Clifford Bart Dunbar v. Naima El Khaoua ( 2015 )

TBxts court of f\rfie/its; nz%o ozstrvct, at Ausrz/u
hio, 03-/7- oo^j Vvf- cv
September 15, 2015
Ch(torJ- far PuA>io/^. fipf^UK^T
v.
PZTzUoiO Fbfc RQH£PiaZf06
TO THB, HotioKftGlB JoBg£S oi= Sflxo COufiT:
CQ/Y>£S ^OtJj Cl'Ucrd dart OuAtL.y jlppjU^ a*J
respectfully fl*>V/« WuY ttoo/T
2W Su/^jorT T/v^eO-f fypalUvT ujitl re.speetf^(ty shu>
JhcT Th& CourT skoultL c^scasT TA/j tie^ecrvnjg _
X
RnsT 3ws/o(\ o£ ^rror TheT OpptBiU^Tv*°J dtp/weJ of hj Rcr ftA^J £i-hlhl*ofi*l fctjkr To O^C
Proc^SJ . (^RECEIVED
f)f>pe.lfa*>1j )ssvt. u>cr 7Xcr r^t 7>/c/ Cov+T ckuScJ tTs\ SEPl5m
d'**tr*1pc,*i 6y f^/;^ Tv ^iUoj fas p<^Tic?pti.no«s ,v ru (*Mi
This CaurT c&rrec?^ stcteJ rf<=r ;a>ai«%j- cc^oT £<
C^M*J access To TU Courfr S^ply i>cc*^r
•Rafter cUlksWcJ Tker*«s ;A>w^re X^ A>«>r W c/j alsJufe
flfihT To pzrsovclly afpe&r- i*S Q~\JJq ,
ftppelU«r Jirf/uaT To appearj flppell^T Simply 7/veJ
to proceed iy afftdawr a*>cl Cofres/>oA)oteA,ce, p> TU
^ud C&urT ot*d /fyy>e/tee, Jee flppe/ferij a*xeujtr To
OKyi^l p^Ti>T)6^ a/uol flppclUtulj P^pose-d fropersoi**lly or py 4,lfenJ<*Tti]e. /ne*T*rty , Xo(. ''
/)/>^e//ee .Coa>TuxL<1 fUr Appellor OHU\reA hs /vyir
To appear arod (Jefwd AiYhje/^ Iccatxse. ctllUoovk kc
receded /^ollc^ 0f r/ve T/v*/, /pe /We /uo pe^uesT To
p^-ior To Ttla I,
/Weflc/jEr TAe 7Wel 6>^T c^J- %>eAeC Oe.ioi-z.
lie olcfc c£ f^e Trie!,
TVv5 Cot^T" CtfeAj acknowledged Appejhojts i7ere^e<^T
Iaj ktf Ga*swv* TV rA-e ori*;n*t petiT/0fj I a**i cvrreuTly
irtCarceroid ky Mc TeJccj PdpatfhevT of Oi/n;^/ vJVftce-
TW T-f ft^ aA>y ^eo5<»AJ T^e Coo/T requires (*y pr*Sc*ice
?ke CoorT u>*/l N>teJL Tv> &eA/dv u>arA*A>7 /vve ^«cfc J\>
TAiX Coc/rr T^trJ CojocludeJf ... t-br Tk.$ S'lhTcfrZAiT
tS \to$oThtc)e.fiiT Tfr comsT>TvTc. c t^ec^yesT flr-o. ic^ck
Ute/WA>7 o<* T #,o £7To/*>«y, TXe. Courts ka^<.
r^pecTtd\y ke>td TkcT Uy oe/\Te,u/ o-cTt^ty G*> Tkt.\r oco/J
clTTomj^ys fkoi+ld v*T ie. j\elJ To 7Ae Xft/^e sTricT
npperllevT Specifically d^o-u/eol ^e WeJ T/^y.fJj To.
patTpapoTe iV 7Ae 77»Jc/ "f u*L>Te.m To Jc xa.
