-
AJO. °^ FILED IN RPCEiVcD IN The Court ofAppeals ^&,xtriiD°.!tfrlS0tt" =^o -We Sixth District u; 1i ii»5 c oo^\ O-Q .A^«-«U NOV 2 4 2015 r^T^J" ' ^oc-CW Texarkana, Texas Sv*^ "£
,| oo. p^U „ „ .fWL> ^i,A^ioWW(,^lVm4)< - „ F . _ .p.*/r tW^ /VM-xjoniW P^£ ^ -r 2Crv"^ a<^ A«oWiWi c\*t*-m SW\«f-.13*1 *3M C*Vhchrpm^. . ., .. „ ^i2,\Z,\i cuVdvcA-W v VrocWer 4*4 x7Yu.<;. sm*. CBHJ 0 f n.4l C-ocVe-2. 3^W^c^c_ \3 ^wn l-Vo\^% ^__^ 9^9 Fj^ M2v £24 C 3^ "7 CTe^t .A#- A^O a OOO , 9LcJh6iA^ UJ_S4~l U.S. V? CXOOU i * p-3^ CQS« PaS^ VS^>S^ ^VCTci A^.Cor()MS CWUU no peV h } * „ « - ^p.3G G-er-sWov/ ?*3^ 4ao^>. k>3 CmrJ - , r ^ o «i7 ^om v*t 11^177^, gV *0. Ores. A«p Cecuw^A^l lo, juohU n* ^V, ^\ . p# | Groi^avii n/ fWAq>poliV p. £•( p«t© i- "^ cArCifc i"^orvVdlw^e^.tp.o^-U p.37 vW&in 0\W^o <&T) ±^\^ 1*0 Cxi* \*fto) , 0 „«..*>. 47 \\of^S\J^M %\% W^£ Xi\ CTev.AwionArA Cell fX&Oill CS*wOc\r«o) 6 , „ » .(p,3?,<^ - --«o.3? u,V Goas\ Arr^A^ YAVJ ^ „ .. p-W3*W^ ^e^ Su.Cor^ .?. ^\e 1>:lUO CVj 3 ~ * - . ^ p.Q.0 \% u.S.C. ^ 3UtU ^ 0 „ , ., , p. Ma. 2T u.s.c% *2U4 c\^C>K& • . . . * p.3^ l\ ;u u ^c. i " c^c^Cc^ • * " ' 9 A ^e*. oC AJiW-Vw p6_s/Z_ XI r-. W>^-VG i xx^M 0 „ , « , . &t LO Mx u.s.C. ^HT7«C^ . . . . m „ . . . . .p.3* Tt^.toxi^V Coke VaA.0\^ „ „ , „ . p.)(o ~tW.C5vi*9raiC. |U~ Go^.g \ \o\.oDA «, w „ , , p. a3 •V^%. Go^e. Ccvorv ?(0C Ar\ \\.07 IM &\ o c * _ p. 5C -fei. C^U Ccvtv^ §T0CAc\ O-0lC\} «, o c -aDO Tw. 6-aoP. ^ ^ a „ c . . . e . -five InAtaV CWVk Oexor^frte^ cle^s. $&,a>^ Vs^zh or> 9-3HC oofU ±>jl cefe/re^\o belov^ q^ " UUvxfP ^KeM^ -CK*l e^WitU op -Ov^ >o^\K A^W G^pWn\ u Yk e 9\«^vr\s * G>o\^ ^\l b"eWre^-Vo ooW^eo^ oVokoAi hereto e co^>\ou'A\ c^iaiy e-jcUtTiV "cki H^eVo, fieo^e \v\ \W\i Cour\a Oe Ah>sao ^tvy ooniA*T -Qqc^s i>eA-CoP-Vh >xo eA- 9WA ;VicV^ See GocV^c rr^ui ^e vw^W^ ^ «?M9WA ^ 47 C^c,Nrl^OCn^o^AWV^o^9l^ U^eev,ei \o iacU&e <*y uJiVWi -Vion ^ rcsooV -Vo oc sdosPCJL ^Wose octunqcy ^a,VV^ rcqj,nqUy 9iX€- iVton*^). ftaaVW dC^WM rx<&i* are. ^r^U, c*u ^.^ qVj^ J"p 33b ^ 37^,379 CS^Cir-2003) OWWnj -VW* a co^-V rv,^ \^K ^ -"^ C-Ue nAii(oU ,^,. (LX;,. P. 91 Ak ^l.jous 4o (UJu „(,]c^.^. G*otU\v>£. ceVo"cvVioo Qa<^ VfcW* o^ An €tUc\\0^ Af>pe«\ - *e«_ c "\ ddeiuv^- ~T>^ i*nju/)cVi>€ (JjiVe^r ^ooi^lnV \n$T&bf\ - rAtn W\o c\a vKL c-eUe-^ ua^qj^ <-uuA1C^\cft3„ on S-PH4 -Wve OxsVocV Co^A ^COA\e<^-Mr\e OeW^OA-V XfLi^es iWon £ellsr* /*-Terri e Uailn?- "^Tuj^VxcVJon -se^cvX-OcU ^.qo -On n-i-W TKe oaVcfc* Cooj>V oWei A^tVWVs, *V^noO ,£cC J\%p>xc\t*sQA\ 0^ Gouas^I ,i^eQnc>o\.l p.K<>s . Oa OrHS -tVe 0\i\<\c\ Cout\ ^coaV^A 5v\€*>e *c3x\\l<*ri ou^VSoo^-^ oum;^ Put^jloaV -VoOao^T \4 of -Vto C\\i.9rc.e. (U-^.OxlG .