Vogel Vs. The Marla Bay Protective Ass'N, Inc. C/W 81424 ( 2021 )

81123: Case View

Nevada Appellate Courts Appellate Case Management System C-Track, the browser based CMS for Appellate Courts Case Search Participant Search

Cases Participant Search 21-36092: This document is currently unavailable. If you need a copy of this document, please contact Clerk's Office at (775)684-1600. Disclaimer: The information and documents available here should not be relied upon as an official record of action. Only filed documents can be viewed. Some documents received in a case may not be available for viewing. Some documents originating from a lower court, including records and appendices, may not be available for viewing. For official records, please contact the Clerk of the Supreme Court of Nevada at (775) 684-1600. Case Information: 81123 Short Caption: VOGEL VS. THE MARLA BAY PROTECTIVE ASS'N, INC. C/W 81424 Court: Supreme Court Consolidated: 81123*, 81424 Related Case(s): 81424 Lower Court Case(s): Douglas Co. - Ninth Judicial District - 2018-CV-0272 Classification: Civil Appeal - General - Other Disqualifications: Case Status: Disposition Filed Replacement: Panel Assigned: Panel To SP/Judge: 05/06/2020 / Wasick, David SP Status: Completed Oral Argument: 10/13/2021 at 11:00 AM Oral Argument Location: Carson City Submission Date: 10/13/2021 How Submitted: After Oral Argument + Party Information Role Party Name Represented By Appellant Claudette D. Vogel Ronald D. Alling (Alling & Jillson, Ltd.) James R. Hales (Alling & Jillson, Ltd.) Perry Woodward (Hopkins & Carley, ALC) Appellant Ronald W. Vogel Ronald D. Alling (Alling & Jillson, Ltd.) James R. Hales (Alling & Jillson, Ltd.) Perry Woodward (Hopkins & Carley, ALC) Respondent 610 Lakeshore LLC Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent 650 Lakeshore LLC Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Alan Scott Leinassar Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Ana T. Farnesi Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Andrew Curtis Lucchesi Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Audrey J. Lampert Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Barbara Boucke Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Belinda S. Zola Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent C. Joel Casburn Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent C. Lynn Casburn Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Carol A. Bloch Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Carol A. McQuirk Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Carolyn J. Whear Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Cathy J. Stewart Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Charles D. Bloch Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Charles J. Voss Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Charles M. Corsiglia Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Charmayne L. Zucker Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Cheryl Chilcoat Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Constance T. Breeze Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Darin G. Fain Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Darrell F. Champion and Joy H. Champion Trust, Under Instrument dated March 27, 2012 Respondent Debra A. Rossi Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Deeann Fulstone Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Dennis B. Farnesi Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Donald R. Swickard Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Donald Samuel Lobato Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Donn Hawksford Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Edward A. White Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Elizabeth A. Nelson Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent F. Scott Hindes Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Garrett D. Schwartz Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Gloria Janis Lee Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Hans J. Wintsch Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Heidi L. Wintsch Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Hope Righetti Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent James J. Wood Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent James S. Voorhees Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Jane A. Beckett Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Jane Finley Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Jeanne Finley Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent John A. McQuirk Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent John F. Ahern Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent John Finley Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent John Stephans Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Joseph Finley Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Joseph T. Breeze Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Joshua Dempsey Lampert Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Judith W. Ahern Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Judy Fujii-Hwang Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Julie E. Voorhees Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Kathy Klein Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent L. Robert Legoy, Jr. Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Lampert Family Trust, dated July 23, 2008 Respondent Larry B. Pilgrim Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Larry L. Wilson, II Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Marianne Fulstone Leinassar Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Marianne Whear Anthony Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Marla Bay, LLC Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Martha L. Voss Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Mary Stephans Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Matthew Till Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Michael Chilcoat Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Michelle L. Whitten Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Milton E. Righetti Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Nancy Nelson Hindes Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Nancy Ruth Paulson Edmundson Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Nicholas D.E. Rossi, Jr. Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Nita S. Schwartz Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Palmina M. Rende Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Patricia P. White Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Paul M Hwang Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Phyllis T. Pike Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Piper L. Smith Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Riley M. Beckett Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Robert E. Whear Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Roland E. Rende Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Sally J. Wood Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Sarah V. Anaya Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Schuyler Hamilton Earl, II Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Scott Fink Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Scott Fink and Kathy Klein Living Trust Dated 12-9-91 Respondent Scott H. Hilkene Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Scott J. Whitten Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Scott M. Smith Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Steven C. Zola Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Steven F. Petersen Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent The Marla Bay Protective Association Catherine L. DiCamillo (Feldman Thiel, LLP) Respondent Todd R. Whear Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Toni M. Pilgrim Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) Respondent Twyila S. Whear Thomas J. Hall (Law Offices of Thomas J. Hall) + Due Items Due Date Status Due Item Due From 01/11/2022 Open Remittitur Docket Entries Date Type Description Pending? Document 05/04/2020 Filing Fee Filing Fee Paid. $250.00 from Hopkins Carley. Check no. 122587. (SC) 05/04/2020 Notice of Appeal Documents Filed Notice of Appeal. Appeal docketed in the Supreme Court this day. (Docketing statement mailed to counsel for appellant.) (SC) 20-16807 05/04/2020 Notice/Outgoing Issued Notice of Referral to Settlement Program. This appeal may be assigned to the settlement program. Timelines for requesting transcripts and filing briefs are stayed. (SC) 20-16812 05/06/2020 Settlement Notice Issued Notice: Assignment to Settlement Program. Issued Assignment Notice to NRAP 16 Settlement Program. Settlement Judge: David Wasick. (SC) 20-17108 05/19/2020 Notice/Incoming Filed Notice of Appearance as Counsel of Record (Catherine l. DiCamillo as counsel for Respondent Marla Bay Protective Association). (SC) 20-19076 05/19/2020 Notice/Outgoing Issued Notice to Provide Proof of Service on Settlement Judge. 20-19087 05/26/2020 Docketing Statement Filed Vogels' Docketing Statement - Civil Appeal. (SC). 20-19842 05/26/2020 Notice/Outgoing Issued Notice to Provide Proof of Service on Settlement Judge (Docketing Statement). (SC). 20-19885 05/27/2020 Notice/Incoming Filed Certificate of Service (Notice of Appearance as Counsel of Record-Settlement Judge). (SC) 20-20066 05/29/2020 Settlement Program Report Filed ECAR/Not Appropriate for Settlement Program. This case is not appropriate for mediation. (SC) 20-20402 05/30/2020 Notice/Incoming Filed Certificate of Service of Docketing Statement by Mail (Served on Settlement Judge). (SC). 20-20452 06/01/2020 Motion Filed Respondents' Response to Appellants' Statement of the Case & Issues on Appeal. (SC). 20-20531 06/03/2020 Settlement Order/Procedural Filed Order Removing From Settlement Program/Briefing Reinstated. This appeal is removed from the settlement program. Appellants: 14 days transcript request; 90 days opening brief and appendix. (SC). 