Collins (Lionel) v. State ( 2014 )


Menu:
  •                       an evidentiary hearing, a petitioner must raise claims that are supported
    by specific factual allegations that are not belied by the record and, if true,
    would entitle him to relief. Hargrove v. State, 
    100 Nev. 498
    , 502-03, 
    686 P.2d 222
    , 225 (1984).
    First, appellant argues that trial counsel was ineffective for
    failing to conduct a proper investigation before appellant pleaded guilty.
    Appellant failed to demonstrate deficiency or prejudice, as he did not
    provide specific factual allegations as to what counsel should have done or
    how further investigation would have affected appellant's decision to plead
    guilty. See 
    id. Therefore, the
    district court did not err in denying this
    claim.
    Second, appellant argues that trial counsel was ineffective for
    failing to object to expert testimony at the preliminary hearing and for
    failing to challenge the testimony in a pretrial petition for a writ of habeas
    corpus. Appellant contends that the expert's testimony about the victim's
    cause of death violated the Confrontation Clause because the expert was
    not the person who conducted the autopsy on the victim. Appellant failed
    to demonstrate deficiency or prejudice. A defendant has no constitutional
    right to confrontation at preliminary hearings. See Sheriff v. Witzenburg,
    
    122 Nev. 1056
    , 1062, 
    145 P.3d 1002
    , 1006 (2006). Thus, any objection or
    challenge to the expert's testimony on this basis would have been futile.
    See Ennis v. State, 
    122 Nev. 694
    , 706, 
    137 P.3d 1095
    , 1103 (2006) (stating
    that counsel cannot be deemed ineffective for failing to make a futile
    objection). Therefore, the district court did not err in denying this claim.
    SUPREME COURT
    OF
    NEVADA
    2
    (0) 1947A .9.109114
    Because appellant's claims did not entitle him to relief, the
    district court did not err in denying the petition without an evidentiary
    hearing. Accordingly, we
    ORDER the judgment of the district court AFFIRMED.
    cc: Hon. Kathleen E. Delaney, District Judge
    Christopher R. Oram
    Attorney General/Carson City
    Clark County District Attorney
    Eighth District Court Clerk
    SUPREME COURT
    OF
    NEVADA
    3
    (0) 1.947A .4te4ED
    

Document Info

Docket Number: 62933

Filed Date: 4/10/2014

Precedential Status: Non-Precedential

Modified Date: 4/17/2021