FREEMAN, WILLIAM HAYWARD Sr. ( 2015 )


Menu:
  •  lco_quTOF cmwnw[/MPPEALS
    \/x/``¢iliam'\ Ha+' `` Abe|Acosta.C¥erk
    33'1'1 F~N\- 359 SQU``+M
    `` Ll\JrN./_"{:aj'}@}.j;°\u%a$ 7135{
    Ré._~;: ami No§>. '\ez€H”D¢»S )_'\``”was wool
    D€a,r !\/\\r. C,‘hr'..\$)rop§\€r A\.P"\M@») '
    P\€.SS€_,__:C\MC! (':",M{_``.( O€}C~Ecj)+¥\@ C\?‘.'<.``l¢r\jg‘ a,Ud 40 M@ CGF:)L/
    O‘\:``\M@'-Y€\S¥c»r pé+'\+'@w£a\~ wr:»+ 0¥ mamdam ¢_J;S. _ ‘
    D\~CAS€¥``\'\€. \+ w``»"W\ ‘\'\w€ C©UH'. pa C@p of +4/\``»5_':€.4"-)+¢0@3- -
    v\fi€§~$ been -€>,e,\;+ ~\v-‘rl/\@ F``w:s+_ Cour,+ 01`` B‘ppea.\ \/)a_ "
    '\'\/"~(:.5_. \SH€'¥‘,THQMK umw '(``@\~' blow K\Nd help _a,¢\_)d'
    a%§\.%+@.wce m _+£q``\:> \m&y§.;,, -
    S.``:¢_\_Jc_€:ref;if;
    b MQ,W.£/'WJM§AWW$N
    ~_<:,c : .%/(,\b_@\_ A¢@§+_&)
    644 666
    414 464?44' _ 111 1116 111631' 645'\‘616“1~
    1 COURTOF APPFALS
    §444_0449/\ H¢\VWA&D FR'F¥.N\M\\ '~
    ' 4". z
    61;1;14106 FREEN\ANS 1\10116€ 012 11111\11)14~\ 113
    494 THF HONORABLL ;TUDG[OF SND COURT
    C©r\/\ENO\/\/ APPELLANT 44646 114 4416311&46 61\)4144664
    Cap+»f>/\) 61\)‘<4\1\)1))1/\406¥61:4 060-3664 ida1¢_~,, 1¢3 N\6410N
    4’6€606§‘414\) 466\16 04' 4411 3 69421'4 405~41\6 lvw\ 964141011)
    46v 1004 0 mamcl@mc)é 436§66 00 1904 r6616v11\3ka\4?1244 __
    4461\1§6\~1{54' 04 1\1'\11 601\1'\ 4646 44164 01\1 644 c46\6 il was , 1116
    » 016 44\64 6"1\)<4'- 465 664 044\1 mme+\m§ 4\011)0164>46 6012F4' "
    11\)"`` 44``/162‘ 119 6r664 305'4166 12014\ 54011144\1€., A@Ur44416,
    494\042014\.10\ ‘4OW\'4' ,
    pUl’§UanH' ‘4*0"4"61< P Cs\) 4>40€ Ru4e (aq‘lr Rg\a‘40r Freew\aw ~
    446-§ 4411§ 1964166 04 4\1\611)<461110§ 1614-41 44/\6 486/914 431541064
    ``Qow+ 066124121 Cour+ repo"”`` __"1~ re§poM¢/€,M+ \/\/144 5411r6 1
    420%;11\)196 1 _ ' `` , v _ 1 1
    444646401~1 4"1~661~/~6191§ 64504\1411\)¢1 6 1,01114' 04 mandamus 12121~4-4/1"__
    144/13 4:\44$‘4' CDUH' 04 4\66€645 . _. 1
    1913 mayo/amos 16 4 4664 119 4646661966464416 46§1>1>166,1145
    _ 4111646 46\11¢46 446 Ye\6401’ 161441 66146 va 46 6661 _ 1
    441``6 44"1£§4 record= 61\*)”<4 406 446»)66~¢4-5 111:441+4§6 44616111164146
    l JUc4 6 3'6'121\)0 @U"N€H' 94€%1<141"4'4\16> 4°€$0 6§44% CG\)§'N¢
    bmc 66\61'1'4'4434 163591~0161§6¢4401\/\64>11) 6 1664-460 l 4,
    Orc4€¥' 4061 644/16 pre%mhwcl 311qu `` _ .
