State v. McIntosh ( 2023 )

[Cite as State v. McIntosh, 2023-Ohio-4022.]
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS
TWELFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT OF OHIO
BUTLER COUNTY
STATE OF OHIO,
Appellee, CASE NO. CA2022-04-040
OPINION
vg - 11/6/2023
JAMES E. McINTOSH,
Appellant.
CRIMINAL APPEAL FROM BUTLER COUNTY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Case No. CR2020-09-1281
Michael T. Gmoser, Butler County Prosecuting Attorney, and Michael Greer, Assistant
Prosecuting Attorney, for appellee.
Repper-Pagan Law, Ltd., and Christopher J. Pagan, for appellant.
BYRNE, J.
© -DPHOF,QWIRG@ RL WW HL R O DAVFLAPPOP\K GFIRVO\WSU/BIOH V XO W
W KOH X W&OFHXUQSR X B&R PP RSOHDYYRRABGP X CHAN VWDLORGI QWHQFH
OF, OWABRQGHISOL WAOUGF ,QWRYKHWG@OMFLVURDIILWRVWULDO
FR X WW AL VLRQ
Butler CA2022-04-040
Il. Factual and Procedural Background
{[2} , 2@FWREHUD% X WEORHUUW D A GUQAGLEW,AWRAYQAR X QW
RIHORQDR X VKX@ WR O RVWL BQ $ D VHF R@K6J UIHHHD RQKH
LQGLFWWH@WH BBPOOH J DWKDACOW BY BU RDWKHG WOPKYLFWLP \
GULY HZW UW RysL F WOQVAKH DGQGQRF NHR AW WW RX AX V WOAKL_ FF WLP
W@ARFRQVFLRXVR, AWA K RQ W LVOR\\GDVK KYA FF EUW7LKAY LF WK PIH UHG
VHU LIRXWXULHV
{[3} ,ARYHPEHUOF, QWRQW WSHORDAKLOWHD\RAQVDQLW
1*5, 0F,QWWRIAK OW DAR RKRDDH YDOXW@HRWG URBPOARWWOWXV
D W KWL FRHW KIHO O HRJIH BQ WK H R XB WG HW KK GP OQ W BNW D O XTRWHG
FRPSH WW®W DVOI@ OY D O XDLWAHKY SWIR VO RD * 5,
{[44 )ROOR DIGHY DO X LEWD F8Q\F KR O RWK_AVRK URK OOF , OW RV K
F RPS H WHROWDV@ IG LEDXCE V H T X AVOK\WVE+S D LPT KK BIO G WBO X D WRAWNWG
UHS RASYV QR @K HW KH,QWRAYW KIRK DOL! L FRD'SLOR RD * 5, 7KHLUVW
RS L QWIGDRW Q WaR/VFKH HWKALU LWADSDOERD*5, 7KA HF RRL OMIGD W
OF, Q Waok/Viet PH HWEKFU L W AW BACK LSULCL Y DU WOE ‘0 FEGQ W RK QMKGD W
OF, Q Wor \PHH HWA L WH ULD
5} , @FWREH UW PD W SUR OH WR GO WHR OOD LV VEG
R QW KIHH O R QD RB & BKIODNU JK HY L F WLEPV WD VGH @ KW K UR-HQ WRO OW K
HYDOX DW RB KVWWE V HT XA 0d G L VGW FQVILG@ GW @@AYVQ WRIYGR W
PH WLAYX U GHQU RR\DS UHS RQGR WORE HG WOEFHIP R Q VW HDA BI V
LQ V DQWHKML RINV KH 1H Q WIR R XW RVHROX © G , Q WRX WHO R OO RKDVX OV
DVFKDUJHG
{76} ,QIRYHPEHU WKAR X UMNO W H O26, GV PV/ARIR P P X QAR WU RC
FRQVLRWOGH DRIW ke 0, 6X EV WPEYF\EH Q WOOO WUUIR J UDG
-2-
Butler CA2022-04-040
|R XG GL WHR GED VUKSHUY 7 KIWRRXDOW LY A,@WWAKBWL RO RWLR
FRPPX GIRVWO\W B ROGWSS UL WATE ROVLRWOQG HIS QL WHO WROFH
W Z\RIRL JK LS\O R'‘QIKD BW KPH QL PXIPL WRQWHQFH
7} S$VSDURVWKLVHQWH @FLQWAV KQBGRE XP WOW OGGH UDO
& RQGLWERQWU Y LAKLASCKI AY UWHEER Q G _L \ UK ORARW/LPVR P P X GIRWW U RC
OF, QWBROWEBJ QIGE F X PW @ MR W DV KAR@®@ GL AIK BAD WL FL O@KWLR
6$0,&8RXMUIR JU BQ ER WEAR O GL WOW ROBBNO .& R X VR JU UDPPF X PQ RWHG
W K®RAYQ WIRROX®KG HF RP PH WH G LG WOW D IWR GWA XUQHU
{§8} $ IHZP RQ WODWLHOUD UF K W K®# X WORNQMAX OWREDWLR
"HS DU WIFLIDRS& S FOLONGR W BPH R O DAMKILABG@D O AW IKIEWQ WIRDKLRODWH
W Z|BX OFHIW K*HH QHGRQGLWARIEBKGWYUYLVKRWASREWWDWARGORZLOQ
DOOHJDWLRQV
Rule 7: On 03/08/2022 the offender admitted to getting
prescriptions for Lyrica and Ambien and then misusing those
prescriptions. An admission form was signed.
Rule 14: The offender was unsuccessfully discharged from
Sojourner programming on 03/08/2022.
The court, through its magistrate, held a probable cause hearing at which Mcintosh was
present. A probation officer repeated the allegations. Based on the testimony, the court
found probable cause that Mclntosh had violated the conditions of his supervision.
Accordingly, the court scheduled Mcintosh for a revocation hearing.