Appellee. -C* Ud htr- &rtjJ- flpptlhc- /l/pe/irvT
Speci&cclly sTcTe-d if Tke. 7>/o/ Court rrT w^oW Acue /o ker>ck {jiarfa-ot rOppell<*>T To
7»e /ATp*tfy Ototsio.-J*
nppe.UcfT pf>o/*pth Gi+s^tred Ta Tke. "fc/c/ CoorT ewd We
Appellee. isJ-iTk kit Ouj/o Proposed Property AvjJ/oaJ„
nppe.lUc r^lea cm fj/ne^ded- PeTiftoss Tuj0 c/«y_r 4t&>^
Fk<. T/Sc I a^cJ- Appellant UtaJ tr/Oc^/e To a^we/^ 7A-e. fi/*e+*'vy
PersoHvlly by Tke. STeTt. of Texts ct^d )Ts ao"ey dj
•£>r Ht Ke.cAi^ U*-Ae Aec«,cue fAe 7/Vc/ C&*saT (i) a?d M»7"
G(/ouJ /vim fa parliC^poTc c>a>J /o/Jored A<"j aT/e^fr To
terttclpJe,j U) o. Hotted qa; i~/nprt>px,/* a^e^me**?" fo Tke.
PeTiTioti ty flppelhzz KMiThooT Cji\)n*) f\ppe UatST aio cpporToMtTy
%re-tcTe rtf (3 j mode, o>*> i/* proper property cAiat/oa// aW
60 Ufi/d ft-f>(>ellc»T ot fault far ^f ie,^ pr^Se^T u,tt*i
TKc STkTt. of Tex&f /n.
Tm f\ppel\oJls deoyesj fc>r- AJ*<^ Tna-lj ftppe.lU/vT raised
T^e. x«"^t ctro^/jds <-V»TA oddaTtoMUxT *$ Tke, r^ouesT^ oijecpofj
or ShoT/cri „Tex. K< fyp. K33, l(*)(dfa)."
To j*T TA;j Op-.^jejj s?«Atd it To re 7*Ac impossible
of a*J i<0/n«Te,< TklS CourT i5 Soy)***} P)ppe\\**>T rT vJ*J q**vj Tt ,01*0re all n>s Cos3 Jk*T flppill^T ked A>*T
Ud 7//*e To aiose^e^ <**d drUer^r^ fi*>d ftpp^H^T *T
•ficulr -faA /oof I**"] preSe^T aW cz^ard a-li 7U co^tno^iTy
property To ftppelUt'
U «I/aui This 7S T* rwofe* frocfrery of Tke. .UA>iTU
ST*Tcj CopsTiToT/caj/ fcrsT A*e^t) /*tA>T r,oAT TZ r&McSJ /*s
JKi. CouhT of L*vJ) d/ne#Ts fttyir To Ove Process <*-W Eoya I
Pr&TecIic+J of W>e, JLa^J..
f)s fh;£ CootTSfoTtd i*i Co^pUll VJd /7&, IfS"
(Tey^ocxX) ( DQv okjer
appeal )f)T flouts Toe Trie! judye To r*cke a/s /V'fcMea
rvli^j oa^ P1*- oTker parly To* tenedy fAe de,{\r IS fiioT prejerved o* Jhs issue o*>d Tke.
C«J>/op/c«VT i5 Uja'tVed,
fippelU**T CoAtTe^ds he JtJ le.TTke Trtjjudyd f»cke
<*fl itjlor/^ed ru/i'w Thraock his /fao//*>*J fir- o/e Abuw r\eari*Jy
G/»d ItiS MoTtor^i for facuu Trial, The Triil CourT *"£ r^«_
^Kv/juo^e ChoSe To imo> hT Tkt^\
oe ovcrr^le-d Ly op^raVcrJ c+- /au>
Thv$/ hppello^T preserved fUs /SS^e 7fte a*ly poSSiUt.
