Damian, Gilbert Santos ( 2015 )

Cause No. 15 305-C
Gilbert S. Damian Th~ cJB,e District::'Court
§ cument contains some
TDCJ-ID 3 382329, §\ pages ~hat are of poor quality
§' at ~he time_ nf im.:anill::ili!:\1
v. §
Walker LOUh~v0e``·
Walker County Distr~ct Clerk: §
In Her Official Capacity, § 278Th Judicial District
§
:§ RECEIVED IN
§ COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
A. RLAINTIFF"S ORIGINAL APR..ICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS
MAR 06 2015
TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SAID COURT:
COMES NOW, Gilbert Damian,Relator,pro se in the above-style and numbered cause Ab~1\cm>m,``
this original Application For Writ Of Mandamus,pursaunt to Article 11 .07 Sectiopn 3(c) of the Texas
Code of Criminal Procedure,and would show the Court the following:
B. RELATOR I.
1 .01 Gilbert Damian,TDCJ#382329 is an offender incarcerated in the Texas Department of Criminal Justice
and is appearing pro se, who can be located~a:t Polunsky Unit, 3872 FM 350 South, Polk County, Texas 77351
1 .02 Relator has exhausted his remedies and has no other adequate remedy at law.
1 .03 The act sought to be comp-lelled is ministerial not discretionary in nature.TCCP Art. 11 .07
Section 3(c) requires Respondent to immediately transmit to The Court Criminal Appeals a copy ~f
the application for writ of habeas corpus,any answers filed,and a certificate reciting the date
upon which that finding was made,if the convicting court decides that there are no issues to be
resolved.No copy of the application for writ of habeas corpus,any answers filed,and a certificate
'
reciting the date upon which that finding was made have been transmitted to The Court Criminal
Appeals. Had such documents been•-; transmitted to the Court Criminal Appeals by Respondent as re-
quired by statute,relator would have recieved notice from The Court Criminal Appeals.
C RESPONDENT II.
2.01 respondent,Gilbert Damian,in her/his capacity as District Clerk of Walker county,Texas has
a ministerial duty to recieve and file all papers in a crinminal proceeding,and perform all other
duties imposed on the clerk by law pursuant to TCCP Art. 2.21 ,and is responsible under TCCP 11.07
1
Sec. 3(c) to immedeiately transmit to The Court of Criminal Appeals a copy of the
9Pplication for writ of habeas corpus,any answers filed,and a certificate reciting the date upon
'
which that finding was made if the convicting court decided that there are no issues to be resolved.
The District Clerk,Walker County may be be served at her/his ;~place of business at Walker County,
Huntsville,Texas 77342.
III.
D. VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 11.07 OF THE TEXAS CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
3.01 The Responde4nt violated Article 11 .07 section 3(c) of the Texas Code of Criminal Precedure
by failing to provided a copy of the application for writ of habeas corpus,any answers filed and a
certificate reciting the date upon which thattfinding was made to the Court of Criminal Appeals
within the time presribed by law and with~n a reasonable time from the date on which the documents
were requested to be transmitted.
3.02 requests for the transmittal of the application for writ of habeas corpus,any answers filed,
and a certificate reciting the date upon which that finding was made were made by Relator to District
Clerk,Walker County, letters dated August 19,2009 State's Motion to Designate Issues and a Proposed
Order Designating Issues purauant to Article 11 .07 Section 3(c) of the\! Code of Criminal Procedure
True and accurate copies of the above Document s are attached hereto as Exhibits"A"i through 11 811
and are incorporated by reference herein for all purposes.
'B.03 To date Relator has recieved no response from Rependent regardingsRelator's request for
transmittal of a copy of the application for writ of habeas corpus,any anwers filed and a certificate
reciting the date upon which that finding was made to the Court of Criminal Appeals.