{79} $ VW KWH Y RF RWDB @OGR XU AV LWKD® O HUDEIGHR OO DWAR QV
DVNKRB2ZF, QWALWKW &U R F HOHGQ W FARK QIVQI@L FVD RAVE WARAYKO G
DG PWBRWKYHROD WK @ XW WB GN BIB, Q WIRW KDW. K DAWZ D Q WIERG
GROF,QWRY&ZOKHWLDQER QIL WPAKGN D &@ D OWRIGY W W POLE
GHF L WURGCPW W KER PP X GIRVO\WAX RY BRODWLRQV
-3-
Butler CA2022-04-040
{410} 7 K IF R XDA H SOV HGBW FD\VGKP WV VIL@IGHVD D GJ X PH ROWVQLHQF’
L@YHQWH QRS JQ W PARK @ DAZ O WV WD W HBH_QW J DORR COW RV K
$1WHU Z WIRBR/XUAW RA REP X GLAVO\VDIOAGC S R HOG QGHI8 QL WRU P
FRQVLRWDRIGQL PW DSVHLANAHE FPF L\[H D D'QGPD[LP MWPHE RL QHDUV
il} OF, QWBD KWHALOWY LJ OQ FHHOWU AR KD VS H BOZLOGQGUHVV
W K HAV L J Q FRHAQUWRAKRVWW KAU GLHZLK L PAKK A iW USSU HV HE\WFA,@ W RV K
ll. Law and Analysis
A. State v. Qualls and Plain Error
{12} 0F,QW RAHM RV LJ QRHQWAUWDWHV
{13} 7+( 75,$/&2857 &200,77(' 3/$,1 (5525 $7 7+(
5(92&$7,24($5,1*
{F144 OF, Q WRWAXWARAD WAAUF_AD OLED VEHH | RXNAR P PL WS BG RU
E\ 1D L QVWBGSJSW kPHD OQ G D W H@walls U X IR HF WGK YRFD@GRQWHQFH
OF, QW\RU/EI H U H Oitate v. Qualls 2KLRSS GWK ’LVW OF,QWRVK
FR QW WA VAR XHUWWUEA RD L ONIRRAQ V IZ HH WIKGIWD 2D WR L WL J DOF MORJU
EH | RUHHY RM LRIRIP P X GIRWO\W OGD Q W HMIFROG JQ WRAV/GF HVG IDBVD DL Q
HU WRAUD QBD HY GILNWZRMD SS OWA GW X PHHIQMD KW UFLAD OQ NOH_GOMRG
U D lQWdts R DQual/ls W \ DH J X PEI IVAW IRHUFLADIOU W
{415} &ULP 5 %SURY LVGHDVO DHQU RUG/HIHDBWMYHFWKEYWDQW
ULJ RW \E HQ R W LOFOWGSK #XK.K UGIRBAU R X WRAWKCHW W H ROI KARRQX UAK D W
U X OSD D WHK\LOHHP L WB ®URI GV HZR OQ AVL WLR LOH W/LORFAWWD L VHG
E H | RW IRYHUF_FRDOLS te v. Fuel §=6WHKVWOHURRGAW 2KLR
FLWita@Wv. %DUQHYKLRW G )L UM QU U RUN
GHYLDIW BBQ H JIDXOORK VAD YRIF FX U Ube DIN TX RW58e@es DW
6HF R @GHU LFRRW S O DA_RUOM\G%S O DLL @L WX VA D QE YL BOAVHRMK H
-A-
Butler CA2022-04-040
SURFHHG IdQ BW D \RM/& H UW IKNHH UPRXLV/ AHI X Q G D P HSQDDDS@CEGDGH
RE Y L RROQW KUHH F AVLXG WK DIWK R XKODGY EHH HIS S D UMAR FHR X ZIM KER W
RE MHFStiteRGBarnette WKLV WX WIRKLS 2KLR
7 K L WOKHHU LPRXU/KAD YR HF WKE VWODIQMK MDE DW =TXRWE@u
Martin 2KLAW G 2KLR 7 K LPVH D QN/KHHU UPRXUV AAD Y H
DITHFWKAX WFRMHGURFHH Gare DW S$OQDSSHORXEALWOGAWLFH
RS O THLOZR WW P RD WWX.@ GHILF HS WEIRD VW OB AMNRUH YR QW
PD QL IRILWWE D UB IMXAW Stitélv. % DO G HYVKL V 6 X WICRHELS
2KLR
f§ 16} , QQuals WKH QWW WEBRSS H DG H WWIG X P WW =
LQVDOQWMHL RAD @ FWKDAW XGWHH YR EF RWDR@OARPSOGHWHOQVH
WSDUBG@MRFDWDAWQ % XW Q WK WWW KL 1 V DLO. RW
FRPSOGHH @ OS URE DIHLYAS BW QQOY QD WO VW BRIGWLJDWL
IDF WRU R XW FR@ V ZKH OM KW VKWLPUDAVE.GDW 7KAVULDO
FR XIUGVX BID VGILG RWW |W@ualls L @ W\Q D ODIGA.G/LGRUIH IWBQ V DOW \
PLWLJDOVWFMCRIU
17} >H | L CQGRH U UAHUWX F BH \6\0 CHOU RLU Qualls ZD GHFLEHG
W KH] Q WK W&JR KRVBIS S H D/GRMQ RAVR Q W USRLOHCFLHIGON GGANV WELHLFFRIQ G
OF, QWRIWGY D VI) RR XBR XZ IZHID G R SQwall& U X O/HK DQW D OWLDV \
PLWLJDDVF MRUIUBK R XUN FB@ V ZE& HWW VIXW L PUD LEGER QWH[W
RDUHYRFBWDEQGs DW 7KLW HOW Qdhals UX ®@BGEH HOG RSMHG
W KFLAYX UEXR X Q QDS SIO KFLD VEH F D XY ¥ HQ W@ MKRAO DR BY WX JJ HV Ww
D WKH Y RF BMD BVQRWHWD VO V ZA HIQH RP PLR PX GRIOWKBE
YLROD WR BW X HDLGH Y LG HL@IFHUHH F RY Gu H VWKOORY Q W2D/KQ V DDONH
W KWL FRHW K RW AIG HR OD WERQW RDV/KS OFCRDX\Q HF H O HVG8\H F X ONDKADAW
-5-
Butler CA2022-04-040
OF,QWRD\K D YEH HOE OWA UJ KXRUOQVDQO@WWLJEBMWWUIRGDUCHAWDO
KH DOWKXH V
{7 18} Qualls VW DW KRW UF B OWW R ¥ GG V LIGAND CLK KL V KY
WLPUDL VARI HY RF RAWDBRSY ,QWRN KWL WHGR V VL A IK@ ADV
LQ V DOKL RHK LPVR P P X @LRVQ\W UR OD MILLVWDW 6H Dd UR @ WQRWKHU
W L Raa//is L'W K H U H URJUHHOLHQY KAO H
{| 19} ) R WK HOVHHD V RVGER XQ@AGGRAR P P&S OOHLLUGLERIUD L OALIRRO OVACH
Qualls U X GW LVRWJH YR NRCP X GLRVQ\W OO RF H MGRPGR WHIQ W H:@F
RYHUQK,Q@AV RAH RODVGV LJ QRHQWRU
B. Ineffective Assistance of Counsel
{§20} OF, QWAWV OW) LJ QRHOQWAMWWHV
{F213 75,$/&2816(/:$6 ,1())(&7,9@7 74+( 5(928&$7,21
+($5,1*
{§22} OF, QWBVKXWK BUF RXQO BNE Y LICH !H BWV Y MWODNM KH
UHYRF BWD BLOW K WHA KLZKZLODGG UW KUQ
{§ 23} 7 K WV HIARWQ HII HB WWLY\AVR EF IQ V H OX DIGHVYH Q WRROW Y H
W KPDRK Q VSHKDU VR U PADQGHILFLPQW> WKW KHHILFEHQMRUPDQE
S UHM X @/LKEHHIGH QStri¢kland v. Washington 8 6 6 &W
,QUHYLHZEQDRRQHIIHBWVYWVROFRAEHO VWH8[DPLOQKHWKHU
FRX Q VBIRVAWR PLV VL BAQUAKX W WW G4 GUD QRISURIHVVER@BGWHQ
DV VL V W2IGLFOUHH F R J Q LW KIBQAK@® VY WOV U RQU 6 V X MHA YUH QGHUH
DGHT XD WM V WotkGBAHGS B OV J QLI GAB Q WL CK OH UU FR WH DV RQDE
SURIH V WOR@IPHQ WW 7RHV WD BACK RIQGH PR OWHM XWKAH
GHIHQ@ BW GH PRQVWHWWHWHUHDVRQ@DB GB BWIKGIWWRER XQVHO
XQSURI/H \H\ULLARULRGH VK IY WEHU R OF OH ZG YEH HG 11H Ud © W
-6-
Butler CA2022-04-040
{4 244 5HJDU GVIGW H VM OR@LH- FE BAD Y\WV DW oY H&K L BK
DS SH @Q@D0GHWAHW | HIB. W\LIY\H D0) Rid) DAU XL 9 G/N DARK R&U HM XVGIK AH
GHIHQ@BOWH PRQVWNH BWW HD V R GOREN BWLKOELWWR KI LIWVWR XQVHO
HU U KUYWR X QGWD YSO HK &LOMER X B&B YUQVLAWRG WW U L Baie v.
