West v. State ex rel. Oklahoma Tax Commission ( 1999 )

ORDER

Appellant’s petition for certiorari is denied. The Court of Civil Appeals’ opinion is approved for publication and accorded prece-dential value.

VOTE ON DENIAL OF CERTIORARI

HARGRAVE, V.C.J., HODGES, LAVENDER, SIMMS, OPADA, ALMA WILSON, KAUGER, and WATT, JJ.— concur. SUMMERS, C.J., not voting.

VOTE TO APPROVE COURT OF CIVIL APPEALS’ OPINION FOR PUBLICATION:

HARGRAVE, V.C.J., HODGES, LAVENDER, SIMMS, OPALA, ALMA WILSON, KAUGER, and WATT, JJ.— concur.

SUMMERS, C.J. — not voting.