3.04 As is clear from Relator's letters,Relator has repeatedly put Respondent on notice that Relator
seeks the transmittal of a copy of the application for a writ of habeas corpus,any answers filed,and
a certificate reciting the date upon which that finding was made to the Court of Criminal Appeals
and that such records are required by The Court of Criminal Appeals to act on Relator's writ of habeas
corpus.Relator has gone well beyond any requirement or obligationsim~ose8upon him by The Texas Code
of Criminal Procedure.In contrast to Relator's effort'.'lRespondent has wholly failed to comply with
the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure,Article 11.07 Section 3(c),is acting in bad faith,and has also
2
fai£: aJifEJrd Relator the prfessional and cOTIIT[)n courtesy of any written responses to his correspondence
7
and requests.
3 •05 Article 11 •07 Section 3(c) clearly states that " [9;;];f the convicting court decides that there:
are no such issues,the clerk shall immediately transmit [emphasis added] to the Court of Crimininal
Appeals a copy of the the application any answers filed and a certificate reciting the date upon~which
that finding was made.Failure of the court to act within the allowed 20 days shall constitute such a
finding."Texas Code of Criminal Procedure Article 11.07 Sec. 3(c). Respondent is in violation of this
procedure,nministerial duties,and thus the laws of this state.
IV.
D. PRAYER FOR RELIEF
WHEREFORE,PREMISES CONSIDERED Relator,Gilbert Damian,pro se,respectfully request a finding that the
Respondent did not transmit documents to the Court od Criminal Appeals within a reasonable time after
the date they were requested and that Relator brought this litigation in good faith and has substantially
prevailed.Relator prays for an Order directing Respondent to trnasmit copy of the application for writ
of habeas corpus,any answers filed and certificate reciting the date upon which that finding was made
to the Court of Criminal Appeals as directed in Artic:!.e·;11 .07 Section 3(c) of the Texas Code of
Criminal Procedure ahd as requested in Relator's letters (Exhibits"A" th4gh 11 8 11 ) .
i ..,- II
Res 'J~8tfuHy;Swbmitted,
8 ``~-------------~
L/
3
THE STATE OF TEXAS ·; §
§
COUNTY OF POLI£~-~
'RELATOR
_)
F.CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that a true copy of the above APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS was served on February
/
25,2rn5 by placing a copy in the U.S. Mail addressed To:
on this the day of February 2rn 5.
Court of Criminal Appeals
P.O. Box 12308
State Capital of Texas
Austin,Texas 78711*2308*USA
4
CAUSE NO :11 5305C
·----
Gilbert Damian § IN THE 27BTH JUDICIAL
TDCJ-ID #382329 §
§
§
v. § DISTRICT COURT OF
§
UNKNOWN COUNTY DISTRICT CLERK, WALKER COUNTV,TEXAS
§
IN HER OFFICIAL CAPACITY, §
RESPONDENT. §
§
ORDER
On this day,came to be heard the foregoing Relator's application for writ of Mandamus and it
appears to the Court that the same should be:
o~;~ GRANTED
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED THAT the District Clerk shall immediately transmit to the Court of
Criminal Appeals a copy of the application for writ of habeas corpus,any answers filed and
a certificate reciting the date upon which trnsmittal was made.
SIGNED on this the __day of ______,,_20_ _•
PRESIDING JUDGE
5
"EXHIBIT A &8"
THIS TIME IS CONSECUTIVE
On l:.lte l,__'f~/.day of x``~)---• 19_3_~ Lll<:' above refer.8tiC'?r:l CclJ.I!=:"' ~·lilS
called l:.o !:rial. The parl:.ies appeared .:I!> fr)llow?: !:.)1e Sl:.ai.,e arpear<:>d
by i~_'s Speci<~l Prosecul:or, and U1'=' defenr:iant ~_:_(_~-t'~f:.__@~.~_~-~-----'
1
,, r £' e.:tr ed in person w i I: h his a I:!: or 11 ey of r ,..<:or d IZ_./t·_;_e.t..l/._(_ ___ --~C-~.·.c_4.,..:Q_____ .
