Nelson Creek Coal Co. v. West Point Brick & Lumber Co. , 153 Ky. 232 ( 1913 )

Response to Petition for Rehearing and Correction of Opinion by

Judge Settle

(For original opinion, see 151 Ky., 835.)

The petition for rehearing calls our attention to 'st manifest mistake of figures in the opinion.

That is, it is said in the opinion:

“As under the contract between them appellant undertook to ship appellee the coal delivered in March from its own mine, and appellee, if it had done so, would have paid a freight rate thereon of only 60 cents per ton; when it failed to ship the coal from its own mine and required appellee to receive it from another and more distant mine at an increased freight rate, it became liable to appellee for the amount of such increase. For this amount, 10 cents per ton, appellee recovered judgment in the court below and to that extent the judgment is correct.”

The mistake in the foregoing excerpt from the opinion lies in the statement that the excess in freight rate thus-paid by appellee was 10 cents per ton, when, in fact, the true excess was 60 cents per ton, and for this 60 cents per ton appellee was properly given judgment in the court below. In other words, the freight rate paid by appellee on the coal received by him from the Bevier mine was $1.20 per ton, instead of 70 cents per ton as in another part of the opinion stated. To the extent indicated the opinion is corrected, but in other respects the petition for rehearing is overruled.