L>J&y he. Cotsld Si~A>ce Ibe -j/VTc o+TexcJ prexJevT&d h*rn
(ros* pe.frSoM«l\y oijecTit^j To We Trid Co^ris e.*>d /9ppe/l*eJ
o-cftoMS iro Ca^rT oT T^e. Jjpie. or Trio.!*
JT
Tke CourT o£ fippeds r&GJoAiivy J*i t^ fyp*fiw*£r
Szco/^d ctrowd of -error} A/i IAJL CofusTiTt>TicA*vl Pi"TTo
fooTpce* i Puz. Process cfd €^ud ProTceTioA* of The Lq^/s
U oJ fcns\T caacI shodJ te re-covsidesed'
f\ppedlcu^T orcjo-ed TkoT JAe felo/oy - c.oti\/ic-7io^ Groopd
f-of diVorce. UJod f\/*tAj0e& To Tke, oricifjcl pe-Tthojo -fo-r*
dtVJorce. i>»J v/to/vTro/J &f T*Xcj R^le. c<£ Civl) ProCecdo-re-
3l-0L\a.f ILoT C^oyires T^cT ffattoxe c**d PUed^s Sv^iecT
To i%Cerftfao*T&f o^ Service, " 4e -filed of /^cjT Three. d*ys
oewe fAe keoriioj* nppe/lct/T Tke*s procet/ed 7© skouJ
TAc/" T^e oA>ly /&gc/ crowds ^/v cliOorce u><^f iAssopperTnLl/ty ~
TkiS CovrT sT*t*d i/o its Opi/oio^Jj *"/"ercJ" &->/e of Cm (
Procedure feo provides Tk*T parties /vxcy a*,e*>d Tke,ir
pleoditoff UproKJtJ*dy fAcT «,uy plecd'"Sj re.Spoises/ or pl&j
offered Grr -QkiJJ ufTkfiS se-ueM Myf of- fit. cl*Te of
Trie/ a/- fke.^e^fTer/'-y i'A«// 4e l,led o^ly afTer l&Qot. of
The, judyt- is alTo'ved* Tex.& Ct\i. /? &*- 60TA* TU d.Oorce
dtcrec c^ T"A«- 7rj«l CoofTs lii»d<*tcS ^f f«cT oajo* c ox>cAaJ**d LaJclS raised ky £t kho^titd
for Tk*. f,rsT Tr»e. its ktr cx/^fdeji p^Tto/O fled hsS ThcsJ
£t\jeA> cJeyS before Trfol- Thescf,/e. et/e^ Th**$k Tk<^e~ is
too JMj/ca7^ooi>%* ^C{J* 8 Lxzaj /ksh,
IT/ Xcj,ad nij HI*-HI (te*. m$)U>T»y Tk«T *&iu,*
To e>hT&>tS Je«ac/<, &f CotstT cjke/O fHitoy a /«7e pie-adi/oj A\e.y
0^. cured by Tke Tr/<}} Courts o-cTto/J i/S Considering
five ar*e#ded p[ecd>r>G )- There-fare fke issoe o*J appeal
oeco/A€S UsheTktr TAc Trie I Codf«,tA>Z Sec PtfcZ V, B/^bre.e_
1
CaAifiy, Gr^p.j %%% S.loM 2W, m- 9J ("tec. App.- fk*n*> **+\
pet d^foied\( ft %id CovrtJ de.ds" o** Luketker Tor aiUui
The, a-^eA/dtnevt of ple*dtM$J is re^/ecjed OA/Jer c*j aixrje -
of" d'Scre F*«aj S'Tr&jodieU( d^ *Ts ^ce,
a*od Tke, opposite5 parTy okjecls To Tie a/ne^dr\c*oT*
Grv&jkelfk V.^ervice, Lloyds Za&Cc.j 791 S.Uld. 9ty 939
(Tex. 11fo)j TLsncJ Vt Cr«kon r*rT).C*ry>.} ^0? S.ujjJ
So~l fH3 (Tvc.flpp.~-AJ,sT>iJ 2o/i,pel defied). Tke o« 7U f^fy WtfZ?«y
Tke o*e-J<*e~T. Grcevtifli, 7tlSu>.*J -T 131. fa
C/weA^l/AeA/T is prejudicial o» i?S f*ce if 0) iT csjert/ o_
jOe^o ioiiTWttoe. t*«TT*s- Tk«T r^jLp*s The AteTor-e of TkY Tke a»&odr*e»t resTj utiTk TU Sov»d
diScreU*) of Tke Tri<\ Co»rT. Qree^Hy^ 7*7 S*<+X*d
©ri?9. Here. OujJkcr cdoes tooT orjae c.vd TU record
does jooTtskou Tk*T he pres&JTtd &/>y Specsfc e.oidwte\
of Surprise or pr^udiec To TU Trie I Co^rT. Xr> ocU^Tjo^
%
UvAihar fveozy oljec.Te.Ji Tt TU o/*\e*jd/***>T *<* p^ejod.cio) o*> t?s foce. f0e.oerjk^ less
OSfoM/iJc u>*7"A<>o7 d&cid'vj fk 7Ae fx>llo<e.