    ``C €ra¥e_\,/ }¢|@ He&pp:l/rr::)+ 7
    \)L>'\\+\n a\-_C-»©pq D,»Y, §_!__7 =\'e,C.or,JSf-pb,w``a``S$\,ee\ w``¢,+{r\g;)¥{-"gh&kqe.._ ~.
    566.\~4\.+¢¥\€&0/-\/-. S+a+ e,_ \?_>O 5,.'00;-.}3,'<:) §‘;€>é_, 5?1;37?75{» '
    _ (".\``€»»;‘Cf``».\'/\.,/\-pp,~,,';@'¢;§1,``.)5»;:;,5..,_:~_,,.4
    1 haw 4'.\@,<4 a 4{;;54;¢~4¢‘
    §[H&\' ¢'3"``5' ."C ‘o o'nrfq`` - D``¢ 544'?``. <;+ C-\erK‘,'
    C.h v``» 5 D ass ``¢ 9 \ s fjex@ c,L-,»;¥e‘d"'/'» :d€§>q- O’¥ "``50 \ o" _, ;L@ IS.,
    é\~A 14 wae. re.~¥umec_;§ 1\.»/ O:_'|',_D_ 051 ;l``g_[q' 1"14;¢,,20";<§,5+"\12.``5€{@/\/\,
    5+64``4414 '“~66“ ``\1\> S-C-CO Y 6@1~ C!€¥..,.w.``»% § ec+``»o/\) 551;``0,>1‘%" ``
    C'>\>.\!.€'r .\\~\€N‘F Ccc‘e:.-Re§%ves% ¥or_ :\M§Orn%a%‘cf/x/~ngg,\w‘(,§ ggr».
    5 md 'Fegu}_r@¢>j"'\¢@ eice,``p$' dr
    -(:¢DN\:§.'
    U\) l-\ qo\g.'€mm e_:~¢+.ag\~. \>_QJL`` ``\
    C.ofy'¢>c.:¢jho')»\_@»\ '§a_-c:,;,i_\g+q 4 ,/
    . 'C.C.,)?? 444 i.v;@.‘_-o4<'¢3~4\@1€£@de4 wh<>,“\g" 334;``»>,;;4@¢1 ;
    ``bq #\,~Me~ Q~o uv+‘ +Ui-rbe,.: _``_\.mé,iq``e_.y+ "__j;, pr-¢Somé_;\vqco kemam 4
    m 6'41’<.’?4*.7‘,:¥6\~ Me; ve 916 ~6€':»'" O@~‘r*»¢;_j PF¢'~C.%@/é d""’7c’ w 77``€"§€@-$€‘
    ' ' de@m> wm 314 461-§§
    »' \/\)``¢ 57 255 ~\'-\6.41' w 6 rd 17 4 @@»\;~ 661 544 pmi/5 -é-
    _'T.D;C.‘£»:C:l_®.1\90:',)$3-7,86’13 ” v * .
    v 3§"``1;9§ F.M_-.-§g@. 3097_4,
    -» L\-V\¢\)¢q§<¥O/\)``)T€\Lac> 7"|-55"1_
    .  ``~&Q_:\‘ ; _,_ .
    CAUS\§ 4\4'0 4322254.€ .
    ' 4%22,2.00
    44\4 4``444§
    434 COURT OF APDFALS
    044 44044‘54©4\4
    444 R45‘; \/\/4 444._4… HA\/WARD 4:42541'4\/\4.\4\4 342
    ReLa+@r _
    ', pmm 444@ 4%24\)6 D\§\'Y\c~lr QOuH 030
    4634445 C_@u¢\r4y, Texa$ _ .
    43[4444 ON 4:04:2\4\4424 404 4\/\…44444\4\445
    Wi 44400046044 ward greemard §4~
    443£:4' C404)014 444 9543/434$/5@
    `` /~\4\€4J 43 904\)4\4642)4 444\)``46'
    64'42x 4`` N\ 650 6@0444
    L\uuuq€»``\©/\\ T€XSS 7735'/
    ‘4‘44044 04' 000 44;444'5
    NUm[>cr 439qu
    140444‘4 44 041 424424445 604/4/54.4 3
    4440444 04444)"41440424444"5 ' ``
    ~ STATCMFNT 04: 1405 0404;
    R\’._\_ATORS 424‘:‘4'4'4'40424 4§0_42 \)~4_4'24~'4 4``041 /\/444 044~4 446
    24
    '34°4"444\04:444 04 0442 040 44_____5
    7
    0
    2._¢>'¢
    4854)4:6 4242€34_44"4“40
    ‘ST/\TE4\/44:4\4'4 04 F/\CTS
    /.4420444/\44\4“4
    ' _~ ISSU€j 4446‘4'4434 00444'45 46641)44:4414 4\¢46'4\044666‘0 pfowde 42
    " 4 ' '4*40_€ 47_€_43_‘\04’ W\``HW COp\€Z> 0'4:~4.44€, ‘4‘4'4<4\~44@9§¢_\,,69~4‘ 404/433 -4-4/\€. \\ t
    b ' 4'40N0r04a4e jud qe:l§b} 44). 304/446~4+ 0666``40424¢\ _4/\) 446 IZQ.Nd 3 "4 ``
    D‘5``4'4’\C‘4' _Cour~4 4``4'9,4”_445 QOuM4c4 ‘4'4=1.05 ~ » _ _ _ _ _ g
    _4354)6 2 T44é regpo¢\,dem+ 4“64``4/560 _4-0 Per$@m w W/__i};;_::_._.f_ . _.
