Queen City Motor Co. v. Texas Auto Supply Co. , 1921 Tex. App. LEXIS 58 ( 1921 )

This is an attempt to bring this case before us on a writ of error from the county court at law of Jefferson county. It will have to be stricken from the docket, because the return of the sheriff upon the citation in error is defective, in that it does not show that defendant in error was served with a copy of the citation. Article 2092, Vernon's Sayles' Civil Statutes, prescribes that service of citation in error shall be made by delivering to the defendant in error a true copy of the citation. The sheriff's return is as follows:

"Came to hand the 11 day of May, 1920, at 10 o'clock a. m. and executed the 11 day of May, 1920 by delivering to Homer Liyne, Pres. of Texas Auto Supply Co.

"Returned _____, 189, ___. Sterling P. Grimes, Sheriff, Tarrant County, Texas, by T. A. Rogd, Deputy.

Fees serving cop ..... $.75 Mileage .............. .25 Total ............. $1.00"

This return is clearly defective, in that it does not appear therefrom what was delivered to the party named in the return, nor that same was delivered in person, nor does it appear that a copy of the citation was delivered to defendant in error by delivering to Homer Liyne, president of said company, defendant in error, in person, a true copy of said citation. It therefore does not appear from an inspection of the record that there has been legal service upon defendant in error; and it has been repeatedly held that, until such service is affirmatively shown, this court cannot take cognizance of the cause. Gainer Co. v. Shoe Co., 149 S.W. 735; Mims v. Foster et al., 177 S.W. 513.

Defendant in error has not appeared here, but the question is jurisdictional, and it follows that the case must be stricken from the docket of this court, and it is so ordered.