2?H31>B51C?>12 54D?251DD13854D?1>4@1BD?6D85 ?EBD"? $175 5>79>5'85?EBD?2C5BF5CD81D97EB59C1@8?D?7B1@8?6D85751B2?H G9D8?ED9DC3?F5B 41D 97EB59C1@8?D?7B1@8?6D855>79>5G9D8?ED D85751B2?H1DD13854D?9D1>497EB59C1@8?D?7B1@8?6D852?DD?=?6D85 =?G5BC8?G9>7D81DD85F5BD931 D5BG9D8D85 B5=?F1 7G9D845=?>CDB1D9>7D81DD85B59C1@E DB1 4D8B?E781>1449D9?>1 D85$?G5B&=1BD=1>E1 12?F545=?>CDB1D5CD81D9D5= 9C18?B9J?>D1 79>51>4 9D5=C D? =1;5E@D85751B2?H'89CCE@@?BDC$ D966QC@?C9D9?>1>49C 3?>DB1BID??==5B35QCC3?@5BE 7D81DD855>79>59>3?B@?B1D5CD85 751B2?H'89C5H1=@ 356B?=D85$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5 %E 7%5AE5CDD85B56?B54?5C>?DCE@@?BD?==5B35QCC3?@545D5B=9>1D9?> ?==5B35CD1D549>D859>1 7D81D2531EC5D85#B45BC4?>?D 9>3 5H81ECD9F5 5>DC>535CC1BI6?B1>5>79>5D?25 3?F5B54D85C3?@5 7E1754?5C>?D@B53 >53D54D?1C816D6B?= 259>73?>C945B541>9>D57B1D54@1BD?6D85% &5>79>59>1 71D ?==5B355H@ 54D81D EBD85B=?B5G569>4D81DD85C3?@5=5B5 E=5B1D5CD85=9>9=E= 3?=@?>5>DCD81D=ECD259>3 5D?253?>C945B541> 5>79>5B1D85BD81>@B?F949>71>5H81ECD9F5 ?D89>7 ?EBD"? $175 9>D85 7E175?6D85C3?@5D81D@B53 >53D54D?1 C816D6B?=259>73?>C945B541>9>D57B1D54@1BD?61>5>79>5 4 ?==5B35QC5H@ 1D9?>9C9>3?>C9CD5>DG9D8G5 DB571B49>7C3?@5BE 7C'85?EBD?6@@51 D5B@B5D541C9>3 7CE2:53D =5B381>49C5?> D19> 7E175D81DC@5396931 3 49C5?B=1I25B51C?>12 D5B@B5D54D?9>3 3F (>9D54&D1D5CNE65B3?O 4 549B &97>96931>D D81DD85C3?@5 7E175QCC9 35@5B=9DC?==5B35D? 9>D5B@B5DD85CE2:53D=5B381>49C5G9D89>D85C3?@5?6D85#B45BC9CD85?@@?C9D5?6 D85@B9>39@ E65B3?'85?EBD?2C5BF5CD81D751B2?H5C1B5>?D =5>D9?>549>D85C3?@5 7E175'85?EBD3?>3 7E1754?5C>?DC@5396ID81D1751B2?H3?>>53D54D?1C816D9C@1BD?6D855>79>5 ?B1>I 7E175D81DB51C?>12 4 ?==5B35QC 9>D5B@B5D1D9?>9C3?>DB1BID?G5 D?==5B35QC 45D5B=9>1D9?>D81DD85% &5>79>59>3 7 4F5BD931 59D85BCE@@?BD542ICE2CD1>D91 35>?B9>133?B41>35G9D8 D9663?>D5>4CD81D?==5B35QCC3?@545D5B=9>1D9?>9C>?D9>133?B41>35 G9D8 D91 352531EC5D85#B45BC3?F5B?> 79>5CG9D81F5BD931 79>581C1 8?B9J?>D1 D9664?5C>?D 381 75D851=297E9DI?6D85C3?@5 7E175?B?==5B35QC45D5B=9>1D9?>D81D D85% &5>79>5C1B5NC@1B;97>9D54C9>7 45B19B3?? D5B>1 5>79>5C25DG55>331>4 33D81D75>5B1D5 ;GD? ;G?6 7B?CC@?G5BO&5594$ D966?> D5CDC?==5B35QC45D5B=9>1D9?>D81DD85 N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DOG1CN=?496954F5BD931 8?B9J?>D1 =5>D1>4565>41>D >D5BF5>?BEB75D85?EBDD?CECD19> ?==5B35QCC3?@5BE 72531EC5D85I1B7E5D81D?==5B3545D5B=9>54 B51C?