hold TkoT Tke ple^d.^y /?A»eWA»e*r i^j ^rprejudicial'
h,rsT/ To TU 4)cTe*>t P»fi>h«r Soy^estr TkvV There. aroundj ope>AJ
ivLck Tke Trie! Co^aT Could heue. orcA»r«oi TXe Juuercc
Lve. d*SQ<}ree.
ftppellcvT respectfully diSeyre&s ooiTk ThoTsT*Te«,&>T^Taj
PIppellonTs fippeil Brie, f o»y jroorTTk HeldA*- 4qJT crowd of
ihtiiSpperToduliTy £'TL&*\phxij addedJ &W 0*t c j^ou^d based
i*i ftjr, Sooh cs felony- Coa>wcTh*j. Morrison \rc fomsc^
113 Su/.*d 371,371*11 frex.^p,-&//«j f?H/^r,Totsrxo().
Dw&er (does A>oT oh^He^e Tke Trie! Co^aIs P/y^c o r
'l /*SvpparT<2>kdiTy . Q-A+d TkiS f/Atdi/SC <2let*e }S StrfiAcie«iT 7~b
Swpp**T The. TrieI CooaU dfssolvTtefJ of Tke /no-rri^ye^ t*o pr<^oJsci*l ef&eT. *
fippellctuT dcscjretS c**d respeeTf^lly crfo Ws Court pc ©
recorder, fippcllcvT Spe.afcdly cjked Tfus Coc^rto a^e^d
TUe Divorce fleece To sUuj fAcT Tke- oi/force is cro Tke Custody of- TU SfrTe. of Texcj o**d
Cou/d VoT Jeyc/L or phySicdly ke. prestArT aT Tke. Tn<>l
U/iTWoT Tke. Tke. Trial C&ir/T A&veA io-cwaT;**/ L/*. Uck.
legally To U /c€.
0TUr TU*/ iMStrpporr^hfy/j p,yC l?0P Appeal krtet "t
PippeWanT STcTeS/ ''Z„ apo^d T<~jo. ftppe1U«>T h«s sk>c^r> TAc
Ovly K/iqUi cjro^jjds rZr dtuorte is iMSoffo*TaJ>d;Ty. This
UJcs Appellees Sole oroo^d iM ker or-io,***! peTiTto^ c/wjJ
fifjpeiUfT k*s Nevtr ot&»ced a>A>d ev*» afreed TkcT TU
Yn$rri*>J Three »,t u
TAe Trcd Courts r^kroc jk*uld be cr^bvded To «
Decree, om Tke Jolt croif^d od
re^c/*dcd f*r~a y€.<^> Trial oat «/£,/ 9 o£ fippetU^Tj frppucl brief itJ
\o
kiS Tro-yer to U*s H*A****tk Co^rT he sTeTdJ, Uflppe/loAjT
pyeSpetT folly prays TUT Tks rlc»o£ftei£ Cooftr re^t^ds
T\\i$ Ccoj-e far a roeuj Tri«,l To Q/^c^d TU decree. To ce«.d
dliforce orc^T^.6 o** Sole c^o-"S o$tt*S\>ppoiTcbAtTy e.*^d
To fairly a*>d -tooyWably cltvcde TU Corw"T^
prop&Ty.