Hawks WKLVWUUHRVE §$ DQ G&S 2KLR
T X R Vbiafa w. Byrd WtHVOWDGLVRG$ 2KLR
$ F F R&te@ v. Longworth W LV WX WIGS 2KLR
1. Rule 7 Violation
{4 25} 5 XO HR IW K*HH QH GRQGLWIBKGY U Y D'SISROQ. MORKFOGWRVK
FRPP X GIRVQ\WUKR ®K , Q WIRWUKHWIRR O GEFUR Y WGDON
| will not possess, use, purchase, or have under my control any
narcotic drug or other controlled substance or illegal drugs,
including any instrument, device or other object used to
administer drugs or to prepare them for administration, unless
it is lawfully prescribed for me by a licensed physician. |
agree to inform my supervising officer promptly of any such
prescription and | agree to submit to drug testing if required by
the Butler County Court of Common Pleas. 1! will also be
subjected to mandatory DNA testing which will be conducted at
the departments [sic] order.
(Bold emphasis added.) The Butler County probation department asserted that McIntosh
violated Rule 7 by "misusing" his prescriptions for Lyrica and Ambien.
{4 26} OF, Q WIRWKXVA RAOUL UFLADIOO Y IY IGGHH GFL @ BLHQJH RR UP DQF
E\SHUPLWMAW AG PWIH5X OHYLROGZWH BQD FFG LGRWL R OKWH
6SHFLILAMQUBRV KXW WHA LGRWL RR @OKWEEHFD KX'HS RVVHYDOGG
SUHVFUL SWER@WLADQGPELH@F ,QWRRNHEFH WKWKSEUREDWLE
GHSD U WRHOGW KIRA D PL V XK VW @ RSVUHH V F OU LESAWUR) Ga WY KEHH S R UW
DQGR W FEFRHQ W DQ. RSHH@VDW/Giw KHZDWPLV X VAIQWUHVFUL 9S W,LOVOR/V K
FR QW WAX@WHS/EH V FU ERY RBH WO He WUD RRR WE OOW K
Butler CA2022-04-040
LVV XAWLZRXOGNWKAWBHUPL VWQ Gt) H+ HDOFRQW WA@OWH Q
LK HD E X VIIGYU H V FU LAS IKE @ VB Q ROW L RORWKBEEHF D XAWEKXOH
G LGRW6 HF L| LAID ECR. Xx \RHB UH VF PBHEGHG DWLRQ
{4 27} >H 1 L UQVRAW KDA ORM Q WRAY KR Q W WON LGRWL RR GX WH
LWH P DW@PYD WHKBDRW IK, Q W FO\RKX QD G@G@F , Q WIRLVAebriified WW KE O H
YLRO D WLKREU LO KHDULWGJQWRQ KLAR X QG HVGAD | WHWK DG
KH DD SGU RE DR LLAKH @ H UGHOVOR WWLKEHIOD O FYJLHRGO DOW GHW G URIE DEO!
FD X KH D U LSQYD U H V XVCKWELDRQ FQ HH G@ W KVAW DAWBHU R YILXGURAHYELLG «HQ FF
UHJD UW KCEHW B WOK O FL R O DDVQIGRR@H W B WOWHKU © DAD D O O HGH G
W KSYU R E DGAHLS°OQU W PG WOUMER W BPH R O DOVWIARIOKLHH F RIES SHDO
{4 28} 8S RQH Y LAHZL QAGKOPRY OQ WIRDVRL WCFROW KC IG KU F RVUKG@ANMK O G
VXS SW KEMR Q W HV RVR OJFLADOQ VU+40S V H V H2QDWBR WW RVCKZHHGLUD QR H
SURIHVVER@ SHOW FH QW W Firlodfalid 8 6DW (YHOQZHDVVXWKDW
OF, Q WIRWAKU LLEDRWW H UNAKIOOWU LB OP ELSQH VF UZ SI\PEROQWW OU HOD WwW
K LRYH Q WB O O WKXW KG RK HOVRAK D QW IK] B AWK BW G P-L WAR X VK OY
SUHV FU LOISWWRQaW&HU RE DGVELRIQU W PSIHOSWDUANG RW IRASL RODWLR
OF,QWB@RLWRHRO BWOAIKL OK OHG LGRWW R KE, IQWIRJRERV LQ J
FRQW URCEQ/MOVOKEAWUGID Z| SOGVF ULB RBE\VLFIFWR@X OWDWKRW
OF,QWADWH RYH UPLWAK ME >DRQW UWREOMW@QKROHWWDZIXOO
SUHVFURBHEREADOLFHGXKNG F LBIVO OS UH VF FRRWQUREY WO@ FH
P D Q QAHW MHD & DW Z IKK F ULUZEHHFGH V \CORUMLIOR W K@®WHWODZIXOO
1. In support of his contention that his Lyrica and Ambien prescriptions were meant to address his mental
health issues, McIntosh cites an exchange that occurred at trial between the prosecutor and one of the doctors
who evaluated Mcintosh. Our review of this testimony does not clearly indicate to us that the doctor testified
that these medications were for mental health treatment. That is, there is some ambiguity in the testimony.
Regardless, for purposes of our analysis we assume that the Lyrica and Ambien prescriptions were prescribed
to address Mcintosh's mental health issues.
-8-
Butler CA2022-04-040
SUHVFUD ®@&@D FWE X RIW KDW VV FUL BWR QP DD \K D YEH HHDHDUHL
LLMWDE[S O LG ILVWOBR & \WRHDS UHV F 6 REMOVKEO We BRKLEQWWKEH
W H UPR IF R P P X GAR WW RX OW Hod L GH TT HS WR KDE KWRHDSUHVFULEF
FR QW WR WGSG F IR U G WOXJHOULEE D VIL QV KUHH F RGF, QW RARKX GW HO
GHF L WLERRAVR Q WHAYAY ROO IRV K@@D Q GQ V WHDSAD UJ XPH@QWYRU
OHQLBWARQWHQFLQJ
{7 29} ORUHRYVA,W WRAY GIL URRW GUA F RU Wf D Q WAHEGG PWW KH
YLRODW GROAN D @ KS SR U WRG BW NW KDW W POLEGRIEAWPsOL SW LGR J
Q RN RVZKFRR Q WRH/QKAD WWW ~APLOGL RRQ HOU \EDX WW KORE R HOVRUH T XXL ER
presume W KPDPRK QYWRDY ERMY WL WCXKAV L ROQGDOMERLPVO L ARAWKERR QW UD U
ZHS UH V XPHIDRAK QWHOG HOUGIET PIYWHV WORE EABOYOJQLIGABQWRQ
LWKHYHUFRNHDVRGDROMV WORGUPGimdWland DW *LYHOKWWHUH
ZDWEDVLAYW K5K OHY LR O DAML RGGRH YL G HWEK AWX GG DO OW @ DAV
SUHVXPSWLRQ
{7 30} )LQDOWRAW KARX UW VGH ORFSU DAWERKSGHWIGHIHQGDQW
FR PS ODNG\VA-_ V WLRRIQR P P X GA RAW RO DWOLRUH OL PLLHOIDWWQS LF DO ¢
VDOWLBOGWBURFRWBVIHF OV V EV RERKQWROF H &f&lew. Jimenez
W KL V WX \ D K RIJAD 2KLR F L WaldfeJv. Frazier WKLVW
& X\D K RIAD 2KLR DQRKW KIDW Md&tord State v. & OD LGN
"LVWQLAG 2KLR State v. Dye WKLV WW KHIRV
& § 2KLR $VLQ@menez 0F,QWRYVBSUHOL MHODUMYG J
ZK L RIKU HF -H IRWHO@ WR. IAVHIDHD O HLA PG X GIRVa\W U ROD WH\RXKEW HT XHQV
PDGBFRPS OBIGRAL V WLARV@HL RO DDWARKGY Y RF KWDRQOQA,QWRVK
FR PS QOHOVPH. V V DAV. WW OARFRGQ F HPUROIVH FV AV REE KI Viligtez DW
Butler CA2022-04-040
{§31} SFFRUG Z@UGIG H UWRF ,QW RAGH MH WLW DAKAHQW
UH J D UIGUDGEJP L V WIBB WOW LRODWLRQ
2. Rule 14 Violation
{323 5XOHRWKHQHABQGLWERQNUY ZKLME,QWRVKHWE
|R O GSRUR Y WGKHDGH R X O G
[FJollow all rules and regulations regarding of [sic] treatment
facilities or programs of any type in which | am placed or ordered
to attend while under the jurisdiction of the Butler County Court
of Common Pleas.