^e€ C^vroU p-4SO. On k^'S-IS" C^"VoO -C\\eA K\^ rw>Vvon ^rLwy« To A*" aA/^ euuvH2A noo^ d4V\nC.W\€? A^e\\<*4 GouMe\ G«tr^ AVtor^Cjr\*re- a Sri^J- -/\\Coc^ ) <^a*s. ^r^ -^U A\io^ on C^iU's WW£, Att«r re^'nj SotN^ W\e£ CmW, o^ujA oo s-eWe/ices oc c\Wioo$ i-o^re. c\c,Ae V-o-^ ^a,YW.AV^do We $>da>W erroneously &W^ A^\.-W^ retonU dvWi "re tn^ua^nj q\do«V mac, wy.AVWA. vjOete o,own,n! A^q (J.C0W " ^W^.e^ C«»\»*A on a/, initioeA Oo. oa-o4-J^C(L . Cal\t)n £\\e^> a wr\V °£ l^Wear Corpus 00 ai ^ ^ ^ otvWjt ,w^Wr x'0 -yvM co^ Y *JD. C-aij-oo^tVciVUlicX- A , ioau>s--S-.?o-<37, s-ee ccotoH «^-tV ^ its-is-? cv^"W aA f. toao- ,Sd^Ur ".Wl^," »a aa a\Vr^ Src procure VM_ «Wx>A--ce.u>r^\o no Quail. ce.ecft.odU " \i -Va\\ux-e -^o ona^ C€Cisoaei\ole vn£u\c\es aW>^V VKe e*\enV 6t^e- record. £eec C^\Wu U^Wa\ H>q^ Was rv>cAe-wiUi AVg, C(LC&. uJnicVv CAI^oa r^e- QjU" on ^'\3-U- GM-len i^a/i JftlfQj oMa oa Ou\'0^T"\^3L-~Ap(?^l cmoIor A Ateu3Trtql cW Vo W\k kircO* QfpeaV ooa£ cesoVa^ onQA"o^pUU oa^ vns^&uenV record, ^e vaaV bs-^o -K4W^\n ^-^-S9 JoV.\)^- P (v^uJrvS iWl^P^ '" vW^f * A^sdS otWi /"oaWU ^ an aVV^V \o peosecvJ^ ku W*uA ,^a\ iXf'W^- ^JaIUa po^es 0 ^\aiWA*«l fv^Vo Cq^o'i i«&4y cvxAvu-dlWop, rfSec^urG od*«nUlVon " V^o nn^M fc©J«s o£ ho aaqjop Ae?cess,V> /meAvcaWi c«ujues> U/n V^ e^i" &esire Vo wV Wa^mA-V \n<^G CA"cVk" on^«A)cuiWn5-VoA\€-"^ p.iafc-U"?©^ ni-m< on s-x ic^AW-5 AA^onT^ ^i"-•rCt^ o4r P MS"°.\4"ej^r -fer ^ ^oV\(r> T^ AwGaA ^o\-\V\ £<*cVs <~onWneA -YAen^Vi S^oorn -Vo caa^lt AVe_ "a^vV^ °^ 9^0^* i€€ -^A iuppCd.viol-l jp./M7- Spacifec«AUj^-«A. f.U- AUo .*« sfcu^ oo&apj-eCLvJoLl p. 4*f*<2^ trO cespec \isie\v *AV w>Wm Anrf^e Q^vW-> prepared a^-(C~ir . AtW* b^oe §>u\-an nwcs -HictM^v^. Vo o^la^ <-ocu ajul^gA AojlVo ^Via^..W\S A)\nVV) A^«nAeA Goo*p\aAvV umWa s**z^&cu{S 04 vkG. G>-HC k^ar\A^ dole.TA <*V ?.\7 - CooVs^portvtfA^sl"eA «A*h toVk fvv^Yian Pb^ Le^v^ "t> Atwla^ C«\Van ^\eA kis \e\Wr \o-Vk4- \S3 r^ Cour\ Coor^naW. CGe^vJ^\i>\$ a^V\e ^-~X\\e -Ac^ij"vT (Po\nV °-£ gccc^ One^ -0rN^Tc^a\ oduaV ecce ^ io ^iwii^ C^Wi cl^W A"Woa^ Oooaaaj Sr\e-C p^e7^SO r\ -VW. ce\\e^ ^ovA^jk^ A^ <\A- &£*-tc Vo cW,\V<2^£ ^e-Sacv o^ YWft/e -)o,s no &W*nS o^ surprise- oj- fC-G- ^uV\cjl- ^Wov^n ^ ScWU*/- oc eo^n o^ a\W^ Vo^°^° -(W^cA AfP^UanVs, 0$e/vn$ Goe£ fGpe^DtSO r "Vke. Tc\a\. G"A *s-f ce^. \o j^aAvn^ ^V^eSdUVW-S r^Vion"^ £> x^-oaa^s. A.".W.oaVv, CW ua Ajlt \ l o v-G A ceVv.es ^on an vnAiip^\; .$Ac\<\?e\\ sAoaAoP^s Ainan -formal pW^A"S Ac^fVeA k~< lAA^er^.See feVxicsA* \j fc^cvir *WW .^. "AV1,4 XO CV*n;0, oA-\^ ere AAi .Wit CWte JS4f2An 3-3-is-3eecO.'V}^U p. \^\-\ci3 • A\\ o-( VkG aAAM\ovik/ re\i«j G|> t>M ScJUMUr f(\ua\y^ C<^iG^ \joVi4J nQ^ ^cwipu u^W^ i9^3„^i^koA ~C\rA\nojoin^ VkeiV c-onoloWu ceoerjeA ;e"j^i or o\Wa)ljfc Ae- oWeA \f\vw\i© £.eec«L.v>o\.l pl(p4. :r„ *ke ctvWoAv>e-We ?WW{vA Soa^NA ceUA *to\ «i^\A ouAwAacMki enAA\^ -Ya4^\ Ae> s?ceA\en or t'm- /v>eA\^Je reVe^se -3:A£ * eA om\-oC- AWe-Afpea\ Vo uVA\2.