Carpenter v. . Blake , 1872 N.Y. LEXIS 523 ( 1872 )

Allen, J.,

reads opinion for reversal and new trial.

Eolger, Rapadlo and Andrews, JJ., concur upon the first ground discussed.

Peckham, J., reads opinion for affirmance. Church, Ch. J., and Grover, J., concur.

Judgment reversed.