1\olh parl:.ies announced ready for trial, at;rl !:.l1L~e!..._!~-~-~-.,;...--b_uL~-LLJ!.£!::.:::.::::- c omrni t 1:. t:?.d on 2~--/-~_/_J__ ___ , 19 Iff:,
·and that he be punished by confinement in Ute Te>cas Depifrt.ment 0f
r.>,rrer:-:tions for a term of _d_/_2_"'_ _____ -__ ____ (_~ years, and that sur.-h
! " tt li s l1 me 11 t. be c a r r i e d i n I: o ex e c u t i on i 11 t· l1 e ma n n "r p r e. s c r i bed by J. i1 w .
Jt is further ORDERED by l:he Courl:. that lhe ,Judgrnent and Sen!:enr:-:e 111
l:his cause shall began to run after l:he S0ntence of la\o.' in cause
no. _j_~_/_/_L_:--- __ . received on I: he _j{/_(.__ day of .Q~_c;_f-:::.i~---. 191__2_, i 11
!.II'.? .2...J.cd-D1 s t r 1 c t Court of g_l.__c_~..-LJ:_i&. _____ C oun t.y , 1 e>{a s I for t. he
__
0 f fens e of /l~.c_t:3_~_f_~__ !Z;,._,;``_jf.__ ~_~_L c?__._ .. · for wI 1 .i. c h I: h '?. de f e nrl.:t 11 I:
received t``"-W~!:._<'!:D years, has ceased h) oper<~te.
The Defendant is hereby remanded in jail until l:lte dir·ections of l:.ltis
s etd: enc e can be obeyed.
'24--.
·-·-······
_ _.:____
'PF:SIIH J ----·--------·-·-------
- . I
'·--
I f ' ,.;.
.
o. /.
STATE OF TEXAS IN HIE D I STG I CT COUrn or
*
''~"'
v~. w~ /;{c...- COUNTY~ IEXAS
l_:l_f:._·TH ~IUDICIAL OI.STRICT
*
J1JO(,?Et·1ENT_ f'NQ ``NT~!J1;s Qbl. F·Lsfl QF
GUILTY CJR bi_OLO ~ONT_EN].~Bs ~.sF DR~ COURT
W~l VIER OF JURI TRIM.•
,_ll.IDGE
rRESIDING: .£.:::_"'::!.//'-"':._ _ _/? r-V.r..!_ _________ _
l\ TTORNEY FOR l\TTORt-JEY FOR
STATE : .;:::_.-, ~.:::..lf__ Afi::::_.:!_q_~------- DE FE t~ DA IH : _.L-;_.f.L.z..~_f._d{__ _a(:_~. e ~ L__
OfFENSE
COt~V I CTED Of: ./1.~-JL-0'-"-'~cL____.d_-LL.EF..!.-:_(-:!__o~:_ ___ A __ 0.c_£_(_'3:._1:_!_::::_L___ {) ;;{'" ·-:::_
[JE(_:;REE Of OFFENSE: __ J.::::-L ___ Dl\TE OffENSE COf1t-1ITTED:_Z:_IT _ _Lj_ I 7:?/-__
<_:!11\RGIHG II~STRUt·1ENT: l£:!12l~It11tii FLEl\: . g1!l1Ii
f'L.El\ TO EN!ll\IKEt-lENT fli-H>HlGS Ot·l
r l\ Rl\GRA Pf-1 C. S) : 'r{6l VE_Q F.t~rll\I.JCFJlEIH:
f11Wlt~G 4 / //-1- .
ON USE OF DEADLY FORCE: ----L~/-~-._-----------------------·------·
l~l_!IH S! it·1EHT 1\1-llJ [)l\TE lU
rLl\CE OF COt-IFINEJ·IENT: 1__,__!2~__,_ t:UI111 HIC F:: SEE DELO'ti /
l!l\TE SEIHENCE .
l i·IFOSED: __:.)A_&'-_j._-y__!__J_z_Z}_________ COST: --0-
/
T liiE
SPECIAL PROSECUTION UNIT
340 Hwy. 75N .. Suite A
Huntsville. Texas 77320
(936) 291-2369
Fax (936) 291-0845
August 19, 2009
Kimberly Blackwill
% Walker County District Clerk
301 Courthouse
1100 University Ave.
Huntsville, Texas 77340
Re: Cause No. 15305C(A-1), Ex Parte Gilbert Damian
Dear Kimberly:
Enclosed for filing please find the State's Motion to Designate Issues and c:·
Proposed Order Designating Issues. Please present these to the judge for his
consideratfion a tong witrt t.ile app~ication for habeas corpus. By copy of this ~etter. pre
se applicant is being notified of this filing.