The probation department asserted that McIntosh violated Rule 14 by being "unsuccessfully
discharged from Sojourner programming * * *."
{33} OF, QWRWKXWARAOLW UFLADOOY DY IGGHH GALW @ \FBUWUQH R UPDQF
E\SHUPLWIWRG PWWIKKOHYLROGZWH@ A D\KHGLGRWRGKWH
+HD UJ XWRW WSK W DYALLRYOD GVH_‘RIGO W RARE KAFR X UMW YW HZCKEL KIA
D UJ X4DW/ FR P S QNHGIP P X CRLRAU\U H & WO WEG J UDARVR MRXUQHU
{§ 34} ,WVXSSRMWWOVIJ XP 168 WRI DO VE RIRIGMWD UK QOG
1RYHPEHU DWKLPEK,QWRG@RLWBAGP P X GIROA\WURODW OK@
FRXBWGHUR@wWAWRIQWBW& SUH V X PWIESERIP P X O& RW U H RAW ORV U
SURJUD@ED OR W HOLEERK WG HW IL RVR M R X SOX ILPYVY H PE HU
WUD Q FRIUOQUSWD&H @ UK Q G06 L QV KAD VEFH I RONH% X WBCREKWBAD\V HR
&5 E X WQ V WIHOD @ntirely different case % X WEORFHXLOMD VHR
&5 6SHFLILOFQQOURYRLWWHERYHPEHU KHDUW®DW
KLM OR QD RK DROW L FE QVKED V He X VBRKIWWAD\V HR & 5
Y LR O DW \WAHGUPPIW KAR P P X GLRVQ\\WWUKADOVG -U H Y L BK HIOR S R VRHKL PR U
K LAY 1 H @ \QHK\DAAF RFCDOV Pb X VW&GR PK BVI \V IHR & 5 *LY AKW WH
WUDQ¥E WISH O @HOW WU O\U D WE ©O DV KIDYWRAVH | RUA ® SSHDO
-10-
Butler CA2022-04-040
LWQ RAH U WKB OKW VD OQ ERE DSW BA XDS SH WF VRE H WKHFIR XOG
SURSABOVL@HU
35} 5HJDUGDYAWNX PW OU D Q V BUIRSWS D BW IHS S H (GIF LENG
G R HORWK S SPY, W ADU X/ PW GDA D \Q RAW G HW AREGP S OMKBHRIM R XUQH
SURJ WIKR ® @ GW UNHX U L V GRIME KVELXAVGORHXLORMIA\X BIR PP R3GD H DQV KH
F D VEH | UVR @® SSH DOA UD Q PWLHSONW D E OVLKVIKG GH Q W IGLH OAUHQ
FD VHF, QW2D/K U G HWSIBU W LEQ& 8 H
36} 0 RUHR WIKULUYY L G HGF IMHS S H CUCHIF ANAK S SW J X PHOW
W K@AYV Q WRAY XQ IGYEH HRQU G HW REP S OVMABHR MR XA B WL V
FRPP X GIRVQ\W ORD VEX | RUS VG _L V F X D ERR GHKRR XQIOND PIF GQ W RV K
LQ W PS 0,& RXVWRJUBBQHIDSWHOQWH QFLQ@WRVIOH® JUHHPHQ\
F RQ W DW @FERGQUG L VK SOD W L FIL@/ BES D RG XVUWR JU DROW UHH PHQW
WLWOSKG 6XEVWBARWGH QWDOQB 25735 2*5$0 3$57,&, 3$7,21
$*5((0(17$1' :$,9(52) 5,*+76t VWDWIKDAVQ WRAYXDIG HF RPPHQGH
IRWHVLGW OWD DOGWIL BK U KOXD UWL FILL@DOHORO RJUDWOVR
V W D WKIOBWR MR XSLHGFHRUY GI Y LIRKUW QZ D \RQR IW KU VLG WOW DIV H
SURJ UD\PHEG6 $0 WRKLOR,QWRAXOWHIHUUHG
§37} :-H GRQORMO RWKSUH FED MLAZK\OF, QWRYKXQVXFFHVVIX
GLVFK D LWRERR M R X UQ@ LUE H FD OF HQ W@ WG RAR Q WHA R OO DIG GR OQ
WK®RWHFEZOGHYH ORGWHQ@WE M HR XH YI KHOR W KOK F RU®@HG
E\OF,QWWKPMIS S AWAY O F OO WWWROUW H_LREHL@' S H CEQUDUHH®) HG LGR W
YLRGXKWH 7RW KER QO WW BHM L G H_GIFHUHH F YX GJ HW WOR Q WERWUKH H G
W RR O OWR@X CRW U H D WIP FHLOORLIBVUL RI VU ID@ KL FKIKZ D \6 O D FDHOGW KEAV
ZDWXEMWEML @O D FLI@R MR XDD IWRW KA$ 0,8 RXBWRIU BH EDXVH
W K HLWQHR W KK OKLA F RVORAG S S\N KD J X PIN RAV Q WIRD/BU HD WARRQWH VV
-11-
Butler CA2022-04-040
W KEK O HY L R O DAK LHRH X S SIARWWVKDHU J X PN RADI UFLADOQA/BG@HILFLHQ
IRQ RVR QW HW WHL@ODWLRQ
{38} ORUHRD WU WKEX O HY LR O DW LQWEBWN KH IRYUOG8 WR AK H
5XOHYLRODWERRS O DIG F OWW KYEL R O DW DIF @ L270. WIHGN IIHF WLY
DVVLV REQ KAN ROF Hdinfrez 2KLR DW
3. Failure to Cite Qualls or Investigate a Mental Illness Defense
{§39} 1H[WF,QWBY KXKLWR X OY BOQ HII HE WALDOM\HYD L OVRG WH
R GL UW FRE X WW) W HO KR @ Wh Wi KS S H ROM OLLRAs DQG
LWOVD QJ XGU UH AWLEBI® UAWRVR © V LOGQRUWIH Q GLHQV BQ MWRW L FRHD
FRPP X @LRAOQ\WK OER OMKLIERMIGLVFE X DERQ@KHXLOBQOQKDVJXPHQW