>12 79>565 D85C3?@5?6D85#B45BC21C54?> B53?B45F945>351>4@B?@5B; C?EB35C56QC%5C@1D 56 >D5BFQC%5C@ 1DL ?==5B354569>5C1N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DO1CN.'/85=5381>9C=D8B?E78 G8938@?G5B9CDB1>C=9DD546B?=D855>79>5D?1>1DD138549=@ DCE381C1 2 49D31>251C53?>41BI4B9F5C816D1C816D3?>>53D54F911751B2?H ?BDB1>C=9CC9?>D?D853B1>;C816DO9>1 71D$ D966381 75C D85C53?>4@1BD?6?==5B35QC4569>9D9?>?6N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DOG8938CD1D5C ?EBD"? $175 D81DN9D31>251C53?>41BI4B9F5C816D1C816D3?>>53D54F911751B2?H?B DB1>C=9CC9?>D?D853B1>;C816DO$ D9663?>D5>4CD81D?==5B35QCC3?@5BE 7 9C>?DCE@@?BD542ICE2CD1>D91 352531EC5?==5B3539D54E>B5 35CE381C*9;9@54911BD93 49BB5 D5F945>35D81DG1C>?DC@539693 D?5>79>5CEC546?B =?G5BC$ D966381 75C?==5B35QC45D5B=9>1D9?>D81DD85F5BD931 253?>C945B541N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DO21C54?>?==5B35QC4569>9D9?>?61 N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DO1C1NC53?>41BI4B9F5C816DOD81D31>253?>>53D54D?D85 5>79>5F911751B2?H?B1>I?D85BC53?>41BI4B9F5C816D 41D$ D966 49C17B55CG9D8D89C4569>9D9?> 4 '?CE@@?BD9DC45D5B=9>1D9?>?==5B35B5 DG?1BD93 4?>513145=931BD93 9D9?>?6N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DO 9>1 71D> C55$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CD1DDDC 2 3 '85?EBD?2C5BF5CD81D>?>5?6D85C51BD93 2I?==5B35 49C3ECC1N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DO9>D853?>D5HD?6G1 4 =?G5BC?B @B?F945C@5396939>6?B=1D9?>1CD?8?G1N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DO31>251 NC53?>41BI4B9F5C816DOCE381C1C816D3?>>53D54F911751B2?H?BDB1>C=9CC9?> D?D853B1>;C816D C1@B5 1BI=1DD5BD85?EBDB5:53DCD85B5 3545C5BF9>7?6:E49391 ?D935&55$5D9D9?>5BQC ?EBD"? $175 &3?@5%E 7%5AE5CD1DDDC 1 2 3*9;9@549145C3B925C9DC5 3I3 3? 4N.1/>I?>531> 549D1 4C?=5D89>7D81D31>259=@B?F541>4=1;59D 25DD5BO*9;9@54911BD93 ?D3?>D19>D85549D?B91 DB? 4=1I25=1>9@E I?>5 '85(&?EBD?6 >D5B>1D9?>1 35B>C12?ED *9;9@54914E5D?9DCE>B5 5F945>D91BIC?EB35&55$$B?4"= >3F(>9D54&D1D5C ' &E@@ 4 > N1C54?>D85129 IEC5BD?1 C9CD5>D 6?B=1D9?>DD89CD9=5D85B56?B5D853?EBD4?5C >?D1335@D*9;9@54916?B@EB@?C5C?6:E49391 ?D935O?EBDC81F55H@B5CC54 3?>35B>C?F5B*9;9@5491QC DB? 4 6?B ?EB @EB@?C5C 49CDEB29>7 C5B95C ?6 49C3 7 D85= D81D 9 1>I 79F5>*9;9@54911BD93 I79F5>=?=5>D9>1214CD1D5 6?B5H1=@ D85=944 B535>D 41 4 ?=9CC9?>CO 999 N*9;9@5491 1BD93 3?