Thank you for your assistance with this matter. If you need anything further, please
caiL
Sincerely,
. l .; r·. ,-· - -)r I I
.
l
.
\
_,__..._._,
\. \ . ; \ 'l , .
,_U-=-'--. _A./ r .-L .·''--
,......_l.l -v
Melinda Fletcher, Appellate Attorney
Special Prosecution Unit
State Bar Card No 18403630
P 0 Box 1744
Amarillo, Texas 79105
Phone 806 367 9407
.Fax 806 ·367 9407
cc: Gilbert Damian
CAUSE NO. 6430-A
EXP.AR'fE IN THE 278rn JliDhCIAL
§ DISTRICT COURT OF
GILBERT DAMIAN § WALKER COUNTY, TEXAS
STATE'S REQUEST TO DESIGNATE ISSUES
TO THE HONORABLE ..ruDGE OF SAID COURT:
CO:M:ES NOW, the State of Texas, by and through Melinda Fletcher, post-
conviction attorney for the Special Prosecution Unit, and moves this Court to enter an
order designating issues of controverted, previously unresolved fact to be resolved. On
July 23, 2009, Gilbert Damian filed an application for writ of habeas corpus pursuant to
TEX. CODE CPJM. PROC. art. 11.07, seeking to challenge his final felony conviction :tor
aggravated assault
_t>..n application filed under a..rt.icle 11.07 provides for a prompt review by the trial
court to determine whether the application alleges any facts, which if true, couid entitle
the applicant to relief. See art. 11.07, § 3 (c). lf the court deterrr.J.ines that controverted
facts do exist, is shall enter an order designating the issues of fact to be resolved. A..rL
11.07, § 3 (d); see lvlartin v. Hamlin, 25 S.W.3d 718, (Tex. Crim. App. 2000) (holding
· the trial court has a duty to designate issues if it determines a habeas application contains
controverted issues.). Upon entry of an order designating issues, the clerk does not have
a duty to forward the application to the Court of Criminal Appeals, until the trial court
has resolved those issues and entered its fmdings. See art. 11.07, § 3 (d).
The State believes that the information from appellant's trial attorney will assist
the Court in detennining whether facts exist material to the legality of ApplicCIJufs
confinement before his application is forwarded to the Court of Criminal Appeals.
Consequently, the State requests the Court enter an order designating 1ssues
ordering applicants trial attorney, Elizabeth Derieux, to file an affidavit within thirty (30)
days of the signing of this order, addressing applicant's claim of ineffective assistance of
counsel.
Further, the State requests both parties be allowed an additional thirty (30) days,
after the receipt of the affidavit(s) to prepare their responses to applicant's claims.
WHEREFORE, PREMISES CONSIDERED, the State prays that this Court
enter the State's Proposed Order Designating issues.
RespectfuHy submitted,
Melinda Fletcher
Post-Conviction Attorney
Special Prosecution Unit
P U Box 1744
_A..rnari..llo, Texas 791 OS
Phone & Fax 806.367.9407
Texas Bar Card No. 1 8403630
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on the 19m day of August, 2009, a true and correct copy of the
State's Request to Designate Issues and Order were mailed postage prepaid to pro se
applicant, Gilbert Damian, TDC # 382329, % TDCJ Wynne Unit, Huntsville, Texas
77349.
Melinda Fletcher
CAUSE NO. 6430-A
§ IN T.lti'!:E 278TH JUDICIAL
§ DISTRICT CO-URT OF
GILBERT DAMIAN § WALI