Mark Edward Kinsler v. Carl Baker, et ux., Edith Baker

I N THE COURT OF APPEALS OF TENNESSEE
EASTERN SECTI ON
FILED
October 1, 1997
Cecil Crowson, Jr.
Appellate C ourt Clerk
MARK EDWARD KI NSLER ) HANCOCK COUNTY
) 03A01- 9703- CH- 00080
Pl a i nt i f f - Appe l l e e )
)
)
v. ) HON. THOMAS R. FRI ERSON, I I ,
) CHANCELLOR
)
CARL BAKER, e t u x )
EDI TH BAKER )
)
De f e nda nt s - Appe l l a nt s ) AFFI RMED AND REMANDED
W LLI AM E. PHI LLI PS OF ROGERSVI LLE FOR APPELLANT
I
FLOYD W RHEA OF SNEEDVI LLE FOR APPELLEE
.
O P I N I O N
Godda r d, P. J .
I n t hi s s ui t , t h e Pl a i nt i f f s e e ks a de t e r mi na t i on t ha t
h e o wn s a r i ght - of - wa y f r om hi s pr ope r t y l oc a t e d i n t he Four t h
Di s t r i c t of Ha nc oc k Count y ove r t he a dj oi ni ng pr ope r t y of t he
De f e nd a nt s .
The Tr i a l Cour t f ound i n f a vor of t he Pl a i nt i f f ,
r e s u l t i ng i n t hi s a ppe a l , whi c h r a i s e s t he f ol l owi ng i s s ue s :
1. Di d t he Tr i a l Cour t e r r i n f a i l i ng t o f i nd t ha t
t he we i ght of t h e e vi de nc e pr e ponde r a t e d t ha t
t he e a s e me nt o f t he domi na nt e s t a t e ha d be e n
a ba ndone d.
2. Di d t he Tr i a l Co ur t e r r i n f a i l i ng t o f i nd t ha t
t he we i ght of t he e vi de nc e pr e ponde r a t e d i n a
f i ndi ng t ha t t he e a s e me nt of t he domi na nt e s t a t e
ha d be e n a dve r s e l y pos s e s s e d by t he owne r s of t he
s e r vi e nt e s t a t e a nd t hus t e r mi na t e d.
3. Di d t he Tr i a l Cour t e r r i n f a i l i ng t o f i nd t ha t
t he we i ght of t h e e vi de nc e pr e ponde r a t e d i n a
f i ndi ng t ha t a n a t t e mpt e d a dve r s e pos s e s s i on of
t he domi na nt e s t a t e ' s e a s e me nt ha d c omme nc e d mor e
t ha n s e ve n ( 7) ye a r s pr i or t o t he f i l i ng of
pl a i nt i f f ' s s ui t t hus ba r r i ng pl a i nt i f f ' s s ui t
pur s ua nt t o t he pr ovi s i ons of Te nn. Code Ann. §
28- 2- 103.
The de e d whe r e i n t he Pl a i nt i f f a c qui r e d t he r i ght - of -
wa y h e c l a i ms a nd pr i or de e ds i n hi s c ha i n of t i t l e a r e a s
f o l l ows :
1. N. T. Ba ke r a nd wi f e t o L. D. La ws on, da t e d M r c h 19, 193 1 ,
a
c o n t a i n e d t he f ol l owi ng l a ngua ge : " Pa r t i e s of t he f i r s t pa r t i s
[ s i c ] t o f ur ni s h pa r t y of t he s e c ond pa r t a La ne r oa d out of
t he m.
2. No r a Ba ke r a nd wi f e t o L. D. La ws on, da t e d De c e mbe r 1, 19 3 2 ,
c o n t a i n e d t he f ol l owi ng l a ngua ge : " Nor a Ba ke r a nd Lul a Ba ke r
d e e d s L. D. La ws on a nd wi f e a r oa d out ove r t he i r l a nd t o publ i c
r oa d. "
3. L. D. La ws on t o Kyl e Si z e mor e a nd wi f e , da t e d Nove mbe r 27 ,
1 9 4 3 , c onve ye d pr ope r t y a c qui r e d by pr e vi ous de e ds f r om Ba ke r .
No r i g h t - of - wa y wa s me nt i one d, a l t hough t he de e d doe s c ont a i n a
" h e r e di t a me nt a nd a ppur t e na nc e " c l a us e .
2
4. Ky l e Si z e mor e a nd wi f e t o Ros c oe Ki ns l e r , da t e d M r c h 24,
a
1945. No r i ght - of - wa y wa s me nt i one d, a l t hough t he de e d doe s
c on t a i n a " h e r e di t a me nt a nd a ppur t e na nc e " c l a us e .
5. Ro s c oe Ki ns l e r a nd wi f e t o Euge ne Si z e mor e , da t e d Apr i l 6 ,
1956. No r i ght - of - wa y wa s me nt i one d, a l t hough t he de e d doe s
c on t a i n a " h e r e di t a me nt a nd a ppur t e na nc e " c l a us e .
6. Eu ge ne Si z e mor e t o Kyl e Si z e mor e a nd wi f e , da t e d De c e mbe r 7,
1962. No r i ght - of - wa y wa s me nt i one d, nor doe s t he de e d c ont a i n a
" h e r e di t a me nt a nd a ppur t e na nc e " c l a us e .
