Commerce and Industry Insurance Company Starnet Insurance Company Catlin Insurance Company, Inc. Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty S.E. United States Aircraft Insurance Group And QBE Aviation Syndicate 5555 at Lloyd's v. American Jet International Corporation D/B/A Million Air Charter, Rew Investments, Inc., Houston Aviation Partners, LLC, Woolsey Aviation, Inc., Million Air Lackland, LLC, Go Fayetteville, LLC, Reno Aviation Partners, LLC, Gulfport Aviation Partners, LLC ( 2015 )

JUDGMENT Court of Appeals First District of Texas NO. 01-14-00488-CV COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY INSURANCE COMPANY, STARNET INSURANCE COMPANY, CATLIN INSURANCE COMPANY, INC., ALLIANZ GLOBAL CORPORATE & SPECIALTY S.E., UNITED STATES AIRCRAFT INSURANCE GROUP, AND QBE AVIATION SYNDICATE 5555 AT LLOYD’S, Appellants V. AMERICAN JET INTERNATIONAL CORPORATION D/B/A MILLION AIR CHARTER, REW INVESTMENTS, INC., HOUSTON AVIATION PARTNERS, LLC, WOOLSEY AVIATION, INC., MILLION AIR LACKLAND, LLC, GO FAYETTEVILLE, LLC, RENO AVIATION PARTNERS, LLC, GULFPORT AVIATION PARTNERS, LLC, TALLAHASSEE AVIATION PARTNERS, LLC, MILLION AIR INTERLINK, INC., ROGER WOOLSEY, AND CARL MOODY, Appellees and AMERICAN JET INTERNATIONAL CORPORATION D/B/A MILLION AIR CHARTER, REW INVESTMENTS, INC., HOUSTON AVIATION PARTNERS, LLC, WOOLSEY AVIATION, INC., MILLION AIR LACKLAND, LLC, GO FAYETTEVILLE, LLC, RENO AVIATION PARTNERS, LLC, GULFPORT AVIATION PARTNERS, LLC, TALLAHASSEE AVIATION PARTNERS, LLC, MILLION AIR INTERLINK, INC., AND ROGER WOOLSEY, Appellants V. COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY INSURANCE COMPANY, STARNET INSURANCE COMPANY, CATLIN INSURANCE COMPANY, INC., ALLIANZ GLOBAL CORPORATE & SPECIALTY S.E., UNITED STATES AIRCRAFT INSURANCE GROUP, AND QBE AVIATION SYNDICATE 5555 AT LLOYD’S, Appellees and AMERICAN JET INTERNATIONAL CORPORATION D/B/A MILLION AIR CHARTER, REW INVESTMENTS, INC., HOUSTON AVIATION PARTNERS, LLC, WOOLSEY AVIATION, INC., MILLION AIR LACKLAND, LLC, GO FAYETTEVILLE, LLC, RENO AVIATION PARTNERS, LLC, GULFPORT AVIATION PARTNERS, LLC, TALLAHASSEE AVIATION PARTNERS, LLC, MILLION AIR INTERLINK, INC., AND ROGER WOOLSEY, Appellants V. TORUS NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY AND WAUSAU BUSINESS INSURANCE COMPANY, Appellees and CARL MOODY, Appellant V. TORUS NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY, Appellee Appeal from the 80th District Court of Harris County. (Tr. Ct. No. 2013-41195). After due consideration, the Court grants appellees American Jet International Corporation d/b/a Million Air Charter, REW Investments, Inc., Houston Aviation Partners, LLC, Woolsey Aviation, Inc., Million Air Lackland, LLC, Go Fayetteville, LLC, Reno Aviation Partners, LLC, Gulfport Aviation Partners, LLC, Tallahassee Aviation Partners, LLC, Million Air Interlink, Inc., and Roger Woolsey’s motion to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. Accordingly, the Court dismisses the petition for permission interlocutory appeal of appellants Commerce and Industry Insurance Company, Starnet Insurance Company, Catlin Insurance Company, Inc., Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty S.E., United States Aircraft Insurance Group, and QBE Aviation Syndicate 5555 at Lloyds’s. The Court further dismisses American Jet International Corporation d/b/a Million Air Charter, REW Investments, Inc., Houston Aviation Partners, LLC, Woolsey Aviation, Inc., Million Air Lackland, LLC, Go Fayetteville, LLC, Reno Aviation Partners, LLC, Gulfport Aviation Partners, LLC, Tallahassee Aviation Partners, LLC, Million Air Interlink, Inc., and Roger Woolsey’s cross-petition for permissive interlocutory appeal and petition for permissive interlocutory appeal, and Carl Moody’s petition for permissive interlocutory appeal. The Court orders that costs be taxed against the party incurring same. The Court orders that this decision be certified below for observance. Judgment rendered May 12, 2015. Per curiam opinion delivered by panel consisting of Chief Justice Radack and Justices Keyes and Lloyd.