Adair Holdings, L.L.c, a Nebraska Limited Liability Company v. Matthew Thomas Trucking, L.L.C., and George Thomas

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF IOWA
No. 13-0590
Filed September 10, 2015
ADAIR HOLDINGS, L.L.C, a Nebraska Limited
Liability Company,
Plaintiff-Appellant,
vs.
MATTHEW THOMAS TRUCKING, L.L.C., and GEORGE THOMAS, et al.,
Defendants-Appellees.
________________________________________________________________
Appeal from the Iowa District Court for Marion County, Terry R. Rickers,
Judge.
A tax sale deed holder appeals the district court’s denial of its petition for
the recovery of real property. REVERSED AND REMANDED.
John T. Clendenin and Colin C. Smith of Nyemaster Goode, P.C., Des
Moines, for appellant.
George Thomas, Pella, and Matthew Thomas Trucking, L.L.C., Pella,
appellees.
Considered by Vogel, P.J., and Potterfield and Mullins, JJ. Goodhue, S.J.,
takes no part.
2
VOGEL, P.J.
Adair Holdings, L.L.C. is the tax deed holder of certain property in Marion
County. The immediate past title holders were George Thomas and Christine
Marie Thomas, husband and wife. The property is currently in the possession of
Matthew Thomas Trucking, L.L.C.,1 under an unrecorded lease agreement with
George Thomas. Adair Holdings brought this action under Iowa Code chapter
646 (2011) to obtain possession of the property. 2 The district court denied relief.
Adair Holdings now appeals asking that we reverse the district court’s decision
and find that it is entitled to immediate and unconditional possession of the
property.
I. Background Facts and Proceedings.
On June 19, 2006, the property in question was sold at a tax sale due to
delinquent property taxes. A tax sale certificate was issued to Adam Assets/US
Bank. After the expiration of the statutory period of one year and nine months, a
notice of the expiration of the right of redemption was sent by ordinary and
certified mail to all parties of interest on February 12, 2009, pursuant to Iowa
Code section 447.9. Signed certified mail receipts show that on February 14,
2009, Matthew Thomas signed for the certified mail sent to the address of the
property in question for the “person in possession” and for George and Christine
Thomas. Christine Thomas signed for herself and George Thomas for the notice
1
The lease is between the “Landlord-George Thomas” and “Tenant-Matthew Thomas,
Trucking LLC,” providing rent would be $100 per month, paid annually, for a five-year
term beginning in March 2008, and signed by George Thomas and Matthew K. Thomas.
2
Iowa Code section 646.24 provides, “When the plaintiff shows that the plaintiff is
entitled to the immediate possession of the premises, judgment shall be entered and an
execution issued accordingly.”
3
sent to a different address on the same date.3 Adam Assets/US Bank assigned
its interest in the tax sale certificate to Adair Holdings on June 10, 2009. When
no one redeemed the property within the statutory ninety days, the Marion
County Treasurer’s office issued a tax sale deed to Adair Holdings on June 12,
2009. See Iowa Code § 448.1. This deed was recorded on June 15, 2009.
A few days later on June 23, 2009, Adair Holdings filed a 120-day affidavit
with the county recorder’s office. See Iowa Code § 448.15. In response,
Matthew K. Thomas recorded an affidavit on September 15, 2009, in which he
asserted he was the manager of Matthew Thomas Trucking, L.L.C., and had
been in possession of the parcel in question since March 2008 under a lease
agreement with George and Christine Thomas. Matthew Thomas took no further
action on his claim.4
Thereafter, Adair Holdings filed suit on September 17, 2009, against
George Thomas, Christine Thomas, and Person in Possession, asking the court
to declare it to be the absolute owner in fee simple of the property and that it be
placed in peaceful possession of the property. The case proceeded to trial in
May 2010, and in June, the court issued its ruling finding both George Thomas
and Matthew Thomas on behalf of Matthew Thomas Trucking, L.L.C., admitted to
receiving the Notice of Expiration of Right of Redemption. The court concluded
Adair Holdings purchased the property at a tax sale, it met all requirements for
serving the Notice of Right of Redemption, and the defendants failed to redeem
3
Notice of the expiration of the right of redemption was also published in the local
newspaper on February 20, 2009.
4
See Iowa Code § 448.16(3) (requiring those filing claims in response to the 120-day
affidavit to commence an action within sixty days or the claim is forfeited and canceled).
4
the property.5 However, Adair Holdings’s claim was denied because a
prerequisite for filing the 120-day affidavit is to be in possession of the property. 6
Because Adair Holdings had never been in possession of the property in
question, it was not entitled to a determination at that time that the validity of the
tax title was conclusively established as a matter of law under section 448.16.7
The court noted, “Adverse claims may still be allowed except as limited by Iowa
Code [section] 448.12.”8
Adair Holdings then filed a forcible entry and detainer complaint against
Matthew Thomas Trucking, L.L.C., in September 2010. Because of a lack of
evidence to support a finding that an adequate three-day notice to quit was
served on Matthew Thomas Trucking, L.L.C., the action was dismissed on March
11, 2011.9 Neither of these two prior court decisions was appealed.
Adair Holdings then filed this action in December 2011 pursuant to Iowa
Code chapter 646, against George Thomas, Matthew Thomas Trucking, L.L.C.,
5
The court also specifically concluded the claims made by the defendants—that US
Bank’s agent was not authorized to act on behalf of US Bank in sending out the Notice
of Right of Redemption and that Adair Holdings breached a contract with George
Thomas—had no merit.
6
Iowa Code section 448.15(1) provides, in part:
After taking possession of the parcel, after the issuance and
recording of a tax deed or an instrument purporting to be a tax deed
issued by a county treasurer of this state, the then owner or holder of the
title or purported title may file with the county recorder of the county in
which the parcel is located an affidavit . . . .
