Foy v. Domec

By the Court, Sawyer, J.:

The notice of appeal appears to have been served on the 6th, and filed on the 9th, of February, 1867, and respondents move to dismiss because no effectual appeal has been taken. It has been repeatedly held that to render an appeal effectual, under the statute, the filing must precede, or be cotemporaneous with, the service. (Boston v. Haynes, 31 Cal. 107.)

The appeal must be dismissed, and it is so ordered.