OF, QWRWJOVA RAD WALADOO2/TH100 H || HIFRVUCLLYQALIRIDUY H V \8 B WDHABHYVI IHDROY H V
WW KK OHYQG LQIU D FAYDIVARGPP HQWOOGHVNQVH
{440} OF, QW\RD WI X P HOQLWERWV Z BHD VR QW \WWZH V WD WORK U
GLVF X \AVOLFR Q WIR V (OW LJ QRH OQ Uiadds LQ RAR Q W USUOHOFLHOGIW & WW
7ZHO'IW EA DQ BWI D V RIOD @ BB HOG RS A\WE&ILAYX I$ WW X FAKHF DQQRW
VHB QED VILRVER QF O XAGKOROE OQ WHHOU | R U PLOODARAL WR GL UH PAWKLEHO J
W UFLADOUDW W H\G@RvaliR 2D GHILFLHQW
{F 41} 6 HF R QGK HIVE R W KILQ@WK IH F RW KW KG S H ORFDXVON/ H O
VXJJHV WKBRW Q W\RAAP P X GLAVO\W U R OO DAMLUR PW PL WWE ZK HQ
KHDWOHJDQUD Q@KX W RR AKW WEB OO BIG HI L FILACCRWQYHVWLJD'
SRW H@MIIHOROE/THWR @ HQWOOGRX ORT XLWARS H F XOOMMW X POF WV
Q RLV@V KLHH F R&the v. Miller WHVWURZR&S 2KLR
6SHF X ODAVRWR QL ALIROQWD EQ HVIKWB WLR BB @ KQVHO
{7 42} % HF D XZ RO RW OW K OW QW RY KV WDE @LOAKGGW DRIF H V
GHILF&HOMR U PUAQUFDY GILWUE BOQ VINFOW VIR KUHH YRF BWDRB aI
-12-
Butler CA2022-04-040
Q H HGSRAAR Q V WGKHRV V RIB UHM X Gee Bie v. Kaufhold W KL V ®% X W1CRH U
& $F 2KLR
{7 43} :-H RYHUQK,QAV AV EW LJ QRHQWRU
C. Sentencing Issues
{§44} 0F, QWAWKDW@LJQRHQWRUWWHV
{945} 0&,17264+6617(1&¢$6 &2175$582/§:
{7 46} OF, QWRD IK MWK LAW X P PUGHW 9 UIGLIQQ W H:G@IF4L 8 f(D) PLQH
W K HWW X P HQWKW Q
1. Consideration of R.C. 2929.13(B) Factors
{¥ 47} 0F, QW RAY WJ XW KOWWWUEB®YHWUB IG RQOVLGWHHQ
%| DF WLROUA/Y RR R@ PX GIRW\WOBDS R WHOGWHQFH
a. Applicable Law and Standard of Review
{448} 7KHWHBQXPERW WD WAAL V F XD VW FRRUW UE B® UMWRV
FRQVIZGH@QH QW HO@UCHQGKUN MM AKW D VWOUHHH OW HW BOO DOLQLV
W KFLDVV HL U 9 VA V W DWDM Q W HAE X QAVOHVO WC HOOR HY QIRWU
DIH O WR @ LEGIX L GEN KRHY H U USOGU QAR VANQWHQF DQGLWKRVH
SX US ROVQI@ F WRBKF RQVLGHBHG $ % 6BHFRGG& OLVWV
IDFWAWUDWHQWHGRKONMK D BHO V LLG VV HV WHGAMH UL RX ROW WY
R11H Q GRU GR GW KAI H Q GRU YA CRWIHFO GLY L&Vv P $ % &
DQG 7KLUG& %S UR Y WGEKHDWAH Q WH RK WW D\OHQ W PQFH
RI|THQWARIP P X GIRVO\W 6 RR‘ KH HH QIGRIJH HRROYLRFAE GHD EVO \
D IHOR@ KR X LRWIKI KJ UID RD 1H GRVYFL RO RRGMAGDDV X DOLI\LQ
DV V DRIOMNO Vib BU RY WGKAOGALF ERI G_L O/IL\AYQYIKGHW D WY RMDAW L Vol L8H G
% DLIDQG@L% XW& YD O%8 BR Y MCKHDWH QW HRA XK OW
K DG/L V F U\WIRPLSARADYSU L WAH 8 FOG 11H QZKHELF RQ Y LIF WGIGH D KEIO W\
-13-
Butler CA2022-04-040
W BIH O PROX KR X URVWIKI G/HKJ UAKID@VRADARR 11H GRVYH_ R O R WADAT XDOLI\LQ
DV V DXIORAQLI\LAO R IW KIIROO RS QO0\ > @QW KOO WHUHQDULBV
% RV KL X
(4 5 & * GH IL Q\VWAW D Q @ DULY LIIRQH O RCHQWHOQEF Lt
DSSHDB@t¥v. Day WKHVWUUHRESS$ DQ&$
2KLR 7 K WH P D WO) XKIAH KAHUFLRDXQURAVEORALVP S RW HHO RVGIQWHQEI
XQWEA@PPX GLVQAWUBAYG F KWD BOOB P SEVMWGAHI IH Q\GYHLIR O RVR
W H LFPPVR P P X GFLRVO Wb Saaife v. Covington W LV WX WIRES
2KLR $VDSSOLKBBS#B * SURYLGHV
The appellate court may take any action authorized by this
division if it clearly and convincingly finds either of the following:
(a) That the record does not support the sentencing court's
findings under division (B) or (D) of section 2929.13, division
(B)(2)(e) or (C)(4) of section 2929.14, or division (I) of section
2929.20 of the Revised Code, whichever, if any, is relevant;
(ob) That the sentence is otherwise contrary to law.
