Elizabeth Trust Co. v. Underwood

The' opinion of the court was delivered by

Campbell, J.

This action was to recover a balance of $4,000 and interest upon a note originally in the sum of $33,500, given by appellant to' Henry Schmidt and Elizabeth A. Schmidt as consideration for stock representing their interest in the Pulton Specialty Company, a corporation of this state.

Both payees are deceased. Henry Schmidt predeceased his wife, and by his last will and testatment devised and bequeathed to her all his estate, including the note in question.

Elizabeth A. Schmidt left a last will and testament naming respondent as her executor.

The originalnote was given August 21st, 1917.

Appellant in his answer admits the execution and delivery of the original note and the several payments made by him thereon, but alleges a failure of consideration to the extent of two-thirds thereof, upon the theory that the Schmidts represented that they were the owners of stock of said com pany in the sum of $150,000 pax value, being all of the stock thereof, while, in fact, the total stock of the company was $50,000 par value, all of which they’ sold and assigned to him.

Appellant also counter-claims upon two- separate grounds, viz.— (a) Failure of consideration, and (b) fraud and deceit, alleging as the damage payment of federal income taxes in the sum of $8,511.49 in excess of what would have been paid had the total capitalization of the company been $150,-000 instead of $50,000.

The trial court directed a verdict against appellant upon his counter-claims, and also against him and in favor of respondent for the sum of $4,000 and interest, being the balance due upon the note. From the judgment entered thereon the present appeal is taken.

We find there was no error in such direction. There was no evidence to support appellant’s counter-claims of fraud and deceit or partial failure of consideration.

The judgment below is therefore affirmed, with costs.

For affirmance — The Chancellor, Chief Justice, Teen-chard, Parker, Mint urn, Black, Katzenbach, Campbell, Lloyd, White, Gardner, Van Buskirk, Clark, McGlennon, Kays, JJ. 15.

For reversal — None.