Sanders (Timothy) v. State ( 2015 )


Menu:
  •                 facts de novo. Lader v. Warden, 
    121 Nev. 682
    , 686, 
    120 P.3d 1164
    , 1166
    (2005).
    First, Sanders argues that trial counsel was ineffective for
    failing to file a pretrial motion to suppress his statement to officers during
    a custodial interrogation. When an ineffective-assistance claim is based
    upon the failure to file a motion to suppress, "the prejudice prong must be
    established by a showing that the claim was meritorious and that there
    was a reasonable likelihood that the exclusion of the evidence would have
    changed the result of a trial."   Kirksey v. State, 
    112 Nev. 980
    , 990, 
    923 P.2d 1102
    , 1109 (1996). Sanders fails to allege, let alone demonstrate, a
    reasonable likelihood of a different result at trial had the statements been
    suppressed. Additionally, Sanders does not identify what statements,
    made after his alleged invocation of counsel, should have been suppressed
    or allege that any such statements were introduced at trial. We therefore
    conclude that the district court did not err by denying this claim.
    Second, Sanders contends that trial counsel was ineffective for
    failing to file a pretrial motion to sever the joint trial because he was
    prejudiced when the State referred to the defendants collectively during
    argument to the jury and when evidence against each defendant came in
    against both. Sanders fails to demonstrate deficiency as he has not
    demonstrated that such a motion would have been successful.                See
    Donovan v. State, 
    94 Nev. 671
    , 675, 
    584 P.2d 708
    , 711 (1978) (holding that
    counsel cannot be ineffective for failing to make futile motions).
    SUPREME COURT
    OF
    NEVADA
    2
    (0) 1947A   e
    Therefore, we conclude the district court did not err by denying this claim.
    Accordingly, we
    ORDER the judgment of the district court AFFIRMED.
    Saitta
    cc:   Hon. Stefany Miley, District Judge
    Carmine J. Colucci & Associates
    Attorney General/Carson City
    Clark County District Attorney
    Eighth District Court Clerk
    SUPREME COURT
    OF
    NEVADA
    3
    (0) 1947A    44e40
    

Document Info

Docket Number: 64005

Filed Date: 6/10/2015

Precedential Status: Non-Precedential

Modified Date: 4/17/2021