(Emphasis added.)
7
Iowa Code section 448.16 provides that the 120-day affidavit shall be notice to all
persons claiming any right, title, or interest in the parcel described that they must file a
claim with the county recorder’s office setting forth the nature and acquisition of the
interest claimed.
8
Iowa Code section 448.12 provides, “An action under section 447.8 or 448.6 or for the
recovery of a parcel sold for the nonpayment of taxes shall not be brought after three
years from the execution and recording of the county treasurer’s deed.”
9
The court also noted that under notice pleadings the action could have been
considered an ordinary action for recovery of real property under chapter 646, but no
abstract of title was attached as required by that chapter.
5
and any person in possession asking that it be put into possession of the parcel;
that the court issue an execution for those in possession to be removed within
three days of the judgment entry; and that it be awarded costs of the action and
such other relief as the court deemed just. This matter proceeded to a bench
trial on March 12, 2013, and the court issued its decision the same day. The
court noted the rulings in the two previous actions and concluded none of the
evidence submitted by Adair Holdings contained new information that was not
available at the time of the prior rulings. The court found the abstract of title that
was included as an exhibit in this proceeding did nothing to negate the infirmities
that had caused the court to dismiss the prior two actions. The court concluded
Adair Holdings had still not established the validity of its tax deed as a matter of
law and dismissed the action. Adair now appeals that ruling, and neither
Matthew Thomas Trucking, L.L.C., nor George Thomas filed a brief in this
appeal.10
II. Scope and Standard of Review.
As this action was tried at law in the district court, our review is for
correction of errors at law. See Iowa R. App. P. 6.907.
III. Tax Deed.
On appeal, Adair Holdings asserts the district court erred in dismissing its
case because it is entitled to possession of the property in light of the expiration
10
See White v. Harper, 807 N.W.2d 289, 292 (Iowa Ct. App. 2011) (“When the appellee
fails to file a brief, we ‘handle the matter in a manner most consonant with justice and
[our] own convenience.’ . . . [W]e will not search the record for a theory to uphold the
decision of the district court, but will ‘confine [ourselves] to the objections raised by the
appellant.’ In addition, we will not go beyond the ruling of the trial court in searching for
a theory upon which to affirm its decision.” (internal citations omitted)).
6
of the statute of limitations for actions challenging its tax deed. Because neither
Matthew Thomas Trucking, L.L.C., nor George Thomas brought an action to
recover the property within three years of the recording of the tax deed, Adair
Holdings claims the validity of its tax deed is now conclusively established as a
matter of law and it is entitled to possession of the parcel. It claims that the
failure of the earlier actions to place it in possession of the property have no
preclusive effect on the current case as those actions were based on other code
provisions.
Iowa Code section 448.5 provides a tax deed “shall be conclusive
evidence . . . that all things required by law to make a good and valid sale and to
vest the title in the purchaser were done.” The tax deed vests “in the purchaser
all the right, title, interest, and claim of the state and county to the parcel, and all
the right, title, interest, and estate of the former owner in and to the parcel
conveyed.” Iowa Code § 448.3. The deed can be challenged as provided in
section 448.6;11 however, such an action must be brought within three years after
the recording of the tax deed. See id. § 448.12.
It was previously determined that Adair Holdings met all requirements of
sections 447.9 and 447.12 in serving and completing the notice of the right of
11
Iowa Code section 448.6(4) provides a person seeking to invalidate a tax deed must
prove any of the following:
a. That the parcel was not subject to taxes for the year or years
named in the deed.
b. That the taxes had been paid before the sale.
c. That the parcel had been redeemed from the sale and that the
redemption was made for the use and benefit of persons having the right
of redemption.
d. That there had been an entire omission to list or assess the
parcel, or to levy the taxes, or to give notice of the sale, or to sell the
parcel.
7
redemption on Matthew Thomas Trucking, L.L.C., (as Person in Possession),
George Thomas, and Christine Thomas. It is also undisputed that they failed to
redeem the property, and the county issued the tax deed accordingly. See id.
§ 448.1. In the three years following the recording of the tax deed, no one has
brought an action to invalidate the tax deed. While the three-year statute of
limitations had not run at the time Adair Holdings filed the current action in
December 2011, it had run by the time the case went to trial on March 12, 2013.
Therefore, all potential adverse claims against the tax deed were, as of the time
of trial in this case, forever barred from seeking to invalidate Adair Holdings’s tax
deed to the parcel in question. See id. § 448.12.
Adair Holdings filed an affidavit that complied with the language in section
448.15 in 2009, and if it were successful, that notice would have shortened the
three-year statute of limitations to 120 days pursuant to section 448.16. While
this course of action was admittedly in error and ultimately unsuccessful, that
should not have precluded a finding at the time of trial in 2013 that the tax deed
was established as a matter of law because the three-year statute of limitations
had then run. See Dohrn v. Mooring Tax Asset Grp., L.L.C., 743 N.W.2d 857,
864 (Iowa 2008) (noting the 120-day affidavit procedure “simply provide[s] a
quick and low-cost alternative to bringing an action to quiet title.” And “[a]fter the
holder of the tax deed files an affidavit with the county recorder, section 448.16
cuts the amount of time to bring an action adverse to the tax title from three years
to 120 days”).
We conclude the running of the three-year statute of limitations entitles
Adair Holdings to a determination from the court that it has a valid tax deed to
8
the parcel in question as a matter of law. We reverse the district court’s
decision and remand for entry of a judgment and for further proceedings under
chapter 646 consistent with this opinion.
REVERSED AND REMANDED.