State v. Preston ( 2014 )


Menu:
  • [Cite as State v. Preston, 
    2014-Ohio-3936
    .]
    IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF OHIO
    TENTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
    State of Ohio,                                  :
    Nos. 14AP-246
    Plaintiff-Appellee,            :          and 14AP-305
    (C.P.C. No. 13CR-5137)
    v.                                              :
    Cynthia D. Preston,                             :    (REGULAR CALENDAR)
    Defendant-Appellant.           :
    D E C I S I O N
    Rendered on September 11, 2014
    Ron O'Brien, Prosecuting Attorney, and Valerie Swanson, for
    appellee.
    Lisa M. Tome, for appellant.
    APPEALS from the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas.
    BROWN, J.
    {¶ 1} In these consolidated appeals, defendant-appellant, Cynthia D. Preston,
    appeals from judgments of the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas sentencing her to
    five years imprisonment following her guilty pleas to tampering with evidence and
    obstructing justice.
    {¶ 2} On September 26, 2013, appellant was indicted on one count of tampering
    with evidence, in violation of R.C. 2921.12, and one count of obstructing justice, in
    violation of R.C. 2921.32. Appellant initially entered pleas of not guilty. On November 6,
    2013, appellant changed her plea to guilty on both counts of the indictment.
    {¶ 3} On January 24, 2014, the trial court conducted a sentencing hearing.
    During the hearing, appellant's counsel notified the court that appellant wished to
    Nos. 14AP-246 and 14AP-305                                                              2
    withdraw her guilty pleas.     The court, however, denied appellant's oral motion to
    withdraw the pleas. By entry filed February 24, 2014, the trial court sentenced appellant
    to three years imprisonment as to Count 1 (tampering with evidence), two years
    imprisonment as to Count 2 (obstructing justice), with the sentences to be served
    consecutively. The trial court filed a corrected judgment entry on March 26, 2014.
    {¶ 4} Appellant filed notices of appeal from both the initial entry and the
    corrected entry of the trial court. Appellant subsequently filed a motion to consolidate the
    two cases, which this court granted.
    {¶ 5} On appeal, appellant sets forth the following five assignments of error for
    this court's review:
    ASSIGNMENT OF ERROR NO. 1:
    THE TRIAL COURT ERRED WHEN IT FAILED TO COMPLY
    WITH CRIM.R. 11 DURING APPELLANT'S PLEA HEARING,
    AS THE COURT DID NOT ENGAGE IN A COLLOQUY WITH
    APPELLANT REGARDING HER CONSTITUTIONAL
    RIGHTS.
    ASSIGNMENT OF ERROR NO. 2:
    APPELLANT WAS DENIED THE EFFECTIVE ASSISTANCE
    OF COUNSEL DUE TO COUNSEL'S FAILURE TO FILE A
    MOTION TO        WITHDRAW GUILTY PLEA ON
    APPELLANT'S    BEHALF,   THEREBY     DEPRIVING
    APPELLANT OF HER RIGHTS AS GUARANTEED BY THE
    SIXTH AND FOURTEENTH AMENDMENTS TO THE
    UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION AND COMPARABLE
    PROVISIONS OF THE OHIO CONSTITUTION.
    ASSIGNMENT OF ERROR NO. 3:
    THE TRIAL COURT ERRED IN FAILING TO HOLD A
    HEARING ON APPELLANT'S ORAL MOTION TO
    WITHDRAW HER GUILTY PLEA.
    ASSIGNMENT OF ERROR NO. 4:
    THE TRIAL COURT ERRED IN IMPOSING CONSECUTIVE
    SENTENCES WITHOUT MAKING THE FINDINGS
    MANDATED BY R.C. 2929.14(C)(4) AT THE SENTENCING
    HEARING.
    Nos. 14AP-246 and 14AP-305                                                               3
    ASSIGNMENT OF ERROR NO. 5:
    THE TRIAL COURT ERRED IN SENTENCING APPELLANT
    ON BOTH COUNTS TO WHICH SHE PLED GUILTY AS THE
    TWO OFFENSES WERE ALLIED OFFENSES OF SIMILAR
    IMPORT WHICH SHOULD HAVE MERGED AT
    SENTENCING.
    {¶ 6} Under the first assignment of error, appellant asserts the trial court erred in
    failing to comply with the requirements of Crim.R. 11 during the plea hearing.
    Specifically, appellant argues that the court's failure to inform her of the constitutional
    rights she was waiving, as mandated by Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(c), rendered the plea invalid.
    {¶ 7} Under Ohio law, "a trial court must strictly comply with Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(c)
    and orally advise a defendant before accepting a felony plea that the plea waives (1) the
    right to a jury trial, (2) the right to confront one's accusers, (3) the right to compulsory
    process to obtain witnesses, (4) the right to require the state to prove guilt beyond a
    reasonable doubt, and (5) the privilege against compulsory self-incrimination." State v.
    Veney, 
    120 Ohio St.3d 176
    , 
    2008-Ohio-5200
    , ¶ 31. When a trial court fails to strictly
    comply with this duty, "the defendant's plea is invalid." 
    Id.
    {¶ 8} The state concedes the trial court failed to advise appellant of the
    constitutional rights she was waiving by pleading guilty. The state therefore agrees that
    the plea must be set aside and the matter remanded to the trial court for further
    proceedings.
    {¶ 9} Based upon this court's review of the record, we agree with appellant that
    the trial court failed to comply with the requirements of Crim.R. 11(C)(2)(c), thereby
    rendering the plea invalid. 
    Id.
     We therefore sustain appellant's first assignment of error
    and vacate her pleas. In light of our disposition of the first assignment of error, the
    arguments raised by appellant under the remaining assignments of error are rendered
    moot.
    {¶ 10} Based upon the foregoing, appellant's first assignment of error is sustained,
    the second, third, fourth, and fifth assignments of error are rendered moot, the judgments
    of the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas are reversed, and these matters are
    Nos. 14AP-246 and 14AP-305                                                         4
    remanded to that court for further proceedings in accordance with law, consistent with
    this decision.
    Judgments reversed and causes remanded.
    SADLER, P.J., and LUPER SCHUSTER, J., concur.
    ______________________
    

Document Info

Docket Number: 14AP-246, 14AP-305

Judges: Brown

Filed Date: 9/11/2014

Precedential Status: Precedential

Modified Date: 10/30/2014