Corpuz (Ralph) v. State ( 2014 )


Menu:
  •                 Even assuming Corpuz did not consent to the blood draw, we have
    recently held that, while the warrantless, nonconsensual search provided
    for in NRS 484C.160(7) is unconstitutional, the good-faith exception to the
    exclusionary remedy applies when an officer reasonably and in good faith
    relied on the constitution validity of the statute.   See Byars v. State,.
    Nev. , P.3d (Adv. Op. No. 85, October 16, 2014). Therefore,, the
    district court did not err by denying Corpuz's motion to suppress.
    Next, Corpuz claims that the district court abused its
    discretion by denying his motion for a new trial based on prosecutorial
    misconduct. We review the denial of a motion for a new trial for an abuse
    of discretion.   See Steese u. State, 
    114 Nev. 479
    , 490, 
    960 P.2d 321
    , 328
    (1998). When considering allegations of prosecutorial misconduct, we first
    determine whether the prosecutor's conduct was improper and then
    whether any improper conduct warrants reversal. See Valdez u. State, 
    124 Nev. 1172
    , 1188, 
    196 P.3d 465
    , 476 (2008). Here, the prosecutor argued
    that Corpuz may have wanted to prove his car was faster than another,
    and Corpuz timely objected. After a brief bench conference, during which
    Corpuz claimed that the argument was not supported by evidence and was
    speculation, the district court sustained the objection, and the prosecutor
    immediately moved on. Even assuming that the argument constituted
    prosecutorial misconduct, we conclude that it was harmless error.            See
    Truesdell v. State, 129 Nev. , 
    304 P.3d 396
    , 402 (2013). Therefore,
    SUPREME COURT
    OF
    NEVADA
    2
    (0) 1947A
    the district court did not abuse its discretion by denying Corpuz's motion
    for a new trial.
    Having considered Corpuz's claims and concluded that no
    relief is warranted, we
    ORDER the judgment of conviction AFFIRMED.
    Hardesty
    ° D1774             j.
    Douglas
    cc:   Hon. Michelle Leavitt, District Judge
    Mueller Hinds & Associates
    Attorney General/Carson City
    Clark County District Attorney
    Eighth District Court Clerk
    SUPREME COURT
    OF
    NEVADA
    3
    (0) I947A
    

Document Info

Docket Number: 64936

Filed Date: 11/12/2014

Precedential Status: Non-Precedential

Modified Date: 4/17/2021