=@ G1ICD81DG?E 1 =?B5 D978D DB? 35 G?B;O 9F N.1/>?D85B @B?2 D5>D ?>*9;9@54919C D81D =1>I 3?>DB92ED?BC4?>?D39D5D859BC?EB35CC?=5D89>7D81D=1;5C9D81B46?B D85B5145BD?:E475D853B54929 O1>4FN=1>I >DB?4E3D9?>D?*9;9@5491 8DD@C5>G9;9@5491?B7G9;9 5 DB?4E3D9?>0D?0*9;9@5491 35D859B 4B16DCO1>4=1I25N31E78DE@ 9>1851F9 21 354F95G@?9>DO 1=@25 4 E=1>&5BFC54 35B>C12?EDD85 41>75BC?6B5 7?>*9;9@54911C1>1ED8?B9D1D9F5C?EB35&5557141C1F !E;1C5I 4 D89B ; 9>7&8E> 9F ? B5:53D54*9;9@54911C5F945>359>31C5C1@@51 D5B>1D9?>1 4?>7%?>7H9> =@H@?F (>9D54&D1D5C '0000 &E@@ 4 N?==5B35 49C3?E>D54D85*9;9@54911BD93 5CC1>4 1ED8?B9D1D9F539D1D9?>'853?EBD6EBD85B>?D5CD81D*9;9@54919C?6D5>1> E>B5 D91BIC?EB35O+91=5> >DQ 4EC?F(>9D54&D1D5C ' &E@@ 4 N?==5B3549C=9CC54 + ' QC*9;9@54915>DBI1CE>B5 D19>54>?39D1D9?>CD??EDC945 C?EB35CCE@@?BD9>7D851BD93 9D9?>CO D9CB5=1B;12 356?B?F5B14531451>485B5 ?==5B3539D5C*9;9@54911C5F945>35256?B5D89C?EBD'85?EBDF95GC ?==5B35QC851FIB5 35?>*9;9@54911BD93 9>4931D9?>?6D85G51;>5CC ?6?==5B35QCC3?@545D5B=9>1D9?> ?EBD"? $175 >1449D9?>D?259>7E>B5 35D85*9;9@54911BD93 ?D145AE1D5 G81D1N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DO9C@1BD93E D853?>D5HD?61G1 4 =?G5B&55$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7 %5AE5CD1DDDC 2 3DD138=5>D 245C3B925CN@?G5BD1;5?66O1C?>5?6 C5F5B1 7@?G5B6B?=1@?G5BC?EB35CE381C1BE>>9>75>79>5 1>4DB1>C=9DD9>79DD?1>1@@ CE381C1>1DD138549=@ D?BC5@1B1D5 =1389>5 41DDD 2'89C1BD93 D9?>CD851@@ ?6D89C=5D8?4 D??D85B;9>4C?6 5BICE381CDB13D?BCDBE3;C1>4:5D19B3B16DC1>4D85 D5B=NC53?>41BIO9C9>3 359>D853?>D5HD?6NC5=9@5B=1>5>D D54 @?G5BD1;5?66CO?>9>4ECDB91 4=1B9>55>79>5CG8938NDI@931 42? DD?DB1>C=9D@?G5BD?1C53?>41BI9=@ D?B1335CC?BIO 4'85B59C>?9>4931D9?>D81DD85% &5>79>59>3 5>D D54@?G5BD1;5?66O1>4D85% &9C1C=1 79>56?B =?G5BCM>?D 1>9>4ECDB91 55>79>5&559>1 7$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7 %5AE5CDDD138=5>D 345C3B925C1N4B9F5C816DO1C13?=@?>5>D6?BDB1>C=9DD9>7 =5381>931 4B?D1D9?>G89389CEC54D?3?>>53D?D85B3?=@?>5>DC ?614B9F5DB19>D81D31>>?D253?>>53D5449B53D 35?BD85>554D? 1 D25DG55>D85=$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CD1D DD 3'851BD93 D853?>D5HD?61ED?=?29 4293I3 3 5B1 ?6N@?G5BD1;5?66O4B9F5C816DC45C3B929>7D85=1CN?>5 =5D8?4?6DB1>C65BB9>7@?G5B6B?=1>5>79>51>4.@?G5BD1;5?66/D?F5893 D541335CC?BI5AE9@=5>DCE381C1>19B3?=@B5CC?BO1>4NEC54G85>D85B5 9C>QD5>?E78C@13525DG55>D855>79>5@?G5BD1;5?661>41335CC?BIO2ED619 D9?