Newton v. . Hook , 48 N.Y. 676 ( 1872 )

Hunt, 0., reads for affirmance.

Lott, Ch. C., reads for reversal.

For affirmance, Hunt, Gbay and Eabl, CC.

For reversal, Lott, Ch. 0.; Leonabd, C., not sitting.

Judgment affirmed, with costs.