Shawn (Rick) v. State ( 2015 )


Menu:
  •                    Appellant concedes that he failed to use the notice of appeal log as
    required. 1 Accordingly, we
    ORDER this appeal DISMISSED.
    J.
    Gibbons
    PICKERING, J.,dissenting;
    Under this court's holding in               Kellogg v. Journal
    Communications, 
    108 Nev. 474
    , 477, 
    835 P.2d 12
    , 13 (1992), if appellant
    delivered his notice of appeal to a prison official for mailing on or before
    August 4, 2014, the notice of appeal would be deemed timely filed.
    Likewise, NRAP 4(d) provides that a notice of appeal "is timely if it is
    delivered to a prison official for mailing on or before the last day for filing."
    NRAP 4(d) further provides that when the prison has a notice of appeal
    log or another system designed for legal mail, the prisoner must use the
    logs to receive the benefit of this rule.
    Here, it appears that appellant delivered his notice of appeal
    to a prison official for filing on July 26, 2014, within the 30-day appeal
    1 We decline to address appellant's contention that NRAP 4(d) is
    unconstitutional because it is not supported by cogent argument. See
    Maresca v. State, 
    103 Nev. 669
    , 673, 
    748 P.2d 3
    , 6 (1987).
    SUPREME COURT
    OF
    NEVADA
    2
    (0) 1947A (A(M49
    period provided by NRS 34.560(2). Although appellant did not use the
    notice of appeal log, as the majority holds NRAP 4(d) requires, I am not
    convinced that NRAP 4(d) should be applied to defeat this court's
    jurisdiction under the unique circumstances of this case, especially where
    our prior orders in this appeal stated that appellant's notice of appeal
    would be deemed timely filed pursuant to NRAP 4(d) if he could provide
    documentation establishing that he timely delivered the notice of appeal
    to a prison official for mailing. Given our prior orders and appellant's
    timely delivery of the notice of appeal to a prison official, NRAP 2
    authorizes this court to suspend application of NRAP 4(d). I would do so
    and allow this appeal to proceed.
    J.
    Pickering
    cc:   Chief Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court
    Carmine J. Colucci & Associates
    Attorney General/Carson City
    Clark County District Attorney
    Eighth District Court Clerk
    Rick Shawn
    SUPREME COURT
    OF
    NEVADA
    3
    (0) 1947A ero
    

Document Info

Docket Number: 66376

Filed Date: 6/30/2015

Precedential Status: Non-Precedential

Modified Date: 4/17/2021