Palumbo v. Atlas Portland Cement Co. ( 1910 )

PER CURIAM.

Upon a former trial a verdict in favor of the plaintiff was set aside, and the order entered upon such ruling was affirmed without opinion (Appellate Term, May 27, 1909). The practical effect of such determination was that the truck in suit was owned and managed by an independent contractor and not by the defendant. The evidence adduced upon the first trial was substantially the same, as that given upon the trial which is the subject of this review, and in the light of the determination so made upon the former appeal, in which determination we fully concur, the judgment cannot be allowed to stand.

The judgment and order denying the motion for a new trial are reversed, and a new trial ordered, with costs.to the appellant to abide the event.