£ 4<*\A cecjorA •XWWvck.wijauVA fi^&rA Cct^W^V^G loAaVeA oppoAuA^W -Vo pr«vs V>^\va IAs. £-colA\j OioWVicn QncA PAtVA V"e^TvvaY Mioic^Vion cWros on appeal. \aAu^a\A xvcrea\e ^V"^nV^Ao Corker reUase . As. n^AeA *nx,S%r\o" <-^en cWiA^ii^ c* cl^il^e WAte^ra- ceA^res e^o^eA in AeWAAv'n^ pmonons eU'3'A^ikf -for poodle ,4^ CouA e*- pWr\«A MnA Vv>e/) in sooa€ bcaaA -kn.seA aVkciu fcesda-Uon o£Ai$ &cW alle^Aions gaA \4*f\ izsuJis neuAiarA^ V^AcdAe VU £m3 cWh^oy A\A\nc*on keko^M «uvA AA^ebj enka/i(-£ eA^ikV\y-Cor earlier r-etepse aA -Wosg MaA to cm\A crec^ enV^VWnfcA A-o corker reW>se ._r-^ vAeA ^ov-Ma^e ^e^otpA 4oc cesXo — C poxA oovA^ con^A^en\.4rAA lX$- o^eo\ a^A AV«. ce^WA ©vA-cAArv^ - o^vA "^coa^OmA onAV-e ^Wks sen.Wic4< Ao^eocr G^\\-on ^ouV*> noV e^ca()£ co"m\ ^o k( orW o^ T?\A GouA \WmV AsWA as n result o4 a Aecuion okWA^A -f to^ *Ve Se^onA oAncV (A x^as G^Ao? Ap|*«l^:rAa\ <3S~?, A± Vke G-ouA k«\A A ^ucU c< uVclvaA^C? n W>e aa^/A^ »:5rA <^V OS*?. .ScA-i a$An$V c^tivj^rn/vxea-Vql <^lo/eo*S SuUa as icJhU\*r cxrc aA poAiv>A *AKe v£ QmA\s> O sWi^O SIS ^X^ Z\% C^A^a CxV i^7^).^Ta QvAalU , c, ^Vofcp pri- Son^ri , ore9^Ao("Y ko -klir^g ci ovoVsda ^rCo\WWA reUe^ ,re^o^sWAof VKeCoiArV GV^vc AVe. Co^A oC .se"A^ ki^n <-opi«s o^ cccorA^ A OAoAkar- £i<*W Vc^osAV onAo^AW^conA^WA^r mo,ml OaAVTU.TW (U^us^ ^ons ao\ acV^no^VeAseA.x^t prx»rt«r a Vie $eAaIAAml records ki ^o^aV\\ ^ece reo.Aou-lu m^Ae ^oaiUkJ^. Vo o\ken *\\G"eAVor tv\ooe\ar^ ceUeV olaA ce^uvre^ Gn oAer AxrecVag Ake cW\l Vo oro^AG VV\e xovk^/vxcAxon ve^u"VeA. "Oml Ov-sVucV G*>ujA A\s* *a* corpus u nA ^A ofpro- pciAe r^Af qao vu> sAnA <-*-A* rek^ce on 9ceU*r U^pUM.se^ G>^U$» S2S t*A qV3\=?, "\>»e VAA .S^A\Sec GrelWnvj rG^le G?S C3A a 1,31 v.SA^CirW1sJ ', CW\scn siTtsWon U2-F3A Wj^l Utfo C\V 1117) (A^ AAiajt Corson k^s^Ue^e^ VkAsucJU cec,^Avl6A\ £coa~, aAo^ -e ^caAAeA cxas^ cgUA onku seAiAC? or cc.Ao\c-kon vm\| b-G \n Vke A'aaeAncn cA Vke AppellaJbf ColatV »^ec^use C^\\oAiucuss AfP" 0(j&v)a^ Cc\e-t" ^dLStA^ t-r va^s. Vcxaos-hV on \n\s \4-fln A"A^A cWmi c^atftA ^ckMer -***VA */\*ce\^ enAoAC£ ek^kVi Vor *CcA*/AeA ceVense oaAaVws MW>eon. ir\\\recV eAee\ on Mne ^eVmiaoVutt oV ^oWAker CaVVxcan o\A senWxcG oc oO^Wn W<* <-<>AovA\on . Ace co^r.v^abL^ uaW iWW.^eCwH. vj TO^ TcaAS. 9\ga.^. 