>4B9F5C816DC1@@ 4 =?G5BC?BG85D85B1N@?G5B D1;5?66C816DO=1I251C53?>41BI4B9F5C816D3?>>53D54F911751B2?HD?D85 8?B9J?>D1 ;C816D1C9>D85% &5>79>5 4 531EC5?==5B35QC4569>9D9?>?61N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DO9C21C54?>D85C5 E>B5 49BB5 D*9;9@54911BD93 49CG81DE 1D9?>D81DD85% &5>79>561 D85C3?@5?6D85 #B45BCD85?EBD3?>3 1D9?>?>D859CCE5?61 N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DO9C>?DCE@@?BD542ICE2CD1>D91 35 '85?> 2I?==5B35D81D9C>?D6B?=*9;9@54919C DD138=5>D 1>1BD93 >CI 91&D1D5(>9F5BC9DID81D49C3ECC5C@?G5B D1;5?66C165DI9>D853?>D5HD?661B=DB13D?BC1>49=@ DC 41DDD '85 1BD93 5CD85N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DO1CN1>5669395>D=51>C?6DB1>C65BB9>7 =5381>931 61B=DB13D?BC1>49=@ DCO1>449C3ECC5CD85 81J1B4C?6D85C816D1CC?391D54G9D861B==1389>5BI1>4C165DI@B13D935CD? =9D971D5D8581J1B4C 4*89 13145=93@E2 9D9C9BB5 D2531EC59D1 ?DC@5396931 D853?>D5HD?6G1 4 =?G5BC?B1C1 C53?>41BIC816D3?>>53D54F911751B2?HD?13B1>;C816D'8ECD85?EBD 3?>3 >CI 91&D1D5(>9F5BC9DI4?5C>?D@B?F945 5F945>D91BICE@@?BD6?B?==5B35QCC3?@5BE 7 565>41>D1>4565>41>D >D5BF5>?B1B7E5D81D9DG1CB51C?>12 D85C51BD93 5D81D1N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DO31> 251F5BD931 9D9CEC541C1=51>CD?DB1>C=9D@?G5BD?D852 46?B3?==?>9>4ECDBIE>45BCD1>49>7?6D85B5 D5>79>53?=@?>5>DC5F5> D8?E78D85I1B5>?DC@539693D? =?G5BC&5556QC%5C@1D56 >F5BFQC %5C@1D'85?EBD49C17B55C'85*9;9@54911BD93 >?D25B5 6?BD85 4569>9D9?>?61N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DO1C259>71C53?>41BI4B9F5C816D1DD13854F91 1751B2?HD?13B1>;C816D1>4D8513145=931BD93 ?D145AE1D5 9D9?>&E2CD1>D91 359CNCE38B5 D5F945>351C1 B51C?>12 4=978D1335@D1C145AE1D5D?CE@@?BD13?>3 O(>9F5BC1 D91 35N2I3?>C945B9>7D85B53?B41C1G8? 3 7 5F945>35D81DCE@@?BDC1CG5 35D81DP619B D91 35QO5135B?&45)F(>9D54&D1D5C ' L &E@@ 4 39D1D9?>1>49>D5B>1 C?=9DD54*89 5B1 C65BCICD5=D85I619 1D9?> 2531EC5D85I4?>?D144B5CCD85C@5396933?>D5HD?6 =?G5BC1>4D85 *9;9@54911BD93 85B5>D B5 D91BIC?EB35C #D85BB53?B45F945>351 ?DCE669395>D 1D9?>2531EC5D854?3E=5>DC4?>?D5H@ G8I18?B9J?>D1 ;C816D 31>>?D251N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DO6?BD85% &5>79>5'85@ C3?@5 7E175?6D85#B45BC4?5C>?D5H3 71N@?G5B D1;5?66C816DO2ED9D1 ?D5H3 D1 ;C816DC6B?=259>71 N@?G5BD1;5?66C816DO?==5B35QCB5 35?>D85$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7 %5AE5CDD85 '%5@?BD1>4D85$5D9D9?>4?