j[a> a^sujtr TQ This C-wrTj c^loje-of-cvScreTeosJ
StoN^cjds flppe(lcA>T u/i/l skouJ' Tkh CoorT stvTeJ, krr
Trtd C.&T o. pledge Q/^t^d^t^T uvlesJ
COTU opposej perTy presents evidence of surprint or*
pre-JodiCe or ,
fipp^.lhioT ^oArTevdj U coretjud'CC To Tke Tnd Co^rT cT Trtci
Ucvc/ G>oT Ae-ucA c*J<;rrc*>T fippelioft ftddiZo^H^y/
n.ppe.l)cfijT coold 9*oTrespond *y /*>«•/ r~ t"e/re, freuioos
To TU a A^e/^d r^e^T Tke Sole crot"-d for cdwert-e. c*Jcs
Tke AJC-fWir Qrowd of ]trs«ppo.tTctkd:Ty* Tke Trie I
CovrT /V czflocj)cJc TU toeoj oro"d of fL/o»y vcs of f6cT Q*J- Co»dos)o»s of U^J
6-KP/N€-5J"/y Tr>y Tke d*LH>rce ujo /Va/La*-
•ftloMy CoWicTtorS,
J/J PkdkpJ V. Pk.ll,pj} ?J~ Scu,3J fQHjZTl (Tex.fipp-
Qeav/noAjT $000), TU ftppeqU C»vrTSTcfed ujkeAT TA-e. rjtssd^'
d+ rrxarriacc is SovclT Solely o*J CrowJ o£ iAsSapp»rtel>dTy
^Vide/Jet o (• +cT al Caj GAtdyttcci
L\o/vsTrvc.t a^rd faiy f^oT he, Co.usidered ky He. Irtcl C&vrT
}io iTj josT oi^d nSuppe>rTQ4itkTyj
To (-«a/C/ r\fip£.l[ o*>T oTU foT h&iVQ preset
of Trtql ^v;eA/ Tkooek TU Trie I Co^>T kveuf flpp^fU^T cksqs
irtCarCcrxTed &"d TkaT ,fipp*UcA>T iMQS if Uf\»IT" S2*r a
f^eloMy-r- coAjJicTio/A /A/fAre/oce TU Tricl Court a/^d
p^jodsled Tke frppe\UMt
fidd/Tt^ally, TU a/we"W peTiftoAJ is p)re.Jud<^id o*f
its fWe. /a> TUT'iT preje*ds a n^<*j eyrour+d fir d>v°rce.
U;lwck ftppellcA/T u^cs U^oile To c/e/o^d &fc.fi*sT ^«c TU 0»>±"d*-d peT>T,oAJ
Oo-TA To Tke trial Co^-T i*o k,S MoTo^cr frcUrvov* c*+d
/ue-oTK*?! ctivd ftpp&UcAjfs flppe&h Tksu>tre 7/We a^d fippJl^T fr p0 £e
gw^ (UoTrce of coLT To deA/od o-j<&»sT)l c^di (z) ;T
prejudices Tke ^Iq>ajT>PPj' prest^ToTioAj &f TU c^se/
{.ftppvlletfT iocs preuevTed froa* a/us^eritJc Tke o,lieyS Coo/f To
G.[lo CoA*sTtToT»c»tl riykTs To MoTi^ 0<^e Process, fedrtsj &r
k&O&l rr&TecTitA) of Tke. JLolJ*
TU CourT c£ fippecir r^o-Soxfissj iaJ denyiATQ
hppellotds Tkird sT {\pfte.Hd fx>A>d
A«7*\ O.T fc\s\T U r^aSoAJ 0 f- felovy-Ce>M ujkeAJ S*z*'d
Coa>VIcTio\) ujai shh v*+yir*y f\ppelUvPs <^rovA>d Tu^a 6/yw>
CW-e/- TzXcs RAej of BviJeAJee § £oj>6a) X\.t £vJe/>c«
o(c JvoL/neAttj e^vTere.d a,fTer strict or up°r-> *• p le* <>T
ctu-dTy cr $t°la CoAjTetjdere.j adj^df>r^9 o- person J <•>*/*} of
d ^ri/viy/ucjl offense T*rre*y fitcT-esseMTi^i 7o SvsTei.\s
T*e jVdU/»ae^T"0f CoAJOicTiOAj h^ThoTi^clud'^f., c«jke.+s
OhW() Ay Tke STcT*. fir purposes oTker T***' inpe^Ue*^
^L>OQ'*&>\ o.a<2,vsT persons oTUr Tkc^J /7e- accostd Tm ell
Co$e$ TU pe*>de**cy or c\j cppe^l readers s cc-k evidence
T+ro o f ds decS/orJ
e.veA) sTqTe.d TU CoMCvc,Ttos-> kjjoj efftr^ed U Tk*T Co^rT
oaJ (fwe ll^oly. DfTer TU decree,
Siflrce. Tke Le.a,sUTuAc d^fves wAc7/j c»d wA Courts
&re. fooT a.T liktrT To tjr^ort. o-»y }e.yd de-f^Tte^s
HUT ci TX%, ?o3{i^)
IS COAtfTiTvTiovJef, ftppzlUAjTs felony £o.ui>ic7Vc/J u;kTy'
The CoOrToJ Appeals /'a/ Ax>T a.A>su*eri*>5 Tk*s ^rror
Cot<\ftuTTed ^rroT et»d skoulcl reu^u/ / fs cLe-asior*.
