Judges: WRITTEN BY: Don Stenberg, Attorney General Delores Coe-Barbee, Assistant Attorney General
Filed Date: 3/9/2001
Status: Precedential
Modified Date: 7/5/2016
REQUESTED BY: Alfonza Whitaker, Director, Nebraska Equal Opportunity Commission
You requested our opinion regarding whether the Nebraska Equal Opportunity Commission [NEOC] has jurisdiction over a respondent who has only seven full-time employees, but employs students and field inspectors on a seasonal basis. The Nebraska Fair Employment Practice Act, at Neb. Rev. Stat. §
In your memorandum, attached to your request, you indicated that:
Field inspectors are trained by the Respondent for the crop season when they will be working.
Field inspectors set their own hours and decide when the crop will be inspected, within the time framework set by the Respondent.
Field inspectors are not supervised.
Field inspectors report to no one, but are encouraged to contact the Respondent if they have any questions.
Field inspectors do not report to the Respondent except for training.
Field inspectors are not given an employee handbook.
Field inspectors complete a W-2 form and taxes are withheld according to what they indicate on the form.
Field inspectors receive no benefits from the Respondent.
In Haag v. Bongers,
Haag,
In regard to the first criterion, the court stated, "[t]he right of control is the chief factor distinguishing an employment relationship from one of an independent contractor." Haag,
In the instant case, the field inspectors set their own hours and decide when the crop will be inspected within the time frame set by the Respondent. No one supervises them, and they report to no one. The field inspectors have control over their specific daily tasks. The only time the field inspectors come to the Respondent's office is when they are trained, and contact from then on is by choice of the field inspector.
In Commissioner of Labor v. Lyric Co.,
In keeping with the criteria delineated in Haag, we conclude that the field inspectors are independent contractors. In Attorney General Opinion No. 89054 (July 17, 1989), we concluded that the Nebraska Fair Employment Practice Act does not encompass independent contractors.
It will not be necessary to respond to your second question because independent contractors are not covered by the Nebraska Fair Employment Practice Act.
Sincerely,
DON STENBERG Attorney General
Delores Coe-Barbee Assistant Attorney General
APPROVED BY:
_________________________ Attorney General
Hemmerling v. Happy Cab Co. , 247 Neb. 919 ( 1995 )
Larson Ex Rel. Larson v. Hometown Communications, Inc. , 248 Neb. 942 ( 1995 )
Commissioner of Labor v. LYRIC CO. INC. , 224 Neb. 190 ( 1986 )
Pettit v. State, Department of Social Services , 249 Neb. 666 ( 1996 )