20-20883 06/17/2020 Transcript Request Filed Request for Transcript of Proceedings. Transcripts requested: 07/24/19, 10/31/19. To Court Reporter: Kathy Jackson. (SC). 20-22645 06/23/2020 Transcript Request Filed Proof of Service - Request for Transcript of Proceedings. (SC). 20-23171 06/30/2020 Transcript Filed Notice from Court Reporter. Kathy Jackson stating that the requested transcripts were delivered. Dates of transcripts: 07/24/19 and 10/31/19. (SC) 20-24222 07/10/2020 Transcript Filed Amended Notice from Court Reporter. Kathy Jackson stating that the requested transcripts were delivered. Dates of transcripts: 07/24/19 and 10/31/19. (SC) 20-25482 07/20/2020 Motion Filed Respondents' Motion to Correct Caption. (SC) 20-26425 07/28/2020 Order/Procedural Filed Order Amending Caption. The clerk of this court shall amend the caption on the docket to conform to the caption on this order. If any party objects to the amendment, that party shall so inform this court in writing within 7 days of the date of this order. (SC) 20-27455 08/31/2020 Motion Filed Appellants' Motion to Combine Nevada Supreme Court Case Nos. 81123 and 81424. (SC) 20-31958 08/31/2020 Motion Filed Appellants' Motion to Modify the Parties' Briefing Schedule. (SC) 20-31959 08/31/2020 Notice/Outgoing Issued Notice to Provide Proof of Service. Due date: 10 days. 20-32056 09/03/2020 Notice/Incoming Filed Certificate of Service (Appellants' Motion to Combine Nevada Supreme Court Case Nos. 81123 and 81424 and Appellants' Motion to Modify the Parties' Briefing Schedule). Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 20-32504 09/03/2020 Order/Procedural Filed Order Consolidating Appeals and Modifying the Briefing Schedule. Appellants shall have until November 5, 2020, to file and serve a single opening brief and an appendix. Respondents shall have until January 8, 2021, to file and serve the answering brief. Appellant shall have 30 days from the date the answering brief is filed to file and serve a reply brief, if deemed necessary. The clerk of this court shall amend the caption in Docket No. 81424 to conform to the caption on this order. If any party objects to the amendment, that party shall so inform this court in writing within 7 days of the date of this order. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 20-32536 09/03/2020 Motion Filed Respondents' Response to Appellants' Motion to Modify the Parties' Briefing Schedule and Motion to Combine Nevada Supreme Court Case Nos. 81123 and 81424. (SC) 20-32560 10/20/2020 Motion Filed Appellant's Motion to Extend Time to Modify the Parties' Briefing Schedule. Nos. 81123/81424 (SC) 20-38324 10/20/2020 Notice/Incoming Filed Appellant's Proof of Service for Motion filed. Nos. 81123/81424 (SC) 20-38325 10/20/2020 Motion Filed Appellant's Motion to Extend Time to Modify the Parties' Briefing Schedule. Nos. 81123/81424 (SC) 20-38326 10/20/2020 Motion Filed Appellant's Certificate of Service. Nos. 81123/81424 (SC) 20-38327 10/21/2020 Order/Procedural Filed Order Granting Motion. The motion for an extension of time to file the opening brief and amend the briefing schedule is granted. Appellants shall have until December 7, 2020, to file and serve the opening brief and appendix. Respondents shall have until February 8, 2021, to file and serve an answering brief. Appellants shall have 30 days from the date of the last-filed answering brief to file and serve a reply brief, if deemed necessary. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 20-38554 12/07/2020 Appendix Filed Joint Appendix, Volume 1. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 20-44282 12/07/2020 Appendix Filed Joint Appendix, Volume 2. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 20-44286 12/07/2020 Appendix Filed Joint Appendix, Volume 3. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 20-44287 12/07/2020 Appendix Filed Joint Appendix, Volume 4. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 20-44288 12/07/2020 Appendix Filed Joint Appendix, Volume 5. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 20-44289 12/07/2020 Appendix Filed Joint Appendix, Volume 6. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 20-44292 12/07/2020 Appendix Filed Joint Appendix, Volume 7. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 20-44295 12/07/2020 Appendix Filed Joint Appendix, Volume 8. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 20-44300 12/07/2020 Appendix Filed Joint Appendix, Volume 9. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 20-44301 12/07/2020 Motion Filed Appellants' Motion for Excess Pages on Opening Brief. Nos. 81123/81424 (SC) 20-44345 12/07/2020 Brief Filed Appellants' Opening Brief. Nos. 81123/81424 (SC) 20-44350 12/07/2020 Notice/Incoming Filed Appellants' Proof of Service Certificate of Service. Nos. 81123/81424 (SC) 20-44356 12/10/2020 Order/Procedural Filed Order Granting Motion. Appellants' motion for leave to file an opening brief in excess of the page limitation is granted. The opening brief was filed on December 7, 2020. Nos. 81123/81424 (SC) 20-44920 12/11/2020 Notice/Incoming Filed Appellants' Notice of Entry of Order (Granting Appellants' Motion to File Brief in Excess of Page Limitation). Nos. 81123/81424 (SC) 20-45021 12/11/2020 Notice/Incoming Filed Appellants' Certificate of Service (Notice of Entry of Order). Nos. 81123/81424 (SC) 20-45022 02/04/2021 Motion Filed Respondents' Motion to Enlarge Page Limit on Answering Brief. Nos. 81123/81424 (SC) 21-03458 02/04/2021 Brief Filed Respondents' Joint Answering Brief. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 21-03459 02/05/2021 Motion Filed Respondents' Joint Motion to Supplement Appendix and Record on Appeal. Nos. 81123/81424 (SC) 21-03539 02/12/2021 Order/Procedural Filed Order Granting Motions and Directing Transmission of Exhibits. Respondents' motion for leave to file an answering brief in excess of 30 pages is granted. The joint answering brief was filed on February 4, 2021. The district court clerk shall have 14 days from the date of this order to transmit to the clerk of this court "Plaintiff's Exhibit 1" and "Defendant's Exhibit B," entered on July 24, 2019, during the hearing on partial summary judgment. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 21-04264 03/15/2021 Brief Filed Appellants' Reply Brief. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 21-07393 03/15/2021 Motion Filed Appellants' Motion to Enlarge Page Limit on Reply Brief. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 21-07394 03/15/2021 Notice/Outgoing Issued Notice to Provide Proof of Service. Due date: 10 days. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 21-07420 03/22/2021 Notice/Incoming Filed Appellants' Certificate of Service (Motion to Enlarge Page Limit on Appellants' Reply Brief). Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 21-08131 03/22/2021 Notice/Incoming Filed Appellants' Certificate of Service (Appellants' Reply Brief). Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 21-08133 04/02/2021 Order/Procedural Filed Order Granting Motion. Appellant's motion for leave to file a reply brief in excess of 15 pages is granted. The reply brief was filed on March 15, 2021. Nos. 81123/81424 (SC) 21-09541 04/02/2021 Case Status Update Briefing Completed/To Screening. (SC) 04/22/2021 Motion Filed Appellant's Motion to Amend Caption and Notice of Death of a Party. Nos. 81123/81424 (SC) 21-11631 05/06/2021 Order/Procedural Filed Order. Counsel represents that appellant Claudette D. Vogel has been named the sole surviving trustee for the Trust in this action and moves this court to amend the caption to name Claudette as sole trustee rather than naming a new party as a personal representative of Ronald. The motion is granted. The clerk of this court shall amend the caption of this appeal to conform to the caption on this order. Nos. 81123/81424 ( (SC) 21-13032 08/18/2021 Order/Procedural Filed Order Scheduling Oral Argument. This matter is scheduled for oral argument on October 13, 2021, at 2:00 p.m. in Carson City. The argument shall be limited to 30 minutes. Nos. 81123/81424 (SC) 21-24125 08/31/2021 Order/Procedural Filed Order Regarding Oral Argument. This matter is currently scheduled for oral argument on October 13, 2021, at 2:00 p.m. in Carson City. To accommodate this court's calendar, oral argument will begin at 11:00 a.m. on October 13, 2021, in Carson City. Argument will be limited to 30 minutes. Nos. 81123/81424. (SC) 21-25310 09/22/2021 Order/Procedural Filed Order Regarding Oral Argument. This matter is currently scheduled for oral argument on October 13, 2021, at 11:00 a.m. The current status of the Covid-19 pandemic requires counsel to appear remotely for this argument. The court will use the BlueJeans videoconferencing system, which requires laptop/desktop/videoconferencing computer internet access and audio and video (web camera) capability. In case technical difficulties develop at any time, the court will conduct the oral argument by teleconference, which will require counsel to have immediate access to a landline phone connection. Within 5 days of the date of this order, the parties shall submit to the Clerk of the Court a notice identifying the attorney(s) who will argue the case and the phone number and email address of the attorney(s). The notice may be emailed to the court at nvscclerk@nvcourts.nv.gov. (SC) 21-27339 09/22/2021 Notice/Outgoing Issued Oral Argument Reminder Notice. (SC) 21-27371 10/13/2021 Case Status Update Oral argument held this day. Case submitted for decision. (SC) 12/17/2021 Order/Dispositional Filed Order Reversing in Part, Vacating in Part, and Remanding. "We reverse the district court's dismissal of the underlying suit, vacate the award of attorney fees, and remand to the district court for proceedings consistent with this order." NNP21-EC/KP/DH (SC) 21-36092 Combined Case View