    64<044>466 04 4'64;00:4___ _ -_;___ __ _ l _._ 3€{0
    CCRTH_ICNE 045442\/464 _ ’_ 44 '
    :``~',' ;, , ~. . .
    _;' r``dz§$?‘~ ,‘ . :_ '
    ~‘.*,l’i"n, l . ' , f .' ' ' ._...'__-4» 12-__‘_,._,._2,_ ~ "-',=
    ' `` ~ 4 . ~ ~ 4 2 ,. ")._ , -A _
    -CAUSE w \¢3222§@; zz,aé_'.e@©
    u\m:~.\/\/;)m.m\r\ m\v\A/ARD):R§EW\N, 39
    `` ., . » q,Re..La+QF .   q b
    , 1 ID…T… QFP¢\,.``RUES-z C<)U.N.S;w = -
    @€\@.*@v~ <:@H)¥\@§ +m+ +&»@,$@\;\,,qu ia 3 ' .
    CO'\F‘P\€*€ "5+ C“; '5‘\’"€`` QA&``“H€S",“~'\“\/\'€.§¢+Ov\ggq§) .. -
    am 3m OH\_' ',v_'\>``ereom WhO-\na§aw \N+€r€$d\ m _H©
    OU"'C¢O“\('> 0 l '¥\r~‘.``€>"`` §>€3!\4``\.0:\>’, ’ » _ , . .
    Ve\a)mr Freet\nam §r."\‘.‘> a'§>x'O /Se'\``\+}qa¢<>~+ engel is~;
    N@¢S~ vepreeer\‘)¥eqi b_ ngx),\s<:>eL§\\) +ine pr<';ce@di/\)qj 300
    &'\r‘vor Jr\§€; S%alv§. 1919 Te'>'<_as
    n (:>J
    111ng 01 1111-1101'11165 »
    , CASE § 7 pgqe i\jd,n bar
    wa v.F»HhCom~+o-YQP pea\e 'W ,»
    (71}]\).'913 Cc€O 613¢‘1( 191 \49<1) _ , j g
    Re (``Orowadoq€()$,\~l?d(pq 673(7€)< App Saqu ``
    t1``\))‘}‘1‘)1\110\€IG{§;@‘\wqPK”OC»§‘€\'M\!<§)
    NR6. T6bbiQQ_ipS..\13 35 753 751§(1191 APP \.\Oub'ym``\
    [144111 D‘.s+]l©oo)
    fm \;le \/\Jash11vq4om 7 5 w 3d 1314 \E§;).(.Te»<. pr \»\01>51‘1>,\18
    1111@1~_,1.11111 .. 111
    O\/\@.r@ v {»\111»1< 1``.11111¢1€¢ 60111 613@3 111 211 1411/51,[
    CT61°6 !\pp,~ ~D@LL§~;~; tciC;C)) 1 q,
    Ho
    fzm
    I1\1
    14
    RULES ' .
