A. Smith v. 8th Judicial District ( 2023 )

05/09/2023
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF MONTANA
Case Number: OP 23-0241
OP 23-0241
ED
ALEX C. SMITH,
MAY 0 9 2023
Bowen Greenwood
Petitioner, Clerk of Suprerne Court
State of Montana
v.
ORDER
EIGHTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT,
HON. JOHN PARKER, Presiding,
Respondent.
Alex Smith petitions this Court for supervisory control over the Eighth Judicial
District Court, Cascade County. Smith is currently incarcerated in the Crossroads
Correctional Center in Shelby, Montana.
Smith contends that "an extraordinary miscarriage of justice continues, in [his]
petition for postconviction relief, as [he] is being prevented from proving [his] innocence
by multiple involved parties[.]" He further contends that his due process rights have been
violated and his "multiple attempts" by others have "stifle[d] [his] progress in seeking
redress[.]" Smith explains the history of his underlying criminal case, and he challenges
the arrest, his counsel's representation, the prosecution, and his pending petition for relief
in the District Court. Smith maintains ineffective assistance of counsel claims throughout
his writ, requesting expedited relief.
Smith also refers to his former petitions in this Court. See Smith v. Salmonsen, No.
OP 22-0468, Order (Mont. Sept. 20, 2022) (Smith I) and Smith v. Salmonsen, No.
OP 22-0694, Order (Mont. Dec. 27, 2022) (Smith II). We provided that:
[T]he State charged Smith with five felonies, including attempted deliberate
homicide, on August 14, 2021, in the Cascade County District Court. On
June 24, 2022, the District Court accepted Smith's nolo contendere pleas to
two counts of felony assault with a weapon (reasonable apprehension) and
sentenced Smith to the Montana State Prison for two, consecutive
twenty-year terms. Smith did not appeal his conviction and sentence to this
Court.
Smith I, at 1. See also Smith II, at 1.
Supervisory control operates on a case-by-case basis. "This extraordinary remedy
can be invoked when the case involves purely legal questions and urgent or emergency
factors make the normal appeal process inadequate." State v. Spady, 2015 MT 218, ¶ 11,
380 Mont. 179, 354 P.3d 590 (citing M. R. App. P. 14(3); Redding v. McCarter, 2012 MT
144, ¶ 17, 365 Mont. 316, 281 P.3d 189). The case must meet one of three additional
criteria. Spady, ¶ 11; M. R. App. P. 14(3)(a)-(c).
This Court points out that in June of 2022, Smith's underlying crirninal case
concluded in the District Court. There is no matter in the District Court over which to take
supervisory control. Smith does not have a pending petition for postconviction relief either.
We secured the register of actions or docket sheet frorn the District Court. In
January 2023, Smith filed an affidavit of inability to pay filing fees and other costs. The
District Court issued an order granting his request a week later, on January 26, 2023. There
has been no filing of a petition for postconviction relief in the District Court. Smith should
file his petition for postconviction relief as soon as possible in the District Court.
Accordingly,
IT IS ORDERED that Smith's Petition for a Writ of Supervisory Control is
DENIED and DISMISSED.
The Clerk is directed to provide a copy of this Order to: the Honorable John Parker,
District Court Judge; Tina Henry, Clerk of District Court, Cascade County, under Cause
No. DDV-2023-034; counsel of record, and to Alex Smith along with a copy of the court's
register of actions.
DATED this 9, --a-ay of May, 2023.
I r VPir)11
Chief Justice
4
2
e)4 A4,4.L
?,,.___
,C4.
Justices
3