The. CovrT &(- fippech re.Gso/J<**? /a/ ae^y^f
nppe)lo*/ls lourTk Qpocr/jd &£ trro>r . TkcT tkt, Trul
CourT aho-se(} j Ts eJ'ScreTosJ ias its Co/*\/*d
its dtfcreZ/orJ ky asoT Tcfovvo a^y of PIpp^/icArty w/v'TT^'O
C&SpoMSes /a/to coAiS/demTorJj fArdiVf f)ppeli^T'o.T -fc^lT
for ftj0T hotJQ preStA>T aT TU Tnul c+jke* Tke Tr/cl Cou^rT
UiveuJ AppellcvT uias /scarcercTed o^ preue^TeJ -£l*o
aUky^dAJe Trie IJ fifd.-ioj cat Gn-e^ded pe-TrT'oAJ prop >tr
QvCaj IUisck i t vocj fded i*s \Jlo)cTiO/s ef T\jreJ fi*sU
fes
of G.v.-f Procedure M^llo'^Z/j ftvd^j flppelU»T a.T
ftldT f&r felony* CorJ^rcT/o^ uxheAJ occord^y To Texcj
Qdej 0f Gocde*>ce § 8°3(te) Scid CoAjUicbo^ <^los ajoT
•fiAJcl ' oa*\v Tck.vf ZuideAsct fro/« OAse pXirtj OA>e pcrTy ©£ TU dts/erce. all T^e QSSeTTs of Ik
CGt^rx^f^Ty proper-Ty C-oMTrery 7© esT*& hjked ^cjt ler.); pk.ikps s/jm.pj, 73.)j j^orp/joAJ ^rfrriStAJ,
ItJ J!uj,3d 711,37?'?? (Te.ic.frp,,.- OcJIcflfK; ur.Tcds^d))
\r
fiScUr-STokv- \J, STo^ 179 S.tJ. 3J £70, 277 (**#. App.^-
bovsTo>jUijrD*f] So'0, peT> deAsd.
for Tke Co^rT o£ f)ppe*U tw>T To &*>d Tke tnd
Ccaj/T oUsed t Ts tdiscreTtoAj is To ij/Jcre, -QSTckltjled
Case Iced alrecAy d^&ded.
WAeAj ^divorce iS Crc^Te^ oaj Tie So le c/*o<->A>dj
of iK)SorforTol,)iT}/ v&iTUr fcrTy iS cf fZdl To TU*s
Cnutcrd OAre PCAty )O0% o\- Tke. *>SJeTk U/oyij Ae Caj
oAoSe o f d*'scrc'T)o/S *
HppeJIc/ut respectfully asU Tk*s CouaT of ftppe^l?
^° T&kecr t^s &e<,iS*ohS4
Pk f) y sk
flppellovT asks Tkls CoorT fo r*.\ji*oj iTs oiecij TkcT Tke dHl>*rce decree be
CxMt*>ded To sU.£tslT',liL
foKS/sd ojcujT Ts Proposed Pr+p^ty division of
fo% f& flppe/ltC C«j-d&°% To flppej/c+rt XrJ aM.TroA*^
TU VcA^./e iKJ fypelieej poSS*SS;o*j UT* U U* sJcly
^•ud *>&T Tb be CoAsS.'dered Cor*»vA>,ry prop^y. AddtT>oAicHy
TU X/c/ue af TU 9ol(k)piori before Felrucy Uly TUr
U
appellee. h&J Tkrouch Tke Hy&TT torp*rt>ViOAJ if T* U
iArchded i^TU Co/^fAonnTy property. Opce. Just avd
Voir To nppellee^i
liespecTfilly Sub** TT*d
Clifford BarT filler
TOCJ-IO* 17*1*3 9
STdes OfjiT
3c Qo Fm j>cr/y
CEPTXrZCftTE of ^£/evrc£
TksJLcl^y of SepTe^bzr telf, dZ C^CrHfy TkcT o_
Trve. aAid CorreeT Copy o r TAe forego i&Q cdoc^A^e^T foej
hee*J Served on/ Appellee Throvfh keT ftTTorAt^y of
Recordj Behjod Roberts at Vol U)ejT 7? *
~777oj-
Ca3 U>
(*> O •si -
O r^
c
O
1 ° i
T>
s
? p Cr
•Nl
>J -<:
<1
OH
O ' o ^_
c
TX5
o
o 0
J?
o
n C