    VC>~..RD p,``ppro.)©(c§) . q
    ' STATL)TVS . ,
    Tex Gov¥ Code 11\1\11\1 Sec+@w 21 QQ\CQO -; 5,8
    "1'"@,>6,§10\1“\' Coc\e_. P\NN Sem&»o,\) 121.;2°1\(¢\ , g
    Te><, pem@\ C,»Oc\e §ec4~1oM-37110(a9_(37 (d'),.\|err\)b¢\l 1999,.__\0
    ComngTUTI C)\\\
    T@')\.CDMS'¥,A\~¥.'S``§G» , -. 5
    S\)rvwm+ SS\JWQS /315¢ 1\) \/ Gam\§ 737511~3. 1le )'9(91707
    ('V.e¥~ Ap§> 531\)?\1\14@¢\1\0 \981 ,_ 7 _ t 9
    11
    _ _SQAUSE \\'10; \3222§@)€:2,23%0
    . IN.Q\::\A/\Lw-_\\\/\ \~\Av.\/\//\RD \?R\z;§:.»\/\.AN;§Q. f »
    ¢ , " x q Re\é»+¢¢ _
    »RWT<>``RSP‘U:TIQN~@'OR\NRH@…AWNWS
    Ré4c)~4br Fré_e.mz§w) SL\bi\q``\+g 364/445 p-e,+"\+``=@p 4m l/\'I:v;``¢:'+o4 f
    ``, ,_ wa..\). qla§mu<.=> C,€),N\.p\e}¢\)?.uq 04 ~Hw. A@,\s``\a'\ 04- pm-'¥``»cg\ar
    ' ‘p``gvé``~\o¢\m¥ r»»q~»-¥‘we@\x€z_covC``\€>_'.z.,q, ``\+per~‘ra``,,\jg+@ his
    4 \MMQC €,¢\>.°>€.,&mc§ \r\``\s mclth 40 a"<;on,\ \>\e+e gopq 043 H)s j ,
    "4'!"``.\&\£ ’§``€C.O‘{ ¢§'Zj) &i\‘)C\ Q\\ €7§\\``\40``\'4``3/¥4\€<§``\[\\ ‘4’\/\05€_ ' {. . ‘
    §§\“0(_,@@<.4``\~><‘1%. I\\'a..m' e!q‘+\~.€..» Y€\a~§rc)r€> Cc.$m Q\a``m.¢‘é> 64 ~\4)<¢:‘ '
    dew``\a,\_ 059 544 444€_ Jc~ra``.¢\)‘&,cr}\>»``r% @4; @\\_ \,{\.Z.W'a\ .BPPCMGNC:€.'
    Fo\r Q<\av``\¥q\\“€>_\ aim \%``\‘€.S;err'ed. 49 65 Fre,e.,~\ar\))‘ ' " ``
    ' r€%()e?>;\)c\ea\)+, \:\la``\)v§\~\\(_‘e,_ 4;\\@'?<``3¢\);\)@ 43 teree_r r_ecl+@bq
    ~\\)<9"\”’€``, '@-'\3€4 '"4‘4/\€ V€?l\ pa,\``¥~q ``u\? "\M+ev'e_s,+ ``,<-;b re¥€ civ-3440
    613 444€, 64a-46 041-7b >QS-)s.' ' - '
    '%Tmf\i…:m ©xé' J‘L)__m§mCT-ION
    4 T\}\}S C,Qur4 '\r\e»€>"&)“``-``i€>€l``\c+'\c):w 40 ``l€»‘§>o€ 3 uM'-'s+ OWF'- » 7
    .mawdam€rrék. ‘.@,\>54. §4,(+.5 §<,fr€ »<. Cq@v'+ C_@Q!.@-.
    §;\;1.2*.2¢ my - - f
    STA*)*E\_I\E..:\"" Q.F"\?'Hs; <:AS\;
    TF€`` L)Md``@.v 4<_"``11\)<1 pmc€€<§``¢!\lcj)?v€e w\ew\)`` Ma‘s Ap§)@ézieci
    H;S C:o:\)\/¢CHOM amd ``u\) pro ce%<., purchased \n``.s+r".al
    YQ?C\O¥°C\‘S '4:0¥ §'u+or€, E``Sppé\"@~\:@ .Y``€"QSON]N@,)_Q‘\$CQ [,,@ v
    V``€Cll<€;\?€d 4\``»3 Q.Opi€% 04 +4\€. re-Cmc?@ '
    ``“6\'@5 0/\) clau+ 35 \/"\/"HE>Mr@., @.m'am\|€_; a,\')c'"``\s-)%é'
    “n_";a.\ Q.€)\_)Y"rj€>) CCS_L)Y``<\,“ )‘_Q POH€I, L)\?>4'w(?v``e'\4»\e.- 4401\>0"@``54@.~ . .‘ 5 "
    .:)'uc\.ce I®\{,\IJ. BU",'\\\C,H ``\S"H(\iz *>\'(;~‘@:vci}w- ``;,'A,--$ @_.P'~Hwe~
    y . 4 °\A U-\¢ x
    \b\)c:..\;e,r4
    1+4\€¢ \c“€.i’a,+c)r 've¢'se\/ed (;@p``i``@<; 94 \w\:z 4‘<~'\@,\ -"r€ cords 4304~ '.
