Citation Numbers: 66 A.2d 266, 361 Pa. 652
Judges: OPINION BY MR. JUSTICE ALLEN M. STEARNE, May 23, 1949:
Filed Date: 4/15/1949
Status: Precedential
Modified Date: 1/13/2023
This is an appeal from a judgment entered for defendantnon obstante veredicto in a suit by a beneficiary against an insurance company on its policy which insured the life of plaintiff's husband. Judgment was entered for defendant because the uncontradicted documentary evidence established false and fraudulent statements made by the insured in the insurance application, upon which the insurer relied in issuing the policy.
The policy was issued on April 24, 1943. Insured died within three months thereafter on July 3, 1943. The cause of death was "a respiratory arrest," with contributing cause "widespread ulcerative caseous tuberculosis bilateral," which, in lay language, is an advanced state of tuberculosis.
In answering, in the negative, questions in the application, the insured denied, and did not disclose, that he had been medically treated and hospitalized for tuberculosis. The undisputed evidence established that he was aware of the nature of his illness. At one time he was admitted to the hospital after he had "expectorated about a cupful of bright blood and clots." The official hospital records disclose his numerous admissions to the hospital, the diagnosis and treatment for tuberculosis. That the insured's statements were false, and he knew them to be false, cannot be doubted from an examination of this undisputed documentary evidence. This precludes *Page 654
recovery: Freedman v. The Mutual Life Insurance Company of NewYork,
The hospital records were properly admitted as documentary evidence to show the fact of hospitalization, treatment prescribed and symptoms given: Act of May 4, 1939, P. L. 42, 28 PS, 91b; Freedman v. The Mutual Life Insurance Company of NewYork, supra, 412.
Judgment affirmed.
*Page 1
Travellers Ins. Co. v. Heppenstall Co. , 360 Pa. 433 ( 1948 )
Derr v. Mutual Life Ins. Co. , 351 Pa. 554 ( 1944 )
Freedman v. Mut. Life Ins. Co. of N.Y. , 342 Pa. 404 ( 1941 )
Bailey v. TENNESSEE COAL IRON AND RAILROAD CO. , 261 Ala. 526 ( 1954 )
Commonwealth v. Hemingway , 369 Pa. Super. 112 ( 1987 )
Williams v. McClain , 513 Pa. 300 ( 1987 )
Fauceglia v. Harry , 409 Pa. 155 ( 1962 )
Commonwealth v. DiGiacomo , 463 Pa. 449 ( 1975 )
Ganster v. Western Pennsylvania Water Co. , 349 Pa. Super. 561 ( 1985 )
Commonwealth v. Seville , 266 Pa. Super. 587 ( 1979 )
McCloskey v. New York Life Insurance , 292 Pa. Super. 1 ( 1981 )
Glover v. Com., Dept. of Transp. , 167 Pa. Commw. 87 ( 1994 )
Commonwealth v. Campbell , 244 Pa. Super. 505 ( 1976 )
Karasciewicz v. Crown Can Co. , 188 Pa. Super. 212 ( 1958 )
Rue v. K-Mart Corp. , 456 Pa. Super. 641 ( 1997 )