7. Ky l e Si z e mor e a nd wi f e t o M c ha e l C. Hi c kma n a nd wi f e , da t e d
i
J u l y 1 5 , 1991, a l s o c onve yi ng " a ny r i ght , t i t l e a nd i nt e r e s t
wh i c h t he y [ t he gr a nt or s ] ma y ha ve t o a ny e a s e me nt s or r i ght s - o f -
wa y b e n e f i t i ng t he a bove - de s c r i be d pr e mi s e s . "
I t wi l l be not e d t ha t t he de e ds numbe r 3, 4, 5 a nd 6 d o
n o t me n t i on t he r i ght - of - wa y. The Tr i a l Cour t de t e r mi ne d t ha t
t h e r i g ht - of - wa y pa s s e d by vi r t ue of t he he r e di t a me nt a nd
a p p u r t e na nt c l a us e a nd no que s t i on i s ma de a s t o t hi s poi nt . We
d o n o t e t ha t de e d numbe r s i x doe s not ha ve a he r e di t a me nt a nd
a pp u r t e na nt c l a us e . But , be c a us e i t i s t he ge ne r a l r ul e t ha t
" u p o n c onve ya nc e of pr ope r t y t he l a w i mpl i e s a gr a nt of a l l
i n c i d e n t s r i ght f ul l y be l ongi ng t o t ha t pr ope r t y a t t he t i me of
t h e c on ve ya nc e whi c h wa s e s s e nt i a l t o t he f ul l a nd pe r f e c t
e n j o y me nt of t he pr ope r t y, " Bi s hop v. Vi l l a ge of Br ookf i e l d , 42 5
N.E. 2 d 1113 ( I l l . App. 1981 ) , a nd be c a us e no que s t i on i s ma de a s
t o t hi s p oi nt e i t he r , we wi l l not i c e i t no f ur t he r .
3
Our r e a di ng of t he r e c or d, i nc l udi ng t he Tr i a l Cour t ' s
me mo r a n dum opi ni on, pe r s ua de s us t ha t t hi s i s a n a ppr opr i a t e c a s e
f o r a f f i r ma nc e unde r Rul e 10( a ) of t hi s Cour t . I n r e a c hi ng t h i s
c o n c l u s i on, we f i nd t ha t t he e vi de nc e doe s not pr e ponde r a t e
a g a i n s t t he Tr i a l J udge ' s f i ndi ngs of f a c t , a nd t ha t hi s
c o n c l u s i ons of l a w ba s e d t he r e on a r e a ppr opr i a t e .
Not wi t hs t a ndi ng our a f f i r ma nc e unde r Rul e 10( a ) , we
d e e m i t a ppr opr i a t e t o br i e f l y a ddr e s s t wo poi nt s ma de by t he
De f e n d a nt s . Fi r s t , a s t o t he f e nc e t he y c ont e nd e nc l os e d t he i r
p r o p e r t y f or t he pr e s c r i pt i ve pe r i od a nd t he r e by e xt i ngui s he d t h e
r i gh t - o f - wa y c l a i me d b y t he Pl a i nt i f f , i t a ppe a r s t ha t t he f e n c e
wa s n o t c ons t r uc t e d, ma i nt a i ne d, or us e d i n a f a s hi on t ha t wou l d
e x t i n g u i s h t he Pl a i nt i f f ' s r i ght s . I nde e d, t he r e i s pr oof t ha t
t h e ma i n pur pos e of t he f e nc e wa s t o c onf i ne c a t t l e .
The r e i s a no t r e s pa s s i ng s i gn ne a r t he publ i c r oa d i n
c l o s e p r oxi mi t y t o a c e me t e r y. The De f e nda nt s di d pe r mi t f a mi l y
me mb e r s of t hos e bur i e d t o vi s i t t he c e me t e r y, a s i s r e qui r e d
u n d e r o ur c a s e l a w. Hi ne s v. St a t e , 126 Te nn. 1, 149 S. W 105 8
.
( 1911) . Howe ve r , t he y a l s o pe r mi t t e d M . Ki ns l e r a nd hunt e r s t o
r
t r a v e r s e t he i r p r ope r t y. I n t hi s r e ga r d, Edi t h Ba ke r t e s t i f i e d
a s f o l l ows :
Q Ri ght . Now, M . Rhe a a s ke d you a bout di d you
r
mi nd M . Ki ns l e r c omi ng a c r os s you, wa l ki ng.
r Do you
a l l ow pe opl e t o wa l k up a nd down your pr ope r t y?
A Ye a h, t he r e ' s a l ot of pe opl e go i n t he r e a nd
I s a y not hi ng.
4
I t i s a ppa r e nt f r om t he r e c or d t ha t t he s i gn wa s
" mo r e h onour ' d i n t he br e a c h t ha n t he obs e r va nc e . "
For t he f or e goi ng r e a s ons t he j udgme nt of t he Tr i a l
Co u r t i s a f f i r me d a nd t he c a us e r e ma nde d f or c ol l e c t i on of c os t s
b e l o w. Cos t s of a ppe a l a r e a dj udge d a ga i ns t t he De f e nda nt s a nd
t he i r s ur e t y.
_______________________________
Hous t on M Godda r d, P. J .
.
CONCUR:
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _________________________
Ch a r l e s D. Sus a no, J r . , J .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __________________ ______
W l l i a m H. I nma n, Sr . J .
i
5