    P``juquf.->'¥ \;).44;\ +LW‘-~ }S~w\ 04 Q.Ol?>, ``\M w\r\``\c,\A 414@. ¥\@Norab¥z _
    \T'Udc\\_°, :``)-Z}.i"l\€.§ 4"\\\\;4€.?»$‘3!\;) ``-P\'@%.\l:l; \\.\0\ ``\\\) ‘4’\¢";‘3 4?2¢0¢:4 D‘\$*r)€+``
    Cc>w»%" 04" -.P\an``~vs 'Qou_:\r)\;)’\”e.>gg'§,,“¥’\,s;@ v'e<_,pggJC/@M,L ga 31 _j
    ' C'\__ew``.,a¢~.)0\’§\@ € J``Oé¢``e I¢w\ \JO. %un\\'<-:Jv£* §>\``€€'~CUNZ Of'~) »”4'.4‘\€°~- '
    53 m€~ C_@S€- ~ . .' _ ' - .¢ 1 1
    ``````````````````
    *».4
    ;SSUES PR§S§NTED
    ISSU~E 4. fT¥\§ 4\~'\§\ opm 43 r§c@vd§`` \'>§§- $@``;l``@,§+p
    . PYO.\/ldc 4412 F€)a+c>r w\-H§ aop``\e%, 104 441€``4§\``34 4451_,\;..
    ~‘FC*' P.'* ‘~W\.¢Y€ 449 *'*»§N§v§;b\§ '®d§@ 'S§§w-. @§.»»§§H-
    4 iP|-é§\§'\:\ip\¥\l 4"‘\(4@ 48)<’,1";\:¢§"")\€~,4'\;{@+ CDUK,+.) H_QW“S
    C©U'r\r\q , @KSS, 4
    §wn§N§NT'QPTM§§A§TS,
    R€La_'jr@¥ '4:':'§§.:\.§@,:\1 was ch§r'q@(j §,§'d anrduic4@§l/'A) aug
    5€);0§4 ES%ZJU 44 !;“§€>QJ&NJ 53,§4€»:\.>€€¢/ 410 S€\I€ I\ML¢/`` 4?¢``\/_€'
    q §§§§ ’u\) "‘v":o¢§. R.e,\§~l§§r 41qu app§§\ ed ami »41§§§§ § re
    Qur‘r~,gul» §\ p§¢§d§\)§l ``\N§ 44\§`` 424 Q¢_>uv~%m@ §{,)p§.§fs 34 ' -
    H@,US+GN C)A) 'H”»@;C/c':h{ \”€4_3.4¥3¥ FK€€)»»\@N`` pv``<``<;.§\a$ e.c) 44';€ (Z``QP}-e§
    ' 84: 4*\``»3 “4”¥4¢94~ \'€CO%~§"S ``\N‘ "4‘"4j\€~§1‘\)@"¢-4- 44')34 414'€~> ;4``1.1'€;4 .;, Pe'@[
    \,»
    proves 40 be.U;\)s:u@€,€$f``>$.._)l,ho¢.u``ev§v c,){>§u K”&c.§}§)+»-Q£ +!,e»-
    "4¥'.4:14 Y€Q@r¢j~;,,l’\/_\a‘i Y``t.°l'éH.~ok:Obf>_€.r\l€c./'*‘l'\€§+ C.':~_“~;~f?&i_.\) pch/145
    _ 04 44\€ "h-``¢a\ Y``€COS'J/:' wfikt-';‘ YY\``\SS``:Nq ~Q;@m 44)€ ”.H"; Z)_.["n»gor¢/s
    &Wd 44\§;$€4;0¥'€“ _wnHz? b®.€._(<-¥¥@ 44'\€`` f”€%p@§/dau-{- 3;\>6 '\n)%w``r€§
    3b004'"H'u:': ‘»j'”\``s<.>%¢’»w q &\,'4$/_§\``00_/\ °‘4``4®€`` '4``1{;&4 Y<’ Co rcl§ N<'Sr\»')elq
    443@ 44»-\§\ “``\T\“§m$c:e~}pjr »§n§ 44».§; €§r``/l€\- 4¢~§\ wm 441a Sam§, .
