Midland Valley Ry. Co. v. Horton , 46 Okla. 534 ( 1915 )

This case was docketed in this court on June 21, 1912, and a brief filed and served by the plaintiff in error on October 2, 1912, but no brief has been filed by the defendant in error. The case was set down for oral argument on April 23, 1915, and submitted by the plaintiff in error on its brief, and defendant in error was given 20 days to file brief, but the case was submitted on that day. The time granted the defendant in error to file briefs has expired, but none has been filed, and no reason given for such failure. An examination of the very well prepared brief of the plaintiff in error shows that there is reasonable ground for its contention.

In Security Insurance Co. v. Droke, 40 Okla. 116,136 P. 430, the Supreme Court, speaking through Chief Justice Hayes, says:

The "defendant in error has chosen not to file any brief in this court in answer to the brief of plaintiff in error, or in support of the judgment of the trial court. The brief of plaintiff in error appears to sustain fully its contention. It has been held repeatedly by this court that where plaintiff in error has prepared, served, and filed his brief as required by the rules of the court, and there is no brief filed or no reason given for its absence on the part of defendant in error, the court is not required to search the record to find some theory upon which the judgment * * * may be sustained; but, where the brief filed by plaintiff in error appears reasonably to sustain his assignments of error, the court will reverse the judgment in accordance with the prayer of the petition in error. Butler v.McSpadden, 25 Okla. 465 [107 P. 170]; Ellis v. Outler,25 Okla. 469 [106 P. 957]; Flanagan v. Davis, 27 Okla. 422 [112 P. 990]; M., K. T. Ry. Co. v. Long, 27 Okla. 456, [112 P. 991]."

This is a governing authority in the case at bar. We therefore recommend that the judgment of the trial court be reversed, and the cause remanded, with directions to grant a new trial.

By the Court: It is so ordered.