37 F3A IW*,U* CsMnOrVWjC^ec^a^ a Suc cess Vm\ ,wA^>*>uxA nnerekj eAxoAce Av'3'\V^ 4or ocmWAeA release oaA AkusvAn.s 'xnAxrecV e^feJcs, on A\sjl AAer^AA^n e>V ^Wa^qtc\ cWmaA toAAal^ recuse (*fcro\e/'n^e ?s^ Circ^A ke\<^ AWA VkiL ^xAxavxW k«Akc^(}V\\ o S\W C_WiAj A^ ^A\G a\ooxML rvxjulAlQ^G "ftf^xC^cA opinions VoAain. AsvjoeAca HW«c\Cu anAVVe gelo^ cy^wc/U "r^n^A \1a\tA Aevi"°' ^vjinMn oaA OX.GiroA FcAqa*( Ap<*U«fc| Go^As, m^ diiem CalWs conWkoo MnAk^ \M-v1a Ay^AAN^VcX^Miaret-o5niia^.uAA«rSl9\S U AAeAiWious ,^eJL.Aec\A W4K.GV &VX111 G:rCAk*A^A vvuMll no\ Ae - nn^oOSVtr^fc^ VhCAoA'A'kj ok vA i^iVo"^dnrK^tx^tt^S^ VdWVlcA ^bAk 0>m*e \nWnjs tAsW^ CouA Gou\A W pcArsu^A "^19*3 bee^cue. Vk*. pWAx(-f A\Anfc\ 3eeNG reVcase^ As, ncAeA \n "E"1 /3<^cc< ,VU> A^re^e G*uA moAe cW AkA ^cA(fxarA^ ,a prober-for ?r<*p*c" v^uacVv* ceUA^Ul aoAacuv- .Sarxkf xoAfjkj^ MoLmv/AikiVj oV preAjiox^ loss cA ^oAAAjl creaks G/xA So cacxa| pco^JLrl^ beVro^A vaaW ^\W,;x^xAA^uA«bx4 4A A'hG PWaVK x\n uEA^wAs" VkfiL \A»aaAWg ceYAAAWi Sz&te VkA rV)CuykQi>G on ArAxTecV xVi^A" °o Vke x'AAvkf A V\^eono\cVxon -3eG_°<"eA \ an u>S\?3AaAA* OnWU eW<%nS in k ^WS^A t^fkinW <^e- Axon VKe u^uoo^kkAkAo.l A^\\e Ad«xy q/,A ^absWi- VaA ceWAAA oAWn^ qJJtorAeA q on^Wi^I o^eaL See C£vj0\A ^-vAn" aV vX *S3> -^sCp qaA " Tft\M A p. SxT>-SSl\ *AA^Ake ceUef cA4|\ n vj oA^on usi.cV Q4.3. iasM CX.OOSJ, ~\>£ ^fe^ Co^A xA <^oo\Cr xj fXAC Ooaa«V\ i\\% UuS. S3^ tV17*0 A^aYes ciiiPsr AkA I \W!> reviaias c^<*\AdU.Vqc ^ca^A^ai d\aiU*$w xAoere s,vaculss \r\Ake q,cV\^a cot>u\A rxtA ^ecjLssojA^ j^\\ vWie^cXe o\- so-"vQ-T reUase toe W* pcvAon*r AAVcVG^apm ^peutesVkA a pri*- ^ofM^ nA cwvw AW ^..An^ C^uA*^$^-*-^*A^ ta4*.0>»A A^A^caiifor DAW A" -^n i"VAl cel««e"^or^ cAoxVr Aoh ^ ^kon, A o^vu aV oaoA r>e^ eU^k, cw>«-0 , ^O^Oa A r^oA -AW sp*eA c^nixA^akonS cA qne^ parole aipkcA00o Ssjicct^ tor ^roVxAion a^oas A n/M&V ^ f\fl^ parol-ek*"v\j> AAx'cln okxo ?aAe co-vAxovAes cv^/m A<*A A^trAxon ,AecW Vo xWWn Ax^ qx-x^oa W*a.) <2>e^cu5,e G G VO cvxqnqlo^oux, CjoA^NLt , ^ iUL ^xAVAAs V\ve_ vo-or^, " ^eAwfc" Ao ceW- f\A Vx> pr\son procedure* tWAVo sAoAoAx\rG ^W*«A<%Wvs OS-\o A\e V^ajMa o^ coA'ne^eAV-^TAciV 1X4^ LAkno^ ^Ax"A \> G\ose s^o ui 7^ ,~7S*| o.l t xoo4) CTKe incaruro^on ^A rAaAW^ oaA.*t Ntect A \k«- xncorcarAlon oAwA ksAkG oc\$inA ^Mo"e-A oV c-onvnckvvA A crUinq\ ,yaA$Ax-*AV o^en*r An V^ convrtcAnoo onb ^enW>U -See e.£. FeA-i. Conn. 9, 3XCVAC0 C^ crxVMna\ j>uA,J -47 , HAAke A "esVA -ybe.v**- V\A*k c pjo^ec-iVon 00 Ake^u^rveA A cyAV.cCjtr AA vVlxo-tn. G^vWx's c-on\eA^n U Moa\ kis cJU;*^ waA^t $\9tl are A-orecpK^Ae A«p\Ak j^Ke <^W^AA vA ^3o\tt v McDonnell,sopr^ j:^ ,'c\ec|C"JjinpMt^CouA e^reA^ A'Ao^msUA ^o^vA l/x<^n"A 10*« cK^il«AfeA vu erc^iwr€ \o^ AxvOn vke \noA^ coas A-e^e^ ^oA k"G Cre Avk »° u;o^" iAAATn- ^vi&kablc tcooA VKe xp.S\qa\ co -^oulJ esVAAsk XN qa \ueVAAM cA^hVa for e^k or ion(yxj?Ai A". i-ae liecK £>a^AH^r,let a\$o ^A^«rAA',SL»pfe, oA S20Ui.«*V oqr,^ Oe- -^eccxcxo Vo \AoctV\^vV^ oV Vkje y-*A$ «^ ^aV^ or Hp^Mxb/n«A\i*vvpoieA^J0So VAAA"koo^ Vl\V€CVL.