DocketNumber: Docket No. 134.
Citation Numbers: 199 N.W. 373, 227 Mich. 562
Judges: McDONALD, J.
Filed Date: 6/18/1924
Status: Precedential
Modified Date: 1/12/2023
I concur in the result. I am not in accord with the broad holding that an intent to do wrong or to inflict some bodily injury is necessary in all cases to constitute the crime of involuntary manslaughter. Acts of recklessness, in wanton disregard of consequences, resulting in a killing, in order to constitute involuntary manslaughter, require knowledge of wrong doing on the part of the offender, to remove the same from misadventure or mere accident, but a killing, committed while violating a penal statute, requires no finding that the offender intended to do wrong or to inflict some bodily injury. This is my understanding of the holdings of this court.People v. Harris,
MOORE and FELLOWS, JJ., concurred with WIEST, J. *Page 569
People v. Wells , 12 Cal. 4th 979 ( 1996 )
People v. Pulley , 225 Cal. App. 2d 366 ( 1964 )
Fisher and Utley v. State , 367 Md. 218 ( 2001 )
State v. Thomas , 464 Md. 133 ( 2019 )
People of Michigan v. Theresa Marie Gafken ( 2022 )
People v. Aaron , 409 Mich. 672 ( 1980 )
People v. Holtschlag , 471 Mich. 1 ( 2004 )
State v. Millette , 112 N.H. 458 ( 1972 )
People v. Meyer , 46 Mich. App. 357 ( 1973 )
People v. McDonald , 409 Mich. 110 ( 1980 )
People v. McDonald , 86 Mich. App. 5 ( 1978 )
State v. Chambers , 524 S.W.2d 826 ( 1975 )
State v. Catellier , 63 Wyo. 123 ( 1947 )
State v. McKeiver , 89 N.J. Super. 52 ( 1965 )
Commonwealth v. Feinberg , 433 Pa. 558 ( 1969 )
Commonwealth v. Bowden , 456 Pa. 278 ( 1973 )
State v. Streeton , 231 N.C. 301 ( 1949 )