The Frances, Boyer, Master: Irvin’s Claim , 3 L. Ed. 609 ( 1814 )

Livingston, J.

(dissenting.) — I differ in opinion from the majority of the court. Irvin had a lien on the goods, apparent on the face of the papers. I have no difficulty in condemning the property, subject to that lien ; but I cannot assent to an unqualified condemnation.

Decree affirmed.