{7 50} , Btate v. Jones 2KLRW G 2KLR W KAK LRX SUHPH
& R XPWD UD (D8 GH ARXWAF RVRHU H Y LXHOYG 5 l& . DQG
) LU WAN X S U FFFRKO RVWW GD VV * (a) SHUPD @W\5 S H ORRXW
PRGLAY DF DOWH Q W Ht QBS S H OQIXWGH DIOGIR Q YL Q FIL@WGW WH
UH F RoURGHOYRWK S S WIKIA QWH OR KOWOGKQGAWU WBIHG LV MAHON X WF
SURY LOL RIQQAIGN D WKAMDEW & >RO@’G & > % @ R LBGAI@ @
RU & >,@ DW +RZH YW kK S U HRKQORAWWHIG WW DQG
DU®RIWP R QW KWW D W & WW VOLLAVOS GG . DQG
WKH U K PROD . Q R HYRYH U BDIGWS S H OGXW WAR G LAU
YDF DWHQWHOQFR@ODRNXS SIRW WH F RRMEKHUF_ADOU MQ &@ K@UVH U
5 & DQG ld. DW
-14-
Butler CA2022-04-040
{[51} GHFR@OQGnes WKRHKLAMX S U HAX K WOVKD WW * (b)
GR RORY R YO GIVILRW @® SSHORKWARGIRY DF DWHQWEOWVR@
LWYVHZKW WH QW H@RWKS S RB WIGH F KOGH DQG
ld. DW 7KW XS U HERREKKWAND V RV@KBVD S S H OGG WH U P MCKOWMIER Q
UH F RaWRGQRWK S SBWMQ W IG@IRBVRMVT X DVWEKG HW H U P MCKNDDVAIHR QW H QF |
LVRWKHBBOQOWAV BDYDWKWWUKVHGS & * Eld. DW
,Q V W DG Q W HL GGFAAO H DDUGGAAR Q Y L Q FIR@WOW BUD\Z K H WAV UE B ®U W
FRQ V WGGHULVQ FD Q G@AWS RAV & DWZHO WHE F WRLUVWEH &
SURSH BAR \ERW W U HORROR Q W HW RGA HQ @ DW WKH
SHUPLVWW DB WIK DWQRBtate v. Lopez-Cruz = WK_V WX WIGRHLS
2KLR TX R V8laf@ wv. Ahlers WK VWX WIRRLS
2KLR
b. Analysis
{952} , LWWHQWHAG WWE UD QUW W KIGWR QQ. VL GG WUSHUG. QQ FFLSO
DQ&EXUS RAMYQWHREGAD &@ DQKDEDOD OFKHE ULRXUVQKVV
UHFL GLD/FLWERUNG HU @ % DVAQGWY© Y IRWZK A DI WW BMAUFLADDOU W
IRX QW KW KH 1H Q G MRM HO DWEED Y DL CTRFOCK GIRAWDAGWLRQ
(PSKDREPEVWWHG
{4 53} 7 K HJ HF RAUEGH U HUIERIGOHWRKVIDAATAR X RQ V LO GVAKSH &
SULQ FD Q@@HWS RRNA W H QO MODI KH & IDFWRWWHFRBOGR
UH1O AVAAVWDNMIAR X 8 WR S HLIB SG R VSHRGV WC OU HFORHODWDUERRSDU R S WW@\W H QF H
OF,QW BWW MLIGHH UPL V V WOW 9 @ UR V HF R@K6J U HHO RRA HQVH
$FFRUGOQJQW RAHO W HQ RINR Q WWQ@ D Kopez-Cruz DW
{7 54} % XW KW UE B OD OW RAV D WAY AHH Q WH @ Q WOU D/\W I& R X KI DV
FRQVL GHWURRWRUUGHD & @ %D QB QAWR OO RZHAW & DRWD WH
-15-
Butler CA2022-04-040
S U LFFAP P X GFLAVQ\W WR CQ WRW RU UWE & %l DF WAHJUGIR W
DSSOLE ®ESMBRVEH F D K\HAD ¥ RQ Y LR WW WEGF R@EGJ Ul HH I) ROG KH &
%l DF WFRQJO’S SW RR X UDNWCK | WK UHI R QAKAV/ B WKH U A@QIFRUH
QHH @W KAAUFLADON AR Q V MGKSHE %7DFWRUV
55} $VV WD WERGYH & * DXWKRWX UWHAVD PRWEB WK
UHV SW WAH © W HH QIRGH W H UP KW AEF ORGLRGOVRAO H DIDGRQYLQFLQ.
VXS SW KM Q WHR XK OM &G KQUOR & % % XOVF , QWRAGKROW J XH
W KW WUHH F ROJLGOVRRG S SIROQRAW KERR X U MQ WX@GH & %1RGRHV
K HO UJ HKD IW OW 7 QO FIO HH DIOGR QYLQF BQWMON 8 DIZH F D AWHAAUL DO
FR XWHW L HV IG & %| D F WZAAKLHVQYVD K QQHF H WYAIRUR + HVLPSO\
D U J XVID WAMHUFLADXBUUAUEH-GF (DX ARI QV L GAHKURHOGA WZAKUHYQD '@ RUM T XL UH
W@R/R
{¥ 56} 3XU V XVID W * ZHD WHO D DORR GRIVDFDWMWWRVK
VHQWHEOWEHRGD QF ODL AN GRW KWUE B OUNVG @L WALFRGDVLG HAD WLRQ
%i D F W RoLXBAH \ R @ KIUQ D EW BB @IRIY DF OWKHHH QW HAG RWK DW
OF, QWIDVWW NII HMM [SOD Q ERVWIRRVOKRR X UG GL WELFRGAMLG FRU MVHL R ¢
5 & %l D F WSRUUAV/M X IG IL PP2HO/ KUL AY F RZUHG D QL V F@ SQ HM XGKLIFIH
DUJXPH®MULWOHVV
2. Reagan Tokes Law Notifications
{¢57} 0F, QWGMN AYU J XW WUE BD XWWWA\GD LOW GBURSBUBYLGH
W KPH Q G D SVEFOQU\DRN HDV/ZQ R WLILW BIW URGKK % OF ,QWRVK
FRQFH GH WWK WU ERG GS WR S HOUGONL KH@R U GROW K SIH DJ DARNHV
QRWLILEXW WAXGHY Q W HQ DQ WOXKRAED U J XV PA AFR XHUWAUEAG RDO V R
LQFO WGK ROVARW LIL EE QD WAWRLOWW GY HO @ WACUIK LPVR XWIDVQ RAW HYLR XV
GHFL@KGWW RAD OGD WROD RN RW LIL POW QOVOXK@RGLWWH
-16-
Butler CA2022-04-040
VHQWHAG WH
{7 58} 7H | L UWA @ KVAHR WW KW D V8 2eWitlte v. Chappell, 2KLRAW G
2KLR 5 & % VWDWWHOH $D QW DUWW KH
VHQWHA®E K@AW H Ud th@séAtencing hearing W KDSU L WRHU QMHFHVRDU\
UHT X LW XA ROVKROORZLQUPSKDBGGHEKSKUDBEAO
WKROORTE ONPRK O WELLBROYWL F BRE MW @IQQVHQR WQJL FLIW OPEWe J
Q RON P LWWIBH & % 7K DWX E V H PV/\VWLORA AH. Q.: Ws«a#H# RQ) XO =
QR WW KAI 1H QB HLWYDHG Y L V H PVH & % FY ZKHQ
LPSRVDQ@QGHIS OL WAM A GW ko DJ DRANAWZ 7KNWDWROWORQV
ODQJ XDOWRW VRHYIHU HOG REOLJ DAWA QWHOR KYW BQFOWGH
5HDJO@N HAR W LIL FLIDVZ_URLOAWH QV HE @ RIVO'O WCW KIRR Q W WK&HIO DL Q
O D Q J XADW IKVAW D WOK GV/LHAVD RADHASHH D UD RN AIR WLIL BDWIRFSQ\R Y WG G
W KH1H Q @AKEH QW HQ DQ LPQNWD Q MGR W LIL PR VAR OD@HOOLY HUF