//r\i OOAS\i\eA ^vMAoMoa^ COii^i pOTrrviVVr^ po'lSon^ Vo W on cA^rvAcAu-e <^ec AOmWwvxiA SMOU.S> aV "7r4 ', i^ji aKo JST Aq\ 1% 4(ce — ^ecVxo^ xv \Ve A^\sV«V.en oie^o VbA \WcVl &pp\ies CAW$oric«illvyVo o|| WAa "vAeeA Ae S^pra^jG Gjo\atV\a«^s ce^eokA^ pv/"AW pcbooA {o \0rxf\3 \ \^%-S ctcVxoni cJk«l\eAj\rx^ Vko e ^a) V^as \A-Alne VoAoA <^ne ,an ifx,rwAe U^sAV \3 A^A"-eA as A^mdWs -tor kq^i'ag no basA iv\ Woo ovAncV buV no -foA KeoWnj is Ae\A , VCd CouxVs reoico -Cocuss^s on ucUeVUer Akc i/vn«dtA («uu>.*Akctf an a"uQ^e fcx»si* "m U^.^ Cc^V -to* S003A cAx^TKe i^u* o^ A*- AW cicWnn Uqs on arjuaUji beA, i (f) U«oua teja\ tu«Aon A^A vk re- relief oa± onuses oC « ^ se.VoM.-V +ko^!v, i_ j * • P rae reU.v.^s^V -, "„ A Aa "" ^°~ Af^clWVi o^«a^5 &vAeV 9^jG21o^so "2^-(e7. V\Aa\\^4k\S, Lovj\ \'c \o ko^V OiWvS pWAln^. Vo WsS &V«>AjeA sV AVnqa Vofrv>aV pWcAxn^s AcAWk W{ W*o^a/S r\ee vWoes ^/o4 a£ *V 4Xo / cvxA a cAairv> j;kouVk a*r A in^«*0U,-Gor « oejl(j^» eA anko <^>a~ / ^ VWA C^iAoO k^A AA^e no ^lle3Ax^o AMaM:Ws o^-WmIo Vke l,WkA ^. ^ 0q jfVe TeiCv-x>A GWVxS ACV- AaA as a cevu\ A^«/eo£ AlN*re uias a, oV oaw ar $u AJl* \oa\s Wui xA \avJ or tacV ko xos^esV oa^ moi^tr o xr SdMlWs oV-kual \Vi^Aikf VocAKi^Va^ Ca~^> CkiWus pltaA^A by C^.|ko0 See CxVVJoU p. 1U?^aA\70. V\ow>eoer, CAlUns eonUAvi vs. Ak«V oV"T*xrr<>A GouA-ty/ " kiA ^-o^a^ca U**0 £\c^£ L~*o cW\W ctv, pi«A i^AV\§vMsAiokKoW »a M-C E\jk+k anA A/tA-tfn, A**a^«A GorxToUnVs.S^e C^.vjol.l "W aA p. ask-^r oa<^ "^"qV p.sa|- S3 0 „Ap\*'AkC( nrxa^ s^ o, ^vj l^S o,^ ^voernoA^A e^U,ees -in aWp O^uol cc^Ae. orf ««*? a.A Go^akes"A^x(i<.^nr4^ u^W*A „A «^A 4^ A^e\UVi O^ e^er oG^alASo 0£-Q\exAA one-sAx^ an^>\ker ^o^ (A ^WA'u\g an acV\on qjaiasVAke enAxV-j °^ wWkVj A^e Atuax a^eA \3 e"o^eA, ^eeTexQS, A. cxaA CA On\s), v» ¥L.oie$lu X33S^3A%3S, %H4 GTW*ooT). T0 a &u\V c\o.cxxa^\ a^ ossein YnkxS u,eA A&cVs Vke Ae^enses Ao V\akxV\kj AVA ^°>i ^e r<*\seA , See TkcACson u AxnA\; "x s\AiXAM^,50O CT^AA).-3A an vaAAxAmA \$> SxAeA \n k\-S cVkuA CapociVcj, Ake employee m^ rq^e oa^ cUC«/is£ VkA toou\A be <*Mm\ rAeA cecocV^.To keuklizeAwi per-fte- Vin^ Ate Appeal tor CoAkoA A^WpkA AA.u/A £ca/?Vno Vke iowvil. e(L.Vo\.\ v,^1k"A p.3.7MU-7C OaA "Trti" A 0.539-s-VO , FV pr-apa^kp Vke cecepA scWUr- vA3qj p^'A q .s en^ra^p-fte o-t o^n^Vic&gU 8 3;OOO.0Q •Ccorv\Vk5 3«A noaVleS C\«. oW^xn xo^ck^ cekev>u^A a \xvs^»s^ xh\( zr\«„s GTc^A^p. Te"KoAq. 2.003) . 3T^ \> t>Ak Ake ^VMa Oa^ AyfAAiA A"ci Go-"VwA^ A\0\ i>re (aAvsV<\^uUW^oIc as> V C\cxOfv\s ,i\e Cru^ c>^ CA\kA<; c^Vc^ Lau) CV^xaas a^vfxA ScKAUr ^vl \'o^\y^ acVs c"lor <^vA ^AVrooA-\ oaA ^oevv n"W" VkG VcxaV xa ^vAeAon eAAeA on s-^0-04. ^or e^o"l^ ^ckn\^ A\A >\^e\\A o^a^ G^eV 9«^e asA&C> ' VNoV i^c"are onA t\\e AW \nc^~vp\Ae O^aporVA * respecWh .