    C/BS@ qj~.g}¢e,u b\& 441a ';\40¢§§\§§§\04§ ')\) dc)>LH'/\J§4»4,_;l §
    `` '§A§§UN§NTS '
    1055 U€. 4 iT\_ne 445\``§‘?``4“:0,@0§+5 r§ac@r§le.", 40§<§ 4§34§§;1 40
    _pvov``\d E: 44\``€ ``re\a.+m, LU``:“H§ C@p¢€$ @4"»' 441\€4:``~\§441‘§“)$_'
    clr',_p+ where 441§, 440.¢§1§)\'§4>_|§ 30§"'¢5 §``:§``§ u¢., E)u‘r;\§:e+,i~
    'pr@<_~,'»@ 465£1€
    \}J€' bm)§+ ‘Q\J``H“»€r 64 €jf“-’~"m``\M¢i,‘Lu}'\€HnP/r”'+\\€. pé)F4L1 h@§ 546
    336606:4€. \'€Pnec\% 40\1 €§p pea\. 1 cl m amd-am 03 »')s \.N4§~Jc<1,
    4@ bg 5;§3"» ~€71“4"$;»,0§<4;_/0&1" L``{`` §-:zm.€ chi Q‘f!¢?.=c,)§)d‘i@ b] e`` )'}\:)``
    4l sml'4§.d C.'\ \_,” C§Q;sv\ G§»"“§N f;§:€'~ crj_i\JO¢ 'Jz 4\.>¢§,-3’{} 3'_‘4?’" c ``9“5+ '3") d m 'e""+
    !\J§'~i,‘.. <:<§§:,§4¢~'4 hud r§)o~‘§ 40§' q‘_'"€‘/ '-‘3 £‘;4 tila‘~""'4“``1``°``45;4`` "'5"'€'~°4 be a dress
    €id .b'§j 0441§%"?5\+§§')§§’i§£,, 4-4.§>‘.4¢_§»'1'.§§1¢ V;44'§441“r\/Qour+_@43 ’
    g_»,p'g»:#€»§@§§_f=$ 74§',;?.-»$.4§§, QLA) {§ZO,',*.,:§§§§‘S#CT€>L. 4 ‘1``8‘3_) I:£);_jj.;?:Re:`` §E"bb) 0
    ;2``1§‘::£»,§§,3:4 ”}:€?», ':'§:.-‘@l C``fii§;:sé:'App.-- Hz§§s+o~ f_i"f¢z;§§__pi§+.]
    ;»1<:>00``/‘. . '. _ 1 ; . ' F `` ‘
    I§€su€,_¢ 2 !4@»``\“4§§ ``Fr"e>_e.w\'§§>’é, »C.§5§§ "'»»§ &Ur.~»,§M/[@A) .
    '~pp@_a``\ 4 .1~4}{§;'§-”€00)'4; hOw&:-J§§rf.-H\§ r@,4§4br mal/z§»5ed""§"f"f=§},,``l,
    § h} 5 n § 10 Y‘§§;*'§:@b\@ *J.U dq€ §§§( (_U. 'B'UVM€H`` U.~]€S l\')“``-€'5"<1[""?"_“Wn@"
    §§44~0§ do wolf §§ ve § gale '-ua+€ rem;§.c'i‘.q 04 iam
    B"'_€.?c-§vs,>'§ 44"»5 §§ 1\)04 §) -§"*4§€¥ "\l````’ W‘/“Cl”\ H' '."C~a/\/ 56
    _ __§pp§§;€§§f 4a 44{.§ €0:))4§``"¥430§ 44’\€ §°€~53-”'4@:’"' 954<*~'~ ``H/‘““$
    C§;,>§~i~ 40 qv§§:i- \r"»$ m§‘r``»+ 04 mer``~ld@m 1150 Ci``"a"/``}/``N‘! .
    411/m 44\§ r§'\``.€/£“h¢§ éc.e!<§.