D W KH D U L8G V L ZW \AVEKWWV »D:s =W WW FRWIF\R Q F OAKIGEHWY % F
only UHT X WUKEDWH Q WZ HAF X Qh WKH | H QIAN KBHH D JU DN BGYLVHPHQ’
orally DWKWHQWH @ADOLMG GR Hhdt UHT XWIKIKIAR X U WS HADRAAR V H
DGYLVH P MQaitién VH QWHAG WHA
{7 59} OF, QWIRN KOFF R Q WW EB WDXAD®@ \ \CLWW K BOQ J XPRRU ROOD |
L HW KBAMF D #\DHQ G Dalsitékeease control QRWLIL PDX WAAR © D.0LO'\!) GW K H
VHQWH @ADWDQE X V WO \EFLL Q F O XGA GAU L WWE H @IQLVOWK HQ
PDQGDSVAUW\DRANARWLILPRVAYR@MOODNLWKDWJXPEBR.WWRVK
U H OR_L@V\K B PAK KH R YL VHA OQ VGRLIOW U HA OWeaWwO | L DO GH ROD
7RNAQRWLIL B DWAR GAWKKVHD P'WW D VW X8W H % ,QGHRGBQGDWRU
SRV WU H@@DWEHWO IL DDH ROUWLE HG % D@G 7KNWDPH
DWKTHHQWHROFDQOOQ J XW & % WKPRGLWANVXEVHFWLE
-17-
Butler CA2022-04-040
FRQFHUEDQDRNARWLILBDWREQWKEDQGVXEVHFMARRHU OQOLC
SRVWU H@QMDWEWO |1L F/DWH RAKED OGSRVWUHGAQDWAHROHFWLR
V W DWKW WH Q WZ HEE X\CKD OQ B WH | H QFRGFAWU WO LIQU P D WGLRAY/K H
FVXEVHFWLRQ
{¢ 60} OF, QWRO WR OR@ K LRX S U HRX POWDER O GI RNY HEH &
% D@GSRVWUHGHQDOUIRV | L POX WAAHG@I\D L YAHUCHESW\K H
FRXDWVHQWH ®A DQ&h® P X VIVO ERNV WD W@G L WLLQY KARR X WW LW WH
VHQWHMG W@ig. State v. Grimes 2KLRW G 2KLR State
v. Jordan 2KLAW G 2KLR SDUDJBDEBIN KAO O DitekiXied on
other grounds by State v. Harper 2KLRW G 2KLR __ State v. Qualls
2KLRW G 2KLR V\OODHDFVQWBRKMWKDWRXOG EH
QRQVH QVQGQOIOR Q V W\4\W Fi AUFHV WCW U APROGI\WOQVAAVOL@ L EE QWKEHe) GA \W
H [ H P SV\WOHH D Jd DRIN 1@\R WL IL FUDRVALEHRHO W U \
61} $ VDQQWHU PHSI HW WMD UR X @/GR O WAGH LRX SUHPH
& R X USN WWF H GREG RWW U HED QURRVG. | L FODO/GIHR OQ YUHH S H D @ Ri G/RR\
See State v. Demangone WHKVWOHUR RAW 2KLR
State v. Wiliams WHKVWXWIRKG 2KLR $W UFLADOU W
PX VAWRSHRORYRV WU HR QDDARRKGH OQ WHR D Gta WKH QWHQE L
HQWU\(PSKD DIGG HG XP VAHI R OO ORK LAX S UH RXWHU HFHGHQ\
UHJDUGR QW U HQHODYOURRAGL | L FE QWKER QW WD JO BN RR WLILFDWL
1RIRW KH DVARYSOBHQRZ
2 6RPH RI WKH 2KLR 6XSUHPH &RXUW FDVHV GLVFXVVLQJ WKH 5 &
QRWLILFDWLRQV UHIHU WR GLIIHUHQW VXEVHFWLRQ QXPEHUV 7KH\
WKH VWDWXWH ZDV DPHQGFRENW@ERDVGGEL AXWL RIOD D@RZ IRXQG DW 5 &
VWDWXWH
3 7KLV LV D G@adid vHQuaQ WZLWK D GLIIHUHQW DSSHOO BiattW. QWdksDQD WIKH 7
GLVFXVVHG HDUOLHU LQ WKLV RSLQLRQ
-18-
Butler CA2022-04-040
{§62} ,Q PDQ\FDVHVF,QWR WW WK P WQMDAK IDQDO\RLY &
% PEK VBAHF R Q V_L ¥ WWI LAX S U H&PARHXWLVQ WH US BBWS WLI
% DGQ GH ZR X EGF RUUH MWD ZHQQRAQVLQRMIY WH W XWEF
LQWHU S U/MADDND V RVOD VK AAR U GRVUS K U D WHKWVB WY BOUHOGRFHLYHC
DX W KR UEWQ® WW VEAAWKIRX LV GG ERWR OOD WWV RU VWWKW\UW EH
XQGHU VIVFRR@ GAY K BRQV WU X BW DROQDDUQ Réadding Law: The
Interpretation of Legal Texts +RZHYWUEVQRG RQVW URKEWHRQ
RY HU F RE\HR-VW@W IRM O & OFHLVO WH U S Ul. WODMW L B® F KW KAD VI-H U H
ZK H WHAK L®X S U HX 0 WQ RIX V WLLL TX LOU MV K IB W/W OU HEGRE DWUER
QRWLIL EBLVQLEFROQAG/HI@ W HAG WORUILAUVR Y LOSQ.IDY) W K R ULLQWDAVLLSYWHH W
RDQVSHFZRUFG@ & 7 K DLW KVX S U HFRREK WV D/V RIQGri@ds
Jordan D Q‘GL P LFDDD/UB BR HOVROUH RR @ OM QWHUS 2B MGW DW KH QWHQFL
KHDUL@J& % RWKHRUGQ@BDMVVING & % D@G
H R B® @ QR W KERWAGS K U CLG KAW DW X WH
{§ 63} , QV W MOKAKLBXSUH®&RX UW VX LU NAVAS WOU HRCRECOWV BR
QRWLIL FRXW BRIE O X1.GBIGH QWH @AWOWF RPS O HWWKGERBG BDZ
GLYRUBRAWKHWHUS BID\WD WUREEXK U DL\OM KW D VS260a1H Bates
2KLAW G 2KLR "H:LQH GLVVHQ:W DG UW ARWK AWAY WLEH
ZKRKDYGRLQRWHW K WHAKLAXSUHRAXUWHY XLU AAS WU HOHE
QRWLILE BBWILRRYGORAG O W KO WZ HQ DD OLX V B® KH OQ W HAG WH
LQ RWK SS RB WHR WW EGR V WU ARORA | LW VW eH DY =W
-HQQHG\GLVVHQW LQ J GRHWRWHT XEBKUMAQFRUSRWKDWH
>S RV W UFROGMEARAOL@ W AHH QW HAG WRWAVKRD VHGBHDOQG
"H:LQH GLVVHQWK@QQRWLILFR@E RAR ORLVQVU HR QDMA
EFS UR Y LOGW BH QWHRED OUR & S@ @ Grimes 2KLR DW
-19-
Butler CA2022-04-040
'H:LQH FRQFX UW DOG PRHGQON7 K HIU@IRY W D WUKAVTRXLLAU W KID GW
D Q\ W WLHO.D USSR.'QW U HG IQ DEVENRVOD IMGHOGR | | HQ G\HHUOQ W@! & & WADI G
-HQQHG\FRQF X LUM OG J PRIQM ,D JU HH WAKKSHR U WRU RX WLFH
'H:LQHRWLQERQF X LUM WG J PRIQGK B WO F O WKH WE Yo @
UH T X IRUOHOK W WZ'RS H F LA BIR G W UR ROGI\OVFAVOL@ LL EBS\LLARYCLIO WG H
VHQWHRHFDQUQY
64} ,QVWRAEBQ@ V LOW OH J D UGR QW U HRIQDQUARIG. | L ROW K RQ \
V W D WX MPR LERX S U H8PREXHUDA® U R Y ID@ R @ H [ WOXDV OW L FRRVOXML” 8 @H