*"• G n ^\Mn A?<>€4l«fc* to«/i- S-e\ fWa. A\Ur^ on or a^u\ HA-or. S^tfcOoU *V koc Vte AlUjeA VaVAvkj U ^iWi t ^ U-3-04 a^b \\- oe\\ as. Vke VoeV AlnA &c1a\\\*/- nncAe q mAe- c\aA AA\sr<^pfe"^VcvVxOn -Vo Ga\Von °n or a"\ 4A-os\ Ykese al^sAons qs cAl^geA \aWovxa a^ £\«V(VxaA.c AjIaAAa A^JLA^eA Co^pWnA ^-onkr^n-S AkA Gq\\on k^s c, M C^\Un anA kor VaAaj Vo AA<,te ceasoAQ^oU f^uirxes aWV A^eWcvxX 0^ir\s arxet x?= >u V«. ex/xAenuL concerns. VKicru^o^ CqVkA c^o^WaVs kaxje <\\^°*jS vaaAvsqAc^I^ p-erV^vrtcA Vo ^UaAUrs ^c^fAoo". or Ake cecorA- C«\kn kns a"s AcesxeA>M>^'' cxaA A a. Co^vpleie r-apor- V*A ceoorA oA CaWoA ce^vA4_A ^ ^\S^*)iAHM3,MMxj» CT"e<.CiXi.A<»(>. Coc^ui cW\A \ e .oAare nVeA 31a Qv s\wW . A An * S.O^Qo P VAf^rA txV -G^\V>aS ^V ^\ ^™ ConWiV^nAxnA ^ck.ll^oQtS ivMi^Nnere^ ^ Wi .Ax^al ca^c^ A^ SaF^ WV Opmro-nS A?\A\oA-s o^cava^ (Ar^eQ p"e 21o" r mAreXcs x;^«c*> 5C3^u.s.U\nlJ kt*Mr ^ QtV u^Wrt (or non^u^l) CAa ce«\x\^ loe itUr" \»M4ka«iW€ A Ak£ o,cA <-G-keW,^ Ais a, -twxc-Vion nor^al)^ per-Cm-/we Ab^ a ^Aje "in AU_ Cjdo/A roo^, S-te rvuT-eles Sox u.s aV *1 / ns conVrasVeA Xcoaa ^Vlner "•AiwiVuAcAv-e, ^iA rV coi\\ cex>\£^o AkeAxiA GouAs cekapl Vo a^oA CowA^el \n a cXxjA CQ^e Vor akuse o£ Ax^oreVon .-See Cnkson xT\b\WrA 10X ^v^iA^i^n'l Tec^tfo^AteToxaV GsuaN; akuses A-s AucreAion ^AeA iV rea XA ",1)7 CT€1"sJ0jxa AAe/^AS ^kcAkor Ako^e Uan akui-t A Avsc uA^>Ml Aect^£ AeWw We VAV Co^/A acV^A ^o\M^-ou\ reW^u Vs oa^ J^iAks cxAes gaA mAuoVs .sucAa VkA x\;4 acV U3 s_r ^ Co1(1/u «^r~? wU ^V}, "X. GTev.App. VUv^Un £\ an YnAx^enV cc\^fxai AA>/A cJo«-v\je(l -Ma *3\ S.cV iSV?, JS/r-XOUcilJj^ •XVxAeaA ,»-o\Ak onL c U l'A\"A \n s>otvN€Ave*<-«.p~ VoaaA c&.ses^ ^V>qre m\ve p^Wxe oa^ ocU^M vnWeA-s aV s.V^\^e ^G S^.cV\A\aA- Vke ot^/vx\A\s\rdVion A ^uAc* m^ WesV W ser\r^A b^ a^poxnVng a. \cu-o-f3T Vo c&pcesenV oa ^'nAx^A cxA iA3oa\ ,S-e^ TravelKs jx".Go-^ AACoyfiexA *?xsi"A S^-o, sr94 Ore* .i97(J .^ s>uOa ^ C^se ,AV»ereVS O.. pr*_Sx>—^V\an A\a AU«rA C^A'Wn Ake oppiAAk| Vo A^lta^e k\s ta^s o <^*a\WWs cWAi 00 cyf*.al AA>A Cc*|kj/i ^)qs preclude Atroon r oiasAj AunAo Vke \a\VA oppeA cWcV-o VkG lvmssi&o o^ W-l prekkl V\eankj recorAs /v>«^on«\'iu/i^ 4" dai/ns Aee c n t«-"r^e^ °^ o^koCA^-Appl AaiU w»"H oA-ecA A>AU recocA c^A /-c^ ^r oa «UvA Q-nA^keA^WW" wVll-f"i ^ 34 v^CeK3j AaA toACjL-vVe. reVeoa^V reaorAs are o>n&o*& Vd We, U>A OaA \C f^V"k^ V,M We uD^iC^n^ C^urV * ^° AxH A ,A p ^oreSonecDA- cVmsM .ia^A^A^k^ ^vs^A^sa"""P"^'^g vA^Ai^puJC-eA -^oiA^Ace oonkr^xs Vtere are recorAs ^VAkq^qre ^ces- <,ar^f k>r We. ap^q\ cesol^V^ -A«G 3cJnllcA /Akr A^fci'A "7-JO-U *CP^lAA Aff£\\A's O^Jo^ ^cxe^ poje SOASc) ' ^"V A e-X^ Q/N^ W sx."Tk\i XsS r»A Ax^QoixW-^. W<^ouus-e c <*aVqa xn A\.s \ \<^3 co^- p\o.A ^\A nA s«-eVL o\ nevo VvaUjxA G^aWi \s euA/ic s^7F X£ a A- us? CGoaJ^V nAxnj eJneuaA^ Aoes a oV Qi^toCanx| rekev tc o^n kis i^Vence \n ^kis acA-Un , nor Aoes ke gu\c AWts GooA orW ki^x ceAec^eA too a^ Coo"^A or /v\-oAxk{ / \A Oa^ Gii^ecA , AVe ooa^Voa^ o4 Co/AxA"y -Cke Goo^\ ^«a\ oa VoSWkj? Vke oaU| pouiVA* e^A -*kk ackon *W$VA-We. t>n eVx.uarllA cu^Akn^A-^i^teAV»A j\xr ke Can okVcun Ate -Wawripks Vo ap^eA ;oaA At>u\a kv^ o-fpe^l be. jucctssttli ke unwiA esco-pt oon- ^ag^i6aV / oa Ate 3Vo3ae senWxce. i4oo>eo*r/ kx^>oM\A noV Ao^ob^ ocA Cv*a- V^aa^ S73f 3AX*4|XX4 tSAlnCif JOOlKtouA aAin$ AVWjo ^k ul^<^ c\ oqV o^ L^\s \S A> oAcu)n ewA ceoU~a oV kxs eoAouAxon. A* ^ QC~ V^cutl^ aAacG^ Vke. SW^A Wwrt Vo c^pl^ ^v-W> Vke Ay«nq de- clV\on as xAiV«/iLes" ©^vkecase oaA AeW^Vxe AeVk^r Ate Vrxal Co^V k<*& nno reqvoAc*\cLe aUerAoAivrG kA Vo <3^o\aV couas^I " e^uipkoAQl cucA^uvoVo^oes A k^ i«.A-iAvk^n Care a^h UAuiu«|. 5^e C"^n ton. 5^3^ «tV7H. Gcyoa<^ A*A Ate Te unse\_^:i <*V-?i3.r>ve CouxrV coenA ©n Vo nAefm skoA ,U Is easier V> AeWArxe A^Ais cxAe*- Ge^oAal 4Wx pcon«*K-G a^ornl pco^kkon on xJinAAo3u^ b* eKc^n , on Ake xxnAup^€^ facVs o£ Ate UsVaA Case -Vke «*«pkoncA on n -Ccoaa e^Ux^V^ VxVt^nj anA prajecAVx.j'kvS GW'ax^ eTKM^ A^\S cvvji\ atfcon ^>as cxA a"joj-^l A all retao^UW^Gu* AoVkeVacV aAaA^Vqa C^\k>n tey-es Ws pi^cliAro^c A^Aic^kon^ a-s p>reicrikeA c^A^r^ C^vAur, »a ao^u^W qaA aoA&xseA A<^te-AV-AiUakke CqVkm CAAaoV c^vtftAVr 9. S.V^3^ ^oklVe xaaW Vke Xrv-tU^ce oVAtet WaAc^ UsV A pce^cnkeA vxneAx^kons \V\ck,AiOJi ftu9*w$on .OiAx^k^r^Ae ,4AopAM .Aj^cVp^lin-ey Z_xs^o^o\ , fwecK^ke (. po^raAoU exy\b \-l p-isO'^l. Pc^ia^A C^xVntco^vx nno^VaWoJ VkisGioilAcAi^noVA oxuMAukonA C"porkAO oaA^oa e^uiU>U> o^*/^ QtWr.-CVse^VxipJL«i eui\ e AA^es cjUaT A4M uWi ^a^aWI aVA pW/stc« I ax.sAA¥\e$ p\aceAk^ A An UAreaiOAckxe Au^ycAtegecyvA prek\<- e ui Vo oC^ Vke CouaV \o A"o\Vx\ GoaAsekOuA Aed^ia^i ooAkis \iWxk-A v^-cor^ Aoei a A tA froxATje / prtcVAe VVve G>uaV G"tV -(ro^ AoJao so A IcViJ"- .rwxA^ vV Vo be op^ro^r\^ ). AVeVk^V c^o^aaV erreA o^Avj7o\«^A v\^ AuV-| Aro eAxure Jv"tAAW ^a^\oa\ cAse «-oqm\A ce^vtuk V^\^j aAo^janpl Ap^UCs Ope/uVxj Qc^eV pa3e 3So-C ^ A mWe \>A^*AAAte"Myx\V cx^WoaVoaA o€Wa*A* *u*a ^o, iee 9AUc uk^ CWa i; CoW 75q so^A \i\,m CT^lwJ^ **ms- Cx^M \\V0A^ ^\ WA }(a. AcvcA Goua\ cAcmscs A-S AucreVon onV^( If Ate inrA^ kaAeoAe-iCeAo-afY \oarfe^VcoAn pcGseAknj Wsc/u^J, ;x-C Anis couaV AVc^s V\>e An A Co^As o^Vs^eA \AAke o ^ poVnV o^ errors caXseA WraVU ^sVaiVu Vke *CacV AteV C«\W> coas e-f- iecW\4 WneA omV oV CovA oaA Wk$cA» •Vteg*ieoaocje- Co^e.VoVKe \VsO)A- Vcovjerklole -QaAs esWk\ls\A Ake