    U\``)§ ``w§ue j 0§``.¢§§1``§<,.4§0¢§ 413 ¢€)SU,€§ wr``145 v¥m%§"da"'“/S
    i§-d,é``§``w'z+ 3 d‘i‘€>+\~ic.-i' Qouv'+§:)ddqe 04 COUM+ Q'GN!'+
    ~‘40<4.‘[€, 'u\) Gu``r 543'4.§}04‘ :§,\)ci 1,0€» .D”@-\§ "534"€@~4~ LU__CE.)J"<"
    .r\,»)§§.§.§§§§~ 40 €§~* OFQ.Q @w' .XU"<\‘dj~’“’*%``@'“'§``€"€ "'€K’
    60\'."4 (i@§§ .4``4;\)§3§;1.1.9~1?4 _(C\'> v§*r“’m\‘ 464?"835'§3'3"&' UG:) '
    _§§§…§§ S>UP§.;.§§§B :-SE§ 143 §§ W@»SW\N<§+~":~’ q 391-434
    \§"§`` (,``T'€~L. z’;\_p@,~' H'O(_)$J``r@/s§ L 454 ``D;z_;,+‘] !qqq``)§-
    \,\}€ \,\QV€ MO :W§``,~§,d:\_`` <44»01~3 40'\$$'0€€ 3 _Lml+ 04
    m§s\)§§mus §’JC{§"» 1094 §) @71``1~:``=.#:'§?<24 <1»4'€:*4*“ 4"°4.€£5 %``ML``
    45 i\\€ Q€.§SQM ``4‘~’3 €M?ov%c§€ .©"»’Y § U_Y" 5-‘¢)``; C"*+;GM'
    30 614-044 430(``, C4>4``04\4§ 99 665 05 444 449 46 44 ,@’454 1164
    Apj,~ >'§4\.4 /44\)'+79».4}0 4C4"\25, 4))",¢, '_74' <``4=€»0!44\} 4 34240/444+
    304/§qu AS:>N \/ G§rc}a 407 .‘~:``4.4)04 ad lola, 44;)'4 ( 4e``)<
    App .- @4.4444444@444@4<44§4, 000 44000€<.4,44¢4) \5244 404
    964 4``)"4(4\444\_444 4¢91\24 4<> 464 <;‘40~4' "'£``.44;3.. ' '
    _4 404<£, Our~¥ ``v\ 43“4446 ;.4_;§4 544464 ;;-24\) 640 4 554)6 8
    wr``,+ €4¢,07 07_'24\)§4 606 r€%po;uA§-M baca 705€ 04 770: ,_
    4“'444\24\’44“4§4 804 male 4\/3(_~4 G.uc! 4‘4'4€ 43004 ~_4~47340 ~ _
    "BM Appzw 344 "4<004;4\40/4' 440 47,4< 0;,7444'44' 934 “7474‘,``> *4‘4/'\/46€_ CD¢\I~ »'
    €64’<
    A:0 53 p;.``.6:4.
    pmp€vf\\
    46 4'4?``€‘434~‘4< - 47\``4 .4'€ 4“ 444 45 L4'4JC434 406 v
    .. ,_ 4
    4;~] 4:44)€;4 §§
    40
    \ 7
    004 ~4_0\”0\4 46.__4»‘4) 414474€4'44" ~44€; 4~404-4~ 9 cf
    440 ~‘.\JC>:§\J-¢?S..,_L, 040_0 v470 4)4"<4)€¢ €-_‘;\_4 7pp@
    00
    \,\400{\04\ 7430 4~. ¢4'444' ~4044440€44744: "=44642 604 4<§_ 90004/24)%440:4
    404,44~'4\0 044».4~0 ~40 74104.0<4 040 000\.44<04¢ Y.C cod 3644404§0;\/74 §
    74\1)."“`` 4\”44: 34;4>64 46 G.OuY-4' 479 per 004'04\1``44'5 1 4_44\40‘4'0/0' ~40
    0424-6,4-4~/7449€,+4\€, C©r§€c+;\l¢$% 034:“447€4 Owc=.'\” C~Oort4$
    dudq€m¢/\/+ c'?K§y~c_ ``\/. Apé>g 4: 4,0'440¢474 (‘@,,44-:» 54%0 8 w
    9_<'4 4‘7'4 v 451344'467,7» 430 47 34'~"-."403
    TM;» burde,\) 455,\4-44¢€ p§v+o\ 5664&4/\.4‘4 remqu 40
    360 44\§~'4 0 00@4‘»4040»4~4 reading ,5 prege,\)+eo) +O ,
    534/4000 604\3@\» ve%w.v‘v/u7 \~p\)@§§@\ T£X 9 App progb(d)
    t 647
    ~7§?\4\4\;’> V``l'\)f"; Lx)'l“\d <§@\J€wd{m@m“~! 41.11,\';55,74;)4)<;4@~( C,~é.rj»
    Y*{Qi L¢L}r.. suf”"~.£?.a§ "7) §§ 444\7\\»4 \E'_r: 4,-@{_';77777¢¢>§\,);\31_\_. __§C€u 7TQ;.
    k951¢\3‘~§7\v Q.c:c_ie 7’:-7137?0(¢23(1))£ \J€‘ri\.)wm iqq.*i).. :;j‘ 4§§|511
    ®1<.4``5 Q?>D°'-\s.¢~ +4§1;) ~
    C"~€-,M+sa \\§+Me, re§pc),\;».l 691-115 ®4>1 1311,50_¢1» 471):i4‘v haw §)0_1_'@ @,11<5 cluw,``J-i``fo
    (7<3-\».``5€'~ ‘“77iif4€? €id~rov" h'éwv\ 951 44'°1\3 114/004 imm 44/\€ c+€mg 57\£‘;_
    cf 1~>‘<“4’&/7-. 74``\({ 7777' 43”1``£)¥ 75’1&"0\’€§.)4.14;4¥4‘<}!;} LO¢AP§QlN~°d ¢.10004’ §17"``5.