>?D@B?F945145AE1D5CE@@?BD1CD? G8ID85DB1>C=9CC9?>?6@?G5BD8B?E78135BD19>C816DG?E 45B9D1N@?G5B D1;5?66C816DO96@?G5B31>7?D8B?E782?D8D858?B9J?>D1 ;C816D1>4F5BD931 41BIC816D3?>>53D54D?1 751B2?H'85$1BD95CC55=D?3?>3545D81DD85@?G5B6B?=D855>79>5=ECD1D C?=5@?9>D25DB1>C=9DD549>1F5BD931 9>?B45BD?B5138D85 =?G5B 2 N9>D5B=5491BIO256?B59D B51385C1DB1>C=9CC9?>25 D966?B1CD85N@?G5BD1;5?66 C816DOD81DE 41>D1>4565>41>D >D5BF5>?B&55$ D5BFQC%5C@1D$ 41>D >D5BF5>?B1CC5BDCD81DNG85D85B2?D8D853B1>;C816D1>4D85 ?EBD"? $175 4B9F54B16D1B53?>C945B54.@?G5BD1;5?66/C816DC?BG85D85B?> 41BI 4B9F5C816DC8?E C945B54D85.@?G5BD1;5?66/C816D9C9BB5 DO2EDD89C 9>D5B@B5D1D9?>619 756 >D5BFQC%5C@1D 565>41>D3?>D5>4C9>9DC2B956256?B5D85?EBDD81DD858?B9J?>D1 ;C816D 31>>?DDB1>C=9D@?G5BD?D852 D1 ;C816DG5B5D85@?G5BD1;5?66C816DD85 =?G5B2 1D9 51>4>?D6 D857B?E>4O2ED?==5B35 494>?DB19C5D89C@?9>D9>9DC9>1 756QC%5C@1D39D9>7 $5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CD1D B565B5>39>7DDD5CD9=?>I?6 $5D9D9?>5BQCC5>9?BF935@B5C945>D256?B5D85(& >D5B>1D9?>1 C559>1 71D ?==5B35QCB5 35?>D85$5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CD6?B75>5B1 6?B=1D9?>?>5>79>5C45C97>546?BEC5?>1 =?G5B9C>?DCE669395>D'85 $5D9D9?>5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CDCD1D5C F5BI?D85B5>79>545C97>546?BEC5?>=?G5BC81C?> 5C816D1 F5BD931 ;C816DG89381 7D85 2 ?D>535CC1B9 97EB5 D85 =?496954 % & 81C 1 F5BD931 >53D54D?D85751B2?HD81DDB1>C=9DC@?G5BCDB1978D4?G>D855>79>5 D?D85=?G5B2 5BQC&3?@5%E 7%5AE5CD1D 97EB545@93D5425 7D81DD85751BCG?B;G9D8D858?B9J?>D1 ;C816D6B?=D85C945?6D855>79>51>41F5BD931 ?D45=?>CDB1D5D81DD85@?G5B9CDB1>C=9DD546B?=D85F5BD931 ?DCE669395>D5F945>35D?45=?>CDB1D5D81D@?G5B31>?> C=9DD546B?= D85F5BD931 =?G5B '85?EBD3?>3 1D9?>9C>?D CE@@?BD542ICE2CD1>D91 351>4>?D9>133?B41>35G9D8 7B51C?>CD85?EBDB5=1>4C?==5B35QC9>1 71CE>CE@@?BD542ICE2CD1>D91 351>4>?D9>133?B41>35G9D8 7 4B545D5B=9>1D9?>?>?B 256?B5@B9 49D9C6EBD85B D81D?==5B35C81 9CDB1D9F5B53?B4?>B5=1>4 ?>?B256?B5!1I 1>49D9C6EBD85B D81DD85$1BD95CC81 I3?==5>DC?>D85B5=1>4 B545D5B=9>1D9?>?B256?B5 E>5 1>49D9C6EBD85B D81DD85$1BD95CC81 DC?>?B256?B5 E 49D9C6EBD85B D81DD85:?9>D1@@5>49HC81 ?B256?B5 E >965B8?5B?F5C 5>>965B8?5B?F5C E475 1D5452BE1BI "5G,?B;"5G,?B;
Document Info
Docket Number： 23-00011
Citation Numbers： 2024 CIT 20
Judges： Choe-Groves
Filed Date： 2/20/2024
Precedential Status： Precedential
Modified Date： 2/20/2024