Benson v. Littlefield ( 1818 )

Nott, J.

I concur in the opinion, that a new trial should be granted ; but whether it was necessary that the negro should have been returned before the defendant could set up this defence, Í give no opinion.

Cheves, J. 1 concur in the opinion, that a new trial be granted. Johnson, J. having been concerned in this cause, gave no opinion.