    ``c"€*;.§;')r¢, RCN\ 4473 "°'715"4 '<974 §?]EL;$ 794 444/1512 476\,10\1’;\ \\9 3 xian ..,``Tm,{ 77
    LU~ mev‘i+ 149 1413 48$4.1\)'15 :``)"z 1414-115 G@c;ré H::M``s 1 51»1/1)~@)
    44"4R{»\.YE.P
    CD ;€~}\|(``~»1,-»``;¥§475 §>§”q .,``r:: 74{~\,’,“'4\1\9:‘7§' 44‘\7_4‘"`` \.€>:’\.JY'T"Y
    a\\\,>W-" 7"44_»\¢. 13 ``-O,;mf 4\‘>"7;'4_, dau,\‘ €l C;{> L_§ D;.f`` 47\1§' §\<;``
    rld! 4774&711.1575‘77,1’7§4}4' 7'1``4-:!.1¢13&'41"'$__ 1’)'4'71\'-‘ 1441 117 431 ``;~_§~r;j§ jj\}(u‘."_$ }f\,[\';",
    7"7-{7"'€§ a ‘4‘°4~'§ 47``-7)' §777"7``7;4\7``€``774"&7777 .»*7'4"'~4 ``."$7; C(.IN“§ 3``4.: 4_"``})7"’€14!" 733 (\j@+‘
    `` 7947\``7\;~”7 4“\_``-.@ N\O<‘~¢" gulst ~ ...HQ+
    Cea-'\'d`` 41\Ji4>4… 34 4 s1 \4°{=,31/€ 1+ .%1:> 511-1141 1114€@4 H€_
    §Q¥``&L\J_§ F‘i'\\é> Q9U4’4" W74\\ 4'"&``;>¢\101»4 §p,``¢~§ ‘(``€%u€c+
    \44>5
    m:;m\;:_ 1111 '»»\13;@\)1@1
    Tz'\€:`` D€’“‘i€r\)€``!m\} l ``"\_1\11 ?:``m\ 1"1€~1 L_.~_)&yc1' PY€er~/\,QN;»
    51 51913@5!``1; wqu ~ 1111 1111,111)1~\‘14 135 p\¢gw/ »*~1,11¥
    JF\/\€ '<'Sz'boue; \£>51'11)': 1?1f\3c1 Lmre_g¥ \~0'5*13€. \>@&.':‘; 011 mq
    chmo1&uc[°,1 5\111 ~H»Q¥. H/m> rin mam:lwv\w 1_13§1§ vf_
    psi 1211 mim{;~:z ’:1: 13€1§, .1 11\:.111~\,\1 i\~£c 1135 ”\14\€/ 555 1313 .U:) 1135
    \.§ 1)\’*151:1 1133 ("‘~\13 1/.55"1\/\?9)\ ~1\€3 1``~\'¢51“1.~"1 ~1 CDQ<>J} D13”1Y\5 5
    C\€Yi'\ (,\n‘rs> Daw\€.l<.> Q£>:;*``L U/H:,¢@ §Q;\ ;§/ ;\-nu~,§-@N)
    T¥?.. 1353 Ii¢``'_“ 1114.»51,. , W
    1:.‘1\”'".11'€>51 C>;\)+"v\€ 15513~4 @1>1\)0\/, UL@~ 511 1"/\# Q‘\MJ
    §§ 1~»@\,1,[\)€\4_,_' l)M‘\’ 381¢2 \2 I\!"\. "_-'33_,> ‘“O ~DUU"HF)) “\H}Jq‘>"'@lq/)
    T<§:»<._§i» 51'11.-,"55 f
    1D1M1@1YQMWa/zi é*wumw 1515.$15/§_€
    \\§1:\``1,\``\``13&'$”\:\:1\3\1\..\)3}’3 \'r``e(»_,fv\a'\) §;-\» \>g()[$e
    15 DC 3 ``\1.)\\)0 \6¥§“3¢3>
    ~1"\@~’ b. 91011)1\)5111/\ \)ru``.»§~
    359“101 \; N_\, 359 l..JUxH")/\
    L``,\uuuq':’:.}c)~» ,"'1€;.<'!§ 17:_";§;
    (-'a l\-")
    

Document Info

Docket Number: WR-83,228-03

Filed Date: 12/3/2015

Precedential Status: Precedential

Modified Date: 9/29/2016