ScJk\\UA ^ACo^PeW\ r^orViA^ pt^c— Aas cv\A "V\a\ xr, -* ni e^ IJX>^c^cki>e (UUef (U^A oaWs. **m3 cWW WAoVte^A^orAWf c^Ae*cftpk-0rfi(cJr- Cu^A^cJ^ *A Ate (asVoA caue a^Ate Co^e\e -f^arCo^ ^ *^Wx UC c^xVoAkas no oxA>er q" r^e^ qVU^-avW, iV A u^ptf^ Cc^xVoax GDAiktetex^l O^kk uxJire xjici\qVeA* S,VaAAcxrAoV OLftoyeyJ TKe CcqaV or cetxsa\A a pex/A«r,oA \oxuAckao xvoovAUn -HvG VcxA c^xxn\\ SomaA AixceV^i aAo/c^afPec\ (CeoU"rj"""Vs acMon ^ 'UoAeA Vo t^eskon Aka\ We\& enkVie Ao cfxii'l ^n^uAckye-ceke^ onkii I X QA/£'A*itAi °^A AC"cwA \'a s^p°rA-tk«re&G sjuece. UA\ p.3^S- ^\3.A>.e A^ial Ge>^\ -ecce^ b^f 4-£ CavWt iViUAcku-e ce.\{e-C b^f or^-i s\^neA on s'-a5-'S'cv\^ o*x hi, EIJM- <^ M/n*. A-^e^ C^A^ " v„u ^ ^ J \W_ ^wnsV^Wt <^\WM procure- a*±M^L onJoiV^ AtWu o^ iuUd i. | ^W c*J ceU^ * ^wrUjto ftfutfu ^x\V lie oa TO ^dr A te Ue«AiiA$ <2>o^rA Vowa^> Vx\aa ^uAfy OaA "^pelA&cAtesa/Tve* Se^ca^voU *v es wvAarA&jj Voaa3 lA^AitTAke so^e seVo^ ^acVs U aoV AU^AVx>G,-\kc ^\^-e A«=kck Ak^V e^c- nOraxc A^*xaQjeS ^ackj be c\o a" an«^i A^kA 4 ceiweAv Aki^i \^ v"eau«Jtf ^ Vo^ e->t^>-pl^ Ate 3^n?r sc A Avv^A^vx ^a Ak'xs cVccu^j^rQAc^j.^roVVe^cxsA^ case-We iA^A nq( WAs^se* cA^ot Ccoj^aU 6o«illn>n VfU i^i^ u^i^*? Gxee \^asi"CTr^Aep.3^An- V-ooiO V^tl AOpeVX^AxAJ AAkfVo oAaio pOi\'COAo\ckor)Vxpke^S Oaop^AS ce~ UeV XS VaAoC Aro ooaax^T A $< u.^e e Vco-^ *we Pitv^ cWA Vo £ile n iuccessk* &cjyA cooxV A Oa^ K^aA- See.CO_.aoVA "Vtk" eA cvA^>/or o_So1^A^joo3j;^5;f^1f2_oSWtp Zo-?J->3AJ". "?33^35^ GTe^ Atf>. SoAAnWnft 46cV?) .l-k>u>eje/" w^ Apfei|Jb? cwitel 8a/f^ A\ferA c_©nsuv\efe o^iVt^ SckxlUr, sdM)i*r rvnxVeA A\k>rA c^ACajAoa o ^X^ f:U X^7/3oX CSAt^Clr mo), QcWA ^vgAsAcVArt/VKc FiCVW Circa'A re"ue^ Ak^V a ^Vtffcje ct>u\^ oiol^dcp iue_ practss A iV s.tAkAaAkGllLY AeWe«^AVe op^dte proass \\ orooiAe^-forccAoitieA Co^iAai AeUAAaAks ,AUoS*jl AA^Aku xiA^o^ ?S1"^ ifopn Cz^arl??0(^iA ^A V, ^e>,k^ a Sioan Ae" coa^Ues, *. ^ pr^uss x;,0Wkxon ^u^cxo- teAAkAMne anA^cA ^a^e^rt ^ VooAi, in «^ter o^ayo Mo7u.L6f4is Apfe\\As Opo^Aj GiSeV ^ajje_jo0£s0 '" qaas&<*\\h oppVcalole „"2. ^oJeA o^xe\lA_5 AeVo^s oV *o-to^e e)fkr- Ake° vn We JOvaMa A^j/iktA CAv4oa kas plx\ pu^oje o4- \^t^cAsx>e re- UeX \s Vo WA XAiron^&t^ acVs VkA are VkpecAe^eA or Oa We coo^sJto% qcaonA- A&WneAj c<*\ter Ak^A k^ 3ro\\ ccke^ <=*ScmasV p^A aoki»!Ae iajayi^s or Vo pceo<2nVAte. aCnnAM^\on A «-Oconjs fxA tAoM^enVlw AteeAeneA J.SfleTeTca^ lAAAV> Oxre^kto. Coua.u SeW» fecnta fWxnc o3A tMl^sS cver*A?p. A"a 4O03J .MStteu^h iV\v, iAnA\spuAeA AwA ^ ojron^l ac\ Vy*s occujreA »A AVe paA.(ojue.Vo Vte ^cAavA beo=aAse SctUtar -ftleo oaiVwJeguwte fecocA*. CqAten coqs nA a^VocV AG\pr^vxe CjouA kas-oltooieA -s^As g^oiAsV y^akJi AkuAs V^r oros^A^e \A\uncW *e\