Goldsmith v. Pearce , 345 Mich. 146 ( 1956 )

Dethmers, C. J.

(dissenting). I do not concur with Mr. Justice Reid. For reasons stated in my opinion in Budwit v. Herr, 339 Mich 265, a decree should enter here setting aside that of the Court below, providing that the personal property jointly held by defendant Theodore DeWitt Pearce and his wife, Elsie Pearce, at the time of her death, be'equally divided between her estate and said defendant'and, with respect to the real estate owned by them as tenants by the entireties, denying plaintiff the relief prayed, with costs to defendants.

Sharpe, and Boyles, JJ., concurred with Dethmers, C. J.