Citation Numbers: 13 Abb. Pr. 297
Judges: Clerke
Filed Date: 11/15/1861
Status: Precedential
Modified Date: 1/12/2023
—Section 308 of the Code provides that there shall be allowed to the plaintiff, and only to the plaintiff, upon the recovery of judgment by him in any action for the partition of real property, or for the foreclosure of a mortgage, or in which a warrant of attachment has been issued, or for an adjudication upon a will or other instrument in writing, &c., a percentage on the recovery, &c., which cannot exceed sixty dollars. By this provision for the plaintiff exclusively, it may be safely inferred, that the Legislature intended that defendants in the actions specified in the section should not be entitled to any extra allowance.
In section 309, however, as amended in 1858, it was provided that the court may also “ in its discretion make a further allowance to any party, not exceeding five per cent, upon the amount of the recovery or claim, or subject-matter involved.”
If this remained the law, as I erroneously supposed in my late opinion in Hotaling a. Marsh,
The defendants in this action, therefore, are not entitled to any extra allowance, and the order of the special term should be affirmed, without costs.
Present, Clerke, P. J., Ingraham and Leonard, JJ.
In Hotaling a. Marsh (Supreme Court, First District ; At Chambers, November, 1861), it was held, that although the court has no discretionary power to allow in actions mentioned in section 308 of the Code, any more costs than the Code prescribes, yet in any action mentioned in that section,—e. g., a partition action,—an allowance of five per cent, on the recovery of any party may be granted.
This amendment, I believe, has not been repealed ; and by virtue of it, and not by any inherent general power of the court in equity cases (if, indeed, a partition-suit can be strictly called an equity suit), I have authority to make additional allowances to the plaintiffs or any of the defendants.
To the plaintiffs I allow $150.
To the infant defendants Frank and Valentine Marsh, $150.
To Ellen Campbell, defendant, $50.
To the infant defendants Franklin and Harriett Ann Pgters, $50.
■To the executors, $50.
■ To the defendants Harriet Peters and Harriet Ann Marsh, $150.