PD G@DZLU WAX SU HFFREKHUDIW [ S O D MWCKHIE F -D ® WA XLUWH Q H UO. \
WRSHBM O/\K U PLOWNR X UW BERR V WU HG QDYERRVO. | L PO WER QWOX@HG
DVHQWHAGUGiimes DW 2 &RQQRUFL Wordad 2KLR DW
>H DJ U M/HKIDRAR XJLHAQ H UVDSCHODRNQY@V\K U PLYWNR X USaB @ Myers 2KLR
$SS G WKVW = % X\WWKLH/Q H&JUDLOO KGLRSHOVRAYH DG KDGYDW UL DO
FR X URW WE FL VR & QD WHP XW FER WL@) L AV AWW K DAWU K H
FD VRDQGHFLVBROWD WHP BQ BIW X G SHW U LOG RVR U GOIFLVLRQ
GHQ\DQWLP 5PRWLIRMQFT X LRVOWIK UKEM AEBWRROWEZRQEB
O H DOO OXLQACLHHWF R U@ G L Wi\@ WaH\ V H @ UH D WRRHWE WW KHHQHUDO
SUL Q ALIGDDR XWS\H DW U REX X WRX @GI F HV VIDHUTDOM HW BAND JD Q
7RNIAQRWLIL EBIQIFOXKO@N BQWHAGWAA
| 65} 7 KM XS U HF RREXKUDY O W RWAHIGHR Q V WL 8X ACLIRIOBBOEH S D UD WL
RISRZHDW V HF REGBVILAW KR O CL RO RW W U HEGRQDV@URANG. | L PDC WEAR Q V
LQFOX@MBQWHRAGE Wakian DW FLWioG@ns v. Telb =92 KLRW OG
7 K WX S U HERREKWAND V RVQHARGYBHE XSODU FS GV K AF IDIQV@\ RW H O |
LPSR®RV WU HRACWHROO V WHDE Q@P SR SR V WU HRA
SRV WU H-OQRODIWABARDGR VD M X GW\HH Q W H/i@ FOHW >-H GRQRWHK RAW KH
-20 -
Butler CA2022-04-040
VX S U HPPA XW S D U BRVSLARZH BRO F HIUGYKSIR V WOU HFCRHODAQURAAOL IL FD WV
FR QVWZHDAD G DB SDL WI V S\W RMD J ORN HR WLIL F DSeteR/Ghdcker
6ORBSLQLRQ 2KLR WKH LAX S U H8PRKXWAVOWVGKBAIF DOD MEK GWHIW V
WKRALQLPRR@D[LPXPUL WRQURUGHEEYDJDA@NHWKHSDUW RHQW
5HKDEL OD Q@62A/ULLAHG W ICRA H U AVL Gi ISFRLZOUGY L R O BWIKRHOS DUDWL
RISRZHAKWH QBWU RO BQN H Q\IGHLUE UL ZR & WIK® WO JH DW
1TRWKD@ R&R WWIX S U HFRXAUD/20 D OL @latker V X JJ H WW WW MAHH S DU RWLR
SRZHYURX EGY L RO D WHGIH D J DV@ NN HVR WLI L ZW RQ FOO XG G
VHQWHAG WH
{¥ 66 % HF D ¥VW\KPKK L&X S U H8PRHX\WWWVH D V RIGQriMes Jordan D QQialls
G R HRD SOQV KSH DJ O BN KOR WL | LAFRDQ\WW00RGO H F DO XAVKHRRAYSHL Q IGARRQ V
Q ROS SWRH DJ DRNARWLILKOGHROV % ZFHD UIW MAHRQ WHUSU
W KWWD WCC GHHS H QRG6HrReW idan D Q@ivalls
{4 67} 7 KHU H IFRALCHV L ¥ WAI WW KW D WZ ARVAHOVGGHH DUD RNHV
QRWLILBBWX BUG % PK VWHLYB@VHQWHRFDGEG@W
G FQ RQNH HGR FU HV WIDQWHHQQ WHE WOURV WD WK WOoMUDVATHR WLI LF DW
E HJ H V WIDQWH1@2) W HAG ADO GW RAKUR @ RU H DWHD DZK H WK HWH
QRQH K W UE B XG VG RAWAL QO RIVO F O XVGHEAID JD AN HOR WLIL EQWKUR OQ
VHQWHAG WH
3. Failure to Challenge Reagan Tokes Law
{ff 68} )LQDOR QWRV KXW YOM W W RZUDOHOAH || AH IFRVD Y GND LD/ H
4 :H IXUWKHU QRWH WKDW HYHQ LI OF,QWRVK ZHUH FRUUHFW WKDW
VWDWHG LQ D VHQWHQFLQJ HQWU\ DV LV WKH FDVH ZLWK SRVWUHO
WR GR VR LQ WKLV F DIWHXWRK OG YORWLEMAIVMWUURU HQWLWOLQJ OF,Q
SQVWHDG VXFK DQ HUURU ZRXOG EH D FOHULFDO HUURUS@ QiaWy FRXO
2KLR DW WKH V\OODEXV -KHQ DB GHIHQGDQW LV QRWLILHG DEF
KHDULQJ EXW QRWLILFDWLRQ LV LQDGYHUWHQWO\ RPLWWHG IURP W
D QXQF SUR WXQF HQQDAWOQG GW GAWLAVOHG WR D QHZ VHQWHOQFL¢
-241-
Butler CA2022-04-040
FRQVWLWKWO GB GHH DJ OD RNHYZDQ@ KW WAU BD XBW HOOH\G
1D L QWLEDEIN Q R Z OW GW BAK LX S U H&AHX WI IWG F EF OH SNELL V GLY FAK FR OQ
LVVRAVKARQVWLW RWUGADOLAWNHYZ OF, QW@R KYVRWS H FLKD W
FRQVWL W & Y)LASRODW -Z= RAVKREK@GUD L VG
{¢ 69} :H KDYWHS HD WADGQIGK DK IW L OW WH LY AKDOOWR@WIKH
FRQVWLW R\W4H4356 D OF @N HD ZG R HVRAIR Q V WLLONH WH WEY WWD OF FT
FR X Q Wbiat® v. McClendon WHKVWUUHRSS 2KLR
State v. Abner WHKVWUUHRS&S 2KLR State v.
Luttrell WHK_VWUUHRSES 2KLR State v. Roberson
WHYVYWUUHRE&S$ 2KLR D QSfate v. Hodgkin WK
"LVWOUUHR&S$ 2KLR ORUHR WHSK LRX SUHPH
& R XUMWF HQ WOK W WSHH DU DRANHYZLYDFLBBQVWLWRAWHEAGEUDO
°X H38U RF & OW W\GG R HORWL R OVA ER XW URL 6H SDUBWRERGAUV
GRFWHUdcReHEORSLQHRQ 2KLR DW
{¢ 70} )LODO@G\QWRVBHJKP MOOK AU EFROUWUEG IDLOW@J
DFNQR Z WHGH @ GOS) U KSPR XKRDW HW QH[S OLAFD ROWER HKOVRAVS ODLQ
W KD VJ X PH@ MS SH OQ @ RAD MHG LV FBIOQWH D DAG RK \LWDWUURU
| RW KAHUFLADOQURIWIRD YBFNQRZOSIGQ B@OSU HPAKRDW H\K LW J X PH QW
LPHULWOHVV
{71} ) RW HAIRUH J BIRQW BG VOW RAAOQW 1 @RARQWWEDYH
RYHUOQK,QH AWKDW@LJQRHQWR U
lll. Conclusion
{72} 7 K WV UFLADXQULMERSV/D D HOGOW KH Y RF 8 MW/D GEQODJL OWRRIQVLGH|
LQ V DIQ@ MW LJ DW LQ \WWIRDVND) L OVHRGY W OD WOK W W PSUGRN\IL@HIGI.H F WL
DVVLV WWQUHHY RF RMWD BOG JQ WIR\LKOVRY WD BQH V KLARULWH QWHQFE
-29-
Butler CA2022-04-040
7-H WKH U R NAW RO, Q W\RDWAWV L J Q FRHQUWR
73} -XGJPWQWUPHG
PIPER, P